Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Alt solves – Feminism is the only solution to the continuum of violence. Overthrow of the patriarchy is key to preventing nuclear war.

Eschle 13 (Catherine, University of Strathclyde, “Gender and the Subject of (Anti)Nuclear Politics: Revisiting Women's Campaigning against the Bomb”, 2013, International Studies Quarterly Vol. 57, No. 4 (December 2013), https://www.jstor.org/stable/24014644, pd)

However, women's antinuclear activism, and indeed nuclear politics more generally,4 has faded from the pur¬view of gender and security studies in recent years. This is problematic, in the first place because it means femi¬nist IR scholars have paid negligible attention to post-Cold War nuclear developments. While it could be argued this simply reflects the demobilization of women's antinuclear campaigning in the United States and UK with the end of the Cold War and the corresponding decline of the threat posed by the nuclear arms race, feminist IR scholarship has long contested such a straightforward empiricist reading of what counts as wors¬thy of research. In any case, nuclear weapons did not dis¬appear in the 1990s and nor did campaigning against them, as we are reminded by an important but neglected body of feminist work on/aligned with critical responses to the 1997 Indian nuclear tests (e.g., Oza 2006; Das 2007; Chowdhry No date).5 The failure more generally in gender and security studies to engage with such develop¬ments serves not only to fix women's antinuclear cam- paigning in a particular form and to a particular moment, but also to aid the naturalization of nuclear weapons in the post-Cold War world. An additional problem resulting from the decline of ongoing critical engagement with nuclear politics in gender and security studies is that the 1980s Cold War activism of such key initial influence now tends to be perceived in rather simplistic and even stereotyped ways. On the one hand, the rare mentions of nuclear politics in recent over¬views of gender and security studies imply a rather idealized view, relying as they do on a truncated version of the narra¬tive by Enloe and Sylvester et al. about Greenham women stepping into agency in IR, without critically re-examining the original texts or revisiting the evidence (Blanchard 2003:1294, 1302; Sjoberg 2009:197, note 84; Shepherd 2010a,b:78-9).6 The cumulative result is the romanticiza¬tion of the figure of the Cold War woman antinuclear cam¬paigner as a kind of feminist warrior who has now passed into the history books. On the other hand, in gender and security studies more generally, these same campaigners have been effectively demonized. With feminist IR scholars forced to confront misreadings of their own project as bio¬logically determinist by the mainstream of IR (see Tickner 1999; Shepherd 2010a), and with the rising popularity in the field of antiessentialist poststructuralist approaches, initial anxieties about women's peace politics have been strongly reinforced and attention has swung sharply in the opposite direction, toward investigations of the role of women as gender-destabilizing agents of political violence. There is an implicit assumption here that the Cold War anti¬nuclear activist is intrinsically pacific and gender-conserva-tive, the nemesis of feminist IR rather than its lost hope. As Tina Managhan has indicated (2007), however, such an assumption can and should be scrutinized. In line with Managhan, my starting point in this article is the proposition that an antiessentialist, poststructural¬ist-influenced methodology, far from necessitating the avoidance of women's antinuclear activism, can illumi¬nate it in fresh and interesting ways. Recent systematiza¬tions of this methodology in gender and security studies are set out in part one, along with the parameters of my empirical research. I then go on in part two to identify the "basic discourses" in circulation among women cam¬paigners against nuclear weapons in the United States and UK in the later Cold War period, each offering differently gendered constructions of the political subject mobilized in antinuclear struggle. In the third and final part of the article, I explore the ways in which these discourses are reproduced and reconfigured in the post-Cold War texts of Helen. Caldicott, in the United States, and Angie Zelter, in the UK. In so doing, I argue that there were multiple figures of the antinuclear campaigner circulating in Cold War women's activism and that new subjectivities are emerging in contemporary writing in ways that reflect and reproduce the shift from a Cold War to a post-Cold War context and the differing political environments of the United States and UK. I conclude that gender and security scholars ought therefore to revi¬sit fixed, unitary assumptions about the identities of women antinuclear campaigners, as one element in a broader, critical reengagement with the gendered dimen¬sions of nuclear politics. I close by suggesting some future lines of enquiry for such an undertaking, with The literature in IR combining poststructuralism and feminism is heterogeneous and rapidly expanding, but it is specifically the recent methodological recommenda¬tions with regard to gender and security studies devel¬oped separately by Lene Hansen and Laura J. Shepherd that I am interested in here. For these scholars, the sub-stantive focus of poststructuralist-influenced feminist enquiry should be on the discursive construction of gen¬dered subjects in global politics. Thus, Hansen states, " [t]he relationship between identity and foreign policy is at the center of poststructuralism's research agenda" (2006:1), while for Shepherd it is her specifically feminist "curiosity about 'the concept, nature and practice of gender"' and the ways in which "gender configures boundaries of subjectivity" in IR that drives her research (Shepherd 2008a:3, citing Zalewski). To conceive of gen¬dered selfhood as discursively constructed is to see it as "existing only insofar as it is continually rearticulated and uncontested by competing discourses" (Hansen 2006:6). Defined as systems of meaning and representa¬tion, discourses are claimed to "fix" self-understandings and interpretations of the world, and thus to reproduce power relations (Shepherd 2008a:20-3), albeit always tem¬porarily and in incomplete ways. We are thus enjoined to enquire into "multiple and competing discourses about gender ... and security ... [which] articulate specific sub¬jects, ascribe identities to these subjects and position them in relation to each other" (Shepherd 2010b:76), thereby instantiating gendered relations of domination and resistance. As both Shepherd and Hansen make clear, the "discur¬sive ontology" (Hansen 2006:17) underpinning their approach is radically antiessentialist. In general terms, it entails rejection of the analytical utility of distinguishing between nondiscursive and discursive realms, and with this the possibility of enquiring into the material roots of tex¬tual representations, in favor of illuminating how material realities become interpreted as such (Hansen 2006:21-3; Shepherd 2008a:17-19). More specifically, this is an ontol¬ogy that goes beyond the argument in earlier second-wave feminism that the biological fixities of sex are distinct from and nondetermining of gendered identities and roles that are rather socially constructed and challengeable. A post¬structuralist-influenced feminist perspective necessitates rather a more thorough-going discursive constructionism in which the continual reenactment of the gender norms circulating in discourse is seen to shape and give meaning to concrete bodily differences. On this view, the chief task of the scholar bridging feminist and poststructuralist tradi¬tions should be to destabilize apparent certainties about both sex and gender rather than to make claims about or on behalf of gendered identities and thus reinforce power relations. In this light, my claim that Hansen and Shep¬herd's framework can help to illuminate antinuclear cam¬paigning by women needs some justification. There are two issues here that need disentangling. The first has to do with biological essentialism, and whether women's antinuclear activism and the study of it necessarily replicates the view that there are characteristic male and female traits, which are presocial or natural, and which determine immutable social and political outcomes. On this point, it should be recalled that the pioneering feminist IR writings mentioned above not only elaborated a critique of crass assumptions about the embodied subjectivities of women and men circulating in antinuclear discourses, but also lauded certain enactments of antinuclear campaigning as destabilizing of gender certainties, most notably at Green-ham Common. Moreover, as Managhan's more recent study of campaigners at Greenham and elsewhere demonstrates (2007), even when biologically essentialist identities are mobilized, they may have subversive political results.? Managhan concludes that the tactical effects of such identi¬ties should be subjected to careful empirical investigation from a poststructuralist-feminist perspective, rather than assumed a priori to be problematic (2007:646). By implica¬tion, their discursive construction merits critical scrutiny, rather than dismissal or avoidance. A second and more serious issue arises, however, if we accept the premise that a focus on women's antinuclear campaigning necessarily rests on an essentialist approach to the gendered subject in more general terms—assuming fixed, stable entities called women who exist prior to, and who are productive of, discourses and texts. Yet this pre¬mise too is contestable. Many poststructuralist feminists have argued on political grounds that it is possible to maintain a deconstructive analytical approach toward gen¬der while simultaneously pursuing an empirical focus on women, in an effort to avoid "complicity with mainstream efforts to 'write women out of IR" ' (Managhan 2007:644, citing Sylvester). In this vein, such scholars have combined "elements of skepticism, particularly about the social formation of subjects, with elements of a standpoint femi¬nism that has us acknowledging and interpreting what subjects say" (Sylvester 1994:52). Others have sought to develop a more theoretically consistent justification for their focus on women as subjects. Alison Stone, for one, has reinterpreted Butler as implying that "women" have "a history, a genealogy, a 'line of descent"' (2005:5, citing Gatens; see also 2004:15-23), with gender identities, how-ever, fleeting and unstable crystallizing in a layering pro¬cess through which past constructions leave their traces on what follows: "All women thus become located within an ongoing chain of practice and reinterpretation, which brings them into complex filiations with one another" (Stone 2004:19). As Shepherd concludes (2008a:4), such a view "allows for research that investigates the ways in which 'women' as subjects and objects act, speak, write and represent themselves, are represented, written about, spoken about and acted on" 8-including, one assumes, within the context of antinuclear discourses. After all, these have long been the site for the (self-)construction of feminized subjectivities in oppositional relation to the masculinized nuclear state, albeit largely within white, Western, middle-class parameters. So how, more concretely, should such research on women antinuclear campaigners be conducted? Hansen and Shepherd imply that written texts offer a particularly fruitful starting point, as sites in which discourses about gendered subjects are circulated and in which instances or practices of gendered representation are embodied (Shepherd 2008a:24-5). While neither author focuses entirely on the written word, also examining visual imagery and the body (Hansen 2000:300-305; 2007; Shepherd 2008a:24; 2008b), their stress on systems of representation and meaning-making nonetheless goes hand-in-hand with an emphasis on "the analytical centrality of language" (Shepherd 2008a:3) as "articulated in written and spoken text" (Hansen 2006:2). In the case of antinuclear politics, such an emphasis presents a useful empirical alternative to the mass mobilizations and embodied practices that so caught the attention of Enloe et al.9 These may continue to enjoy a nostalgic recirculation in the field of gender and security studies, but are no longer characteristic of antinu¬clear campaigning in the United States and UK today. For advice on text selection, Hansen is particularly help¬ful. Key to her schema is the poststructuralist assumption about the "intertextuality" of discourse, that is, the view that "texts build their arguments and authority through references to other texts," often across the boundaries of particular genres and across space and time, shifting the contours and nodes of a discourse as they do so (Hansen 2006:8, see also 55-72). She develops several models of intertextuality, the first focused on official discourse and documents, the second examining also wider foreign pol¬icy debates, and a third including either representations in popular culture, or the more "marginal political dis¬courses" of social movements and academic commentary (2006:59-64). All three models entail a preliminary focus on primary texts with the researcher then moving outward to secondary sources and conceptual histories, paying close attention to the rhetorical structures typical of the different genres examined (Hansen 2006:52-4, 65-72). The selection of texts for Hansen also depends on the temporal framing of a particular investigation (whether it examines a singular moment, historical development over time, or compares different time periods) and the num¬ber or type of "Selves" being studied, as well as on consid¬erations of textual clarity, popularity, authority, and availability (2006:73-87).10 Having thus identified a field of texts, the researcher should identify within them a handful of "basic discourses" that serve to structure politi¬cal discussion and imaginative possibilities (Hansen 2006:51-2). Then "one might subsequently (re)turn to a detailed study of the articulations of identity and policy within particular texts ... and situate them inside the con¬text of the larger political debate" (Hansen 2006:52). Shepherd focuses her methodological arguments more on techniques of textual analysis. She outlines two steps in this regard, the first focusing on the "rhetorical sche¬mata" of a text and involving a search for the linguistic structures that provide a sense of order in texts, thus constructing the meaning of the concepts ... In the identifica¬tion of representational practices specific to gender, for exam¬ple, I look for instances of gendered identities described "as" or "like", statements about gendered identities that can be problematized, and emphasis on aspects of gender provided by placement within the text. (Shepherd 2008a:30)” The second step involves an analysis of "predica¬tion/subject positioning" (Shepherd 2008a:26, 30-1), which requires unpacking both claims made about the gendered attributes of a person or thing by examining the associated adjectives and other descriptive words or qualifiers, and its position in relation to claims in the text about other persons or things. This chimes with Hansen's claim that a deconstructive reading illuminates identity construction in terms of a "process of linking," whereby a positive series of signifiers are connected to a particular subject, and a "process of differentiation" whereby signs gain their meaning from explicit or implicit contrast with their opposite (2006:19-21). As Hansen reminds us, the researcher should consider not only how discursive stabil¬ity is achieved, but also "instabilities and slips" in the articulation of relationships between identities (2006:42).12 These methodological arguments underpin the dis¬course analysis of antinuclear women's campaigning in the United States and UK that I present in the rest of the article. In Hansen's terms, this is a single Self enquiry, focusing on gendered constructions of the antinuclear activist. With regard to its temporal framing, it is the recent historical development of this Self which is under review, from the 1980s to the present. And with regard to its underlying model of intertextuality, my study examines the "marginal political discourses" of social movement activists, as well as academic commentary about them. In what follows, my reading of the material from and on activist circles in the UK and United States in the 1980s, ranging from pamphlets to academic books to Web documents, seeks to outline the "basic discourses" in circulation in this period, each mobilizing rival concep¬tions of gendered subjectivity and thus of the antinuclear campaigner. Turning to the post-Cold War period, in which the discursive field is sparser with little secondary commentary, I focus on texts by two well-known cam¬paigners that I suggest serve as sites of authoritative meaning-making among activists. A detailed deconstruc¬tion of the rhetorical structure and predicates in these texts is undertaken in order to expose continuities and shifts in the gendered constructions of the earlier period. Revisiting Cold War Discourses With the revival of the Cold War in the early 1980s and the accompanying resurgence of the peace movement around the world, and in the wake of the second wave of feminism, larger numbers of women than ever before mobilized against nuclear weapons. A new generation of all-women groups and women-led actions was launched: The United States, for example, saw the emergence of WAND—Women's Action for Nuclear Disarmament (Cal-dicott 1997:296-9)—and "the Ribbon," which involved 20,000 women and their male supporters wrapping embroidered cloth around the Pentagon (Pershing 1996). Moreover, many women did not confine them¬selves to ostensibly feminine or civil modes of political organizing, instead advocating changes in gender rela¬tions and participating in the revived direct action wing of the movement (Gusterson 1996:193-7, 213-4; Wittner 12 Shepherd advocates these strategies within the context of a Derridean double reading (2008a:28). This seems to be particularly suitable as a way of destabilizing texts that have ossified interpretations with wide authority. It may be, however, less helpful in initial efforts to uncover and unpack marginal political discourses. 2000). It is in this context that "Women's Pentagon Action" organized dramatic demonstrations and block¬ades, for example (Women's Pentagon Action 1982; Linton and Whitham 1989), and that the women's peace camp phenomenon arose. Women made their homes at Seneca Falls and Puget Sound in the United States (Paley 1989; Russell 1989a; Krasniewicz 1992) and at various nuclear bases across Europe, with Greenham Common camp in the UK remaining the earliest, largest, and most well-known example (Cook and Kirk 1983; Roseneil 1995, 2000; Hipperson 2005). Several basic discourses about gender and nuclear weapons helped structure this wave of mobilization. Such plurality has already been noted by academic commenta¬tors beyond IR: In the course of Hugh Gusterson's eth¬nography of the Livermore nuclear weapons laboratory and protests against it (1996:212-3), Roseneil's (1995): 4-7) analysis of the camp at Greenham, and Helen Lidd¬ington's (1991:6-8) overview of the historical antecedents of British women's peace mobilization, three main narra¬tives are identified, with each author naming and describ¬ing the three in varying terms. On my reading, however, six discourses can be distinguished, each giving rise to a different construction of the antinuclear activist. These discourses can be labeled, respectively, maternalist, antivi-olence, culturalist, materialist, cosmopolitan, and cosmo¬logical in character. To begin with, the maternalist discourse brought the fig¬ure of the "Mother-in-Action" to the fore as the key pro¬tagonist in antinuclear struggle (e.g., Caldicott 1986:236). Speaking to and from the reproductive capacities of women, and insisting on the importance of the caring responsibilities and values traditionally associated with them (Ruddick 1989), this discourse implied that a nuclear-free world required the reevaluation, reimagin¬ing, and extension of maternal values and practices, and the displacement of their masculine corollaries (Caldicott 1986:241-2). It thus provided a positive justification for women-led or women-only organizing, encouraging those who had previously been marginalized because of their association with caring responsibilities to make connec¬tions across the private and public realm and become a force for broader political change. The workings of this discourse can be seen in the repeated emphasis placed on motherhood in explanations given by individuals for their mobilization (Roseneil 2000:46, 56-9; Pettit 2006:24-6); in the decorative and symbolic use of photo¬graphs of and drawings by children at protest events (Cook and Kirk 1983:31; Pershing 1996:128-9); and in the revitalization and reworking in activist circles of crafts associated with white, middle-class feminine domesticity such as embroidery (Krasniewicz 1992:60-6; Pershing 1996). One complementary discourse could be termed antivi¬olence, focused as it was on the problematic masculinity of the mainstream political subject and its connection to nuclear politics. Here, masculinity was constructed either as intrinsically pathological or as structurally corrupted: Either way, nuclear weaponry was contextualized on a continuum of violence perpetrated by men and male-dominated institutions—from rape, through domestic violence, to war (Held 1988; Russell 1989b). Within the terms of this discourse, the roots of violence were located in male sexuality and an associated drive to dom¬inate women, nonwhites, and nature (Kokopeli and La-key 1982:233, 235-8; Easlea 1983), and/or to a larger system or structure of "patriarchy" (Warnock 1982; Zanotti 1982), both explanations bearing witness to the influence of radical feminist analyses (Koen and Swaim 1980:1; Roseneil 1995:6-7; 2000:34). Although it was pri¬marily concerned to critique pronuclear male subjectiv¬ity, this discourse had the effect of elevating existing models of femininity and womanhood, providing as it did a negative justification for women-only organizing against the bomb (Held 1988; Rosenbluth and Russell 1989:302-5). A generalized figure of the "Woman" became by default the bearer of antinuclear struggle, a world without nuclear weapons requiring variously the feminization of male psychology, the overthrow of male power and patriarchal structures by women, or even limi¬tations on the numbers of men born into the world (Gearhart 1982). The culturalist discourse, in contrast, had a distinctive emphasis on the cultural construction of hegemonic male and female subjects and the need for and possibility of challenging both. This discourse again positioned patriar¬chy as the structural context in which nuclear weaponry gained its symbolic resonance, but there was also some consideration here of the ways in which patriarchy over¬lapped with and was constituted by power relations such as heterosexism and racism (Smith 1989). This enabled the articulation of a more complex, intersectional cri¬tique of the ways in which dominant forms of masculinity underpinned and fed into Cold War nuclearism (see e.g., Hartsock 1989; Spretnak 1989; Strange 1989). It also allowed for an avowedly feminist "queering" of dominant models of femininity (as embodied, for example, in maternal tropes and their association with middle-class, white, heterosexual respectability) and advocacy of alter-native ways of being (Snitow 1989; Roseneil 2000: chap¬ters 7 and 10). Overall, the discourse hinged on the construction of the "Reflexive Activist," whose critical self-examination and insistence on the stratified, change¬able character of gender, was positioned as central to the struggle for change. As Gusterson (1996:212) indicates, culturalist arguments pointed ultimately to a vision of the postnuclear world as "androgynous," with gender differ¬ence no longer playing a politically meaningful role. The fourth discourse was materialist in character, emphasizing the impact of nuclear weapons and their cost. Widespread in the antinuclear movement (Roseneil 1995:5), when circulating in and through women's activ¬ism, this discourse was frequently typified by a preoccupa¬tion with the impact of nuclear weapons on female bodies and lives. The implications for the reproductive system of exposure to radiation were highlighted, for example (Koen and Swaim 1980), or the deleterious effects on health, education, and welfare budgets of pri¬oritizing spending on weaponry (Beneria and Blank 1989; Omolade 1989). Gender figured in this discourse as dif¬ferential embodiment and lived social roles rather than as an identity or form of power. But, gender was also interpolated in a more abstract way, in terms of a repeated emphasis on the impact and cost of nuclear weapons on human bodies, relationships, and the natural world. The abstractions of nuclear rationality, as pursued by a technocratic, Western, masculine subject, were thus confronted by the concrete, embodied mode of reason¬ing historically associated with feminine (and also non¬white, non-Western) subjectivity, but here assumed to be more widely shared (Buirski 1983; Pettit 1983). In this way, the discourse constructed a feminized but potentially inclusive figure of the antinuclear activist we could call the "Empath." A very different tack was taken in the cosmopolitan dis-course, which focused on women's political exclusion from the defense and political establishments of the nuclear state. Epitomized in British author Virginia Woolf s antiwar rallying cry from an earlier age—"As a woman I have no country. As a woman I want no country. As a woman my country is the whole world"—this dis-course was rearticulated in the Cold War period by radi¬cal feminists who, assuming an undifferentiated commonality of experience of oppression among women worldwide, aspired to a global sisterhood rather than entry into male-dominated institutions." The sense of sisterly connection can be seen, for example, in accounts of the international character of Greenham and the soli¬darity actions that took place around the world (Cook and Kirk 1983:32, 62), as well as in critiques of the loyal¬ties and symbols of mainstream patriotism in both the UK and United States (e.g., Krasniewicz 1992:chapter 8). In addition, security was reenvisioned within the parame¬ters of this discourse in ways that made it more inclusive of women's experiences and transborder relationships. Militarism and the supposed protection it offered were subjected to critical scrutiny (Ruehl 1983; Thompson 1983; Wood 1983); the counterproductive character of violence was documented (Cook and Kirk 1983); and empathetic connections were forged with the ostensibly threatening "Other" (Porter 1983; Mooney 1983:5, 14). In such ways, this discourse reconfigured community and the methods used to protect it, rather than gender. It effectively contrasted a compromised male political sub¬ject in the form of the citizen or politician to an ethical female subject, the "Sister," who transcended geopoliti¬cal specificities. Finally, the cosmological discourse mobilized gendered imagery as part of its holistic conception of the universe and the role of humans within it. In its ecological variant, this discourse drew on a self-conscious ecofeminism (Epstein 1991:176-8; Alonso 1993:246-7) and was mani¬fested in claims about women's connectedness to the nat¬ural world (Salamone 1982; Women's Pentagon Action 1982), in critiques of a dualistic masculine worldview involving separation from and mastery over nature (Grif¬fin 1989; Strange 1989), and in the images of nature pep¬pering women's life stories, poetry, and other texts (Linton and Whitham 1989:186; Pettit 2006:24, 27). In its spiritual variant (Epstein 1991:chapter 5), the discourse gave rise to widespread Goddess iconography (McAllister 1982:ix; Jones 1989:201) and pagan/wiccan narratives and rituals (Epstein 1991:183-92; Krasniewicz 1992:53-60). The antinuclear activist was constituted here as a potent feminine figure, either "Earth Mother" or "Goddess," and urged to exert her powers to usher in an alternative future for the planet. Although it is helpful analytically to delineate these six basic discourses about gender and (anti)nuclear politics in Cold War women's activism, they and the identities they constructed should not be misunderstood as inter¬nally monolithic and sharply distinct from each other in their empirical instantiation. To begin with, the dis¬courses were internally heterogeneous and conflictual. There were rival articulations of a cosmological frame¬work, as I have shown, and also of maternalism, with women's caring capacity rooted sometimes in biologically determinist accounts of their physiology and thereby seen 13 Which is why I think Liddington is incorrect to label this discourse "equal rights." as eternal (Caldicott 1986), sometimes in their socially constructed caring roles and thereby envisioned as chang¬ing and changeable (Ruddick 1989).14 Moreover, the boundaries between discourses were permeable. Thus, cosmological visions resonated with maternalism in their reimagining of femininity while, to take another example, the antiviolence and culturalist discourses both pointed toward patriarchy as the structural context in which men and masculinity gained their power and women and femi¬ninity were subordinated and oppressed. Finally, even the most divergent discourses were not indelibly associated with antithetical political projects and political subjects, but rather offered overlapping and competing sources of meaning-making and identity construction within the same action or text. This is made very clear in detailed ethnographies of the women's peace camps (Krasniewicz 1992; Roseneil 1995, 2000). As I will show in the next part of the article, instability, porousness, and simultane¬ity continue to characterize the six discourses as they have recirculated in the post-Cold War period, along with some notable shifts in content and in the activist identi¬ties thereby produced.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.