Hegemonic masculinity leads to militarization, dehumanization, and expansion. These cause war and mass violence.
Wojnicka 22- (Katarzyna, Associate Professor of Sociology, Editor-in-chief for NORMA: International Journal for Masculinity Studies, “NORMA, Volume 17, Issue 2 (2022), Publisher: Taylor & Francis Online)
Ukrainians awoke on the 24th of February 2022 to find themselves in a conflict over which many had been dreading but which almost as many had also thought impossible. Putin’s invasion of Ukraine has also meant that we, non-Ukrainian Europeans, find ourselves in a time in which the term ‘crisis’ has taken on a much more direct presence. After over 20 years in which the so-called ‘War on Terror’ wrought death and destruction ‘elsewhere’, the actual conflict between sovereign nation-states, with the prospect of spilling over into yet another European war involving multiple nation-states is now a reality. The horrors of war are happening closer to our own countries than many of us have experienced in our lifetimes.
The gender dynamics of the invasion of Ukraine are impossible to ignore. War re-installs gendered demarcation lines that many of us, naively, thought was a relic from the past. Masculinity is mobilized as a rhetorical figure and symbolic resource in the brutal reality for all these young men and women that have to go into a war declared by older men. In the character of the fascist strongman who has become a cult figure in the global far-right, we can see someone who has been valued at home and abroad precisely for his compensatory masculinism (Löffler, Luyt, & Starck, ) as well as ridiculed in Western media (Wiedlack, ). Then there is the resilient, David-esque figure who has been championed for his intransigence and refusal to give up in the face of insurmountable odds. Caught in-between these political leaders are the military conscripts of all genders who are putting their lives at risk, as well as women and children who are being forced to flee as a result of imperialist aggression. On social media, people are celebrating the loss of human life and glorifying militarist responses from political leaders whilst those of us in Finland and Sweden find ourselves closer to NATO membership than at any point during our intertwined histories. It is a new formative moment that most of us wish could have been avoided.
We at NORMA have been sickened and appalled by what we have all seen in the last 2 months. Critical studies on men and masculinities could not be more relevant for analyzing the intentions and the appeal of political leaders as well as the consequences of their decisions. Two of NORMA’s recent special issues were focused on political masculinities and militarized masculinities but neither we, the editors, nor possibly the special issue editors (Christensen & Kyed, ; Löffler et al., ) could have foreseen how timely these related issues would be. Indeed, militarism and the responses to militarism must be understood in terms of characteristics we tend to ascribe to masculinity/masculinities. As Christensen and Kyed (, p. 1) highlight ‘the male soldier, represented as the hero and the warrior, is one of the most fundamental representations of masculinity’ (see also Enloe, ). We see this playing out today in constant coverage of the invasion as well as in the portrayal of political leaders in the years prior.
In the last decade, a handful of social scholars analyzing the nexus between Putin’s masculinity and his governance style have come to an agreement that he represents ‘an alpha male in the international arena’ (Romanets, ), a radical version of hypermasculinity, machismo or masculinist type of gender performance (Novitskaya, , p. 160), which eventually can be described as a perfect example of hegemonic masculinity (Connell, ). This is exemplified in the images of Putin presenting physical strength, e.g. portraying him as stripped to the waist while riding a horse and being captured on film while engaged in typical ‘male’ activities such as fishing, riding a Harley-Davidson, playing hockey, operating a firefighter’s helicopter, fighter jet or shooting, as well as doing judo (Romanets, ). These, combined with his hyper-heterosexuality, unlimited power over Russian society, as well as the need to subordinate all others (men, women and children) leave few doubts, that not only he can be seen as a typified personification of hegemonic masculinity but also that this particular type of gender ideology is one of the main factors that have led to the current invasion of Ukraine. According to Riabov and Riabova (), Putin’s regime is based on creating images of national masculinity and attributing masculine characteristics to the country, where militarization and heterosexualisation are the most profiled elements, and their ultimate embodiment have been Russian ‘war with terrorism’ (Riabov & Riabova , p. 45); other acts of political violence ‘(…) such as the 2008 war with Georgia, the annexation of Crimea in 2014, continuing attempts to destabilise Ukraine through the military intervention in its Eastern territories, and the controversial intervention in Syria’ (Novitskaya, , p. 314) and finally, the current invasion of Ukraine. As Wiedlack () noted, the portrayal of Putin as a figure for homophobic ridicule in US Media affirmed Putin’s status in Russia as a bearer of hegemonic masculinity by seeking to undermine this very public presentation of hypermasculinity.