Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

We solve the Aff’s impacts -- the core value of feminism is pacifism and the end of war. Hegemonic masculinity is key to violence.

Rodríguez-Galán 11 (Marta B, Associate Professor of Sociology/Anthropology & Public Health, Director Gerontology, Hegemonic Masculinity and Counter-hegemonic Feminist Discourses for Peace, Publish: St. John Fisher College.) JYC

The position of women condemning war as mothers has been the subject of much debate among feminists, a debate that probably traces its roots to old discussions of equality and difference feminism and interpretations of the roles of women within the family. Sara Ruddick and Jean Bethke Elshtain are among the pro-family feminists who have theorized about pacifist feminism (Elshtain, 1985; Ruddick, 1983). Ruddick proposed that “maternal thinking,” a way of being in the world based on the concept of “preservative love,” could present a counter ideology to a male dominated culture. Moreover, maternal thinking is not unique to women, nor to mothers, as both men and women and those without children can adopt a nurturing disposition and be socialized into maternal thinking (Ruddick, 1983). For this pacifist feminist, maternal thinking would represent the antithesis of violent masculinity. While opposed to war, Ruddick believes that there is no contradiction between being a feminist and defending the right of women to participate in the military, while at the same adopting a pacifist philosophy. In fact, the incorporation of women in the military as conscripts—not volunteers—could help to “pacify the forces,” as long as many of these women would help introduce maternal thinking. Moreover:

We acknowledge the existence of good causes and the necessity of some battles but claim that there are entirely or principally nonviolent ways of fighting them that are at least as effective as violence (the effectiveness of which is always exaggerated) and that these nonviolent solutions cost less morally, physically, and psychologically.2 

For Jean Elshtain (1985), while most feminists agree on the gendered nature of war and militarism, the majority of them support a realist or its modified version “just war theory” posture, both of which accept war as a legitimate or justifiable political instrument. This well-known proponent of peace feminist thought has critiqued realist feminists and just war theory feminists for failing to present a challenge to the Western discourse of war and politics. According to her provocative argument, feminists must not dismiss all notions of traditional femininity, such as maternal thinking. Instead they must appropriate these images and transform them (Elshtain, 1985). Simultaneously, she also criticizes cultural feminists who assume— consciously or not—a “just war theory” position. Just war theory traces its roots to St. Augutine’s Christian political thought, which argued for the justification of war in some cases using a gendered imagery that represented women as “beautiful souls” in need of protection and men as chivalric “just warriors.” According to Elshtain, many cultural feminists who invoke the “female principle” as ontologically superior to masculinism continue the Augustian tradition of the beautiful soul. While rejecting these romanticized images of femininity, Elshtain also accuses the feminist movement of being “matrophobic” and attempts to restructure political consciousness based upon the implications of “maternal thinking” in a new kind of feminist political thought that she calls “social feminism” (Elshtain, 1985). This position is at odds with that espoused by first wave feminists –Kate Millen, Betty Friedan, Juliet Michell, Shulamith Fireston and others—who had sought to demystify the family and motherhood in order to achieve equality with men. Indeed, the role of women in the family continues to be the subject of much controversy within the feminist movement (Dietz, 1985). Mary Dietz points out some of the pitfalls of the maternal thinking argument: 

Women who do not venture beyond the family or participate in practices beyond mothering cannot attain an adequate understanding of the way politics determines their own lives. Nor can they –as mothers or creatures of the family—help transform a politics that stands in conflict with maternal values. The only consciousness that can serve as a basis for this transformation and so for the sort of active citizenry that Elshtain wishes to promote is a distinctly political consciousness steeped in a commitment to democratic values, participatory citizenship and egalitarianism3 . 

Mary Dietz and other “civic” feminist scholars advocate the peace politics of feminism but disavow its connections to motherhood and maternal thinking. In their opinion, it is feminist political consciousness rather than femaleness or mothering that makes women more pacific. Hence, both female and male feminists should be more inclined towards pacifism. Nonetheless, the fact that women are more likely to be feminists explains the gender gap on attitudes towards war (Cook and Wilcox, 1991; Dietz 1985). 

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.