Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Traits associated with masculinity are glorified and encouraged in military institutions, specifically violence

Henry 17 – Marsha, Associate Professor in the Department of Gender Studies at the London School of Economics and Political Science, “Problematizing military masculinity, intersectionality and male vulnerability in feminist critical military studies”, 2017, Informa UK limited, “http://eprints.lse.ac.uk/79648/1/Henry_Problematizing%20military%20masculinity_2017.pdf”

First, two key works have influenced the development of the concept of militarised masculinity and masculinities, and I acknowledge the specific contribution of two scholars. First Enloe has encouraged scholars to pay attention to the process of militarisation rather than focus narrowly on the ideology of militarism in her ground-breaking work on gender and international relations (Enloe 1991). In this work, Enloe develops further her concept of military masculinity when thinking about the ways in which military institutions are sites of the production of both culture and gender. Here she suggests that gender roles are given opportunity and space to play out, as well as to produce extremes---hyper military masculinity being one example. She also points to the ways in which certain forms of martiality (exclusively associated with men) is hyper-valued within most societies and how this contributes to the glorification of men’s participation in violence and war. In thinking about military masculinity, it is not surprising then that feminist scholars such as Enloe, began to think about the process of socialising that takes place in militarised settings (Enloe 1983, 2000). Thus the social, constructed, contingent, fluid and multiple ways in which individuals are produced as gendered subjects, given a prescribed set of gendered roles, and how those individuals identify themselves, and perform gender within military institutions and settings has been afforded critical attention (Enloe 2000, Whitworth 2004, Higate 2003; Parpart 2015; Zalewski and Parpart 1998; Belkin 2012). Early conceptualisations of military masculinity focussed almost exclusively on formal military settings---that is on national and state militaries. In general, military masculinity tends to be utilised in a range of feminist scholarship as a ‘thing’ that is carried, possessed or produced as an object through military socialisation and found within military culture (except Enloe 2003). As such, it was seen, in the early inception, as a singular form of gendered practice---following on from Connell’s early conceptualisations of hegemonic masculinity (Connell 1987, 1995, 2005). Of course the ways in which military masculinity has evolved as a conceptual lens and a site for empirical research means that there is no single definition, nor is it confined to feminist theorists alone. Military institutions now consistently analyse their own gendered and racialised cultures---although very often this is for improving efficiency and effectiveness in military operations. Further theorisations include that of Dudink, Hagemann and Tosh (2004) Parpart and Zalewski (2008) Belkin (2012), Whitworth (2004); Masters (2005); and Duncanson (2009, 2013, 2015). However, it was Paul Higate’s edited collection (2003) that took up the challenge of further theorising military masculinity. In particular the work engages with Connell and other masculinity scholars and succeeded in pluralising militarised masculinity. This work expanded the concept in such a way that scholars no longer talked about masculinity within military settings as something culturally specific, socially entrenched, pathological, or always already there in the same form--- rather Higate’s collection emphasises at how men [sic] become ‘manly’ warriors through twin processes of gender and military socialisation (ed. Higate 2003). The 2003 collection suggests that it is difficult to simply place the military and masculinity (in an additive way) together---rather both are mutually constituting. At times, in analyses it is difficult to pinpoint which is more influential--- military culture or gender culture! Importantly, Higate’s collection began to pave the way for thinking about militarised masculinities in non-traditional contexts. Thus, work on masculinity amongst rebel groups, militias, gangs, thugs, terrorists and jihadis began to be developed within this sub-field (Amar 2013; Rommell 2016). This challenged the idea that military values only belonged to fields where there was a formal military setting. More contemporary work is concerned with the drone operator, the military lawyer, the conscious objector and so on (Tidy 2015, 2015a). These two tracks of argument have been absolutely crucial to the conceptualisation and use of the term militarised masculinity/masculinities. This is because militarised masculinities mean that the fluid nature of militarisation and masculine socialisation in these frames allows scholars to focus on masculinities in practice and discourse. Rather than using militarised masculinity as an explanation for various negative developments within military settings, scholars are encouraged to probe deeper into what militarised masculinities look like and how they come into being. For example, in Stern and Ericsson-Baaz’s study of perpetrators of sexual violence, they focus on the discourses of perpetrators of sexual violence in the DRC construct as to their different motivations for such acts of brutality (Ericsson-Baaz and Stern 2012). In their research, they pay attention to the narrative strategies used by men to construct and produce themselves as fearsome and honourable military men despite admitting to being part of the perpetration of violence. Similarly, Lomsky-Feder and Rappoport in their work on models of masculinity in the Israeli context demonstrate the influence of nation on men’s different constructions of masculinity (Lomsky-Feder and Rappoport 2003). Lomsky-Feder and Rappoport view masculinities as being produced hierarchically in one military context, and as being influenced by very different military experiences (Russia and Israel). Both of these scholars’ use of militarised masculinity provide us with a more complex account of what motivates men to commit violence (organised or otherwise) in certain contexts, rather than assuming that it is merely an unintended consequence or unintentional by product of male embodiment or male sex roles and military culture. Thus the work of Cynthia Enloe in challenging understandings of militarisation, and Higate’s edited collection on militarised masculinities was a catalyst for rethinking military masculinities and masculinities in conflict (Kirby and Henry 2012). This is turn led to the development of work examining a range of masculinities within militarised (and not only military) settings—in particular Belkin’s work Bring Me Men, was seminal in challenging the idea that military masculinity is a singular and homogenous outcome of military socialisation and/or military culture and that it is always constructed in opposition to femininity and/or heteronormativity. Titinuk’s challenge to narrow definitions of military masculinity (2012) went some way to challenge any tendency towards simplistic or pathological definitions by demonstrating that military organisations also revere various personal characteristics traditionally associated with femininity such as sacrifice, compassion and cooperation. Thus militarised masculinities are not constructed purely on the disavowal of all that is feminine or associated with women. This led to two further developments. The first was a minor interest in female military masculinities (Tasker 2011). Tasker used the portrayal of female soldiers in Hollywood films to reconceptualise military masculinity without the male body---influenced by Halberstam’s work on female masculinities more generally (Halberstam 1998). Tasker takes Halberstam’s conceptualisation of non-normative gender and sexuality is applied to female soldiers who are depicted as occupying a parodic, mimicking or inauthentic military masculinity. In the films Courage Under Fire and GI Jane, Tasker finds evidence of military masculine space where women are able to perform gender in both conventional and unconventional ways. Actress Demi Moore, for example, labours to shed her ‘femininity’ by shaving her head and wearing an undershirt traditionally seen as men’s attire, in order to be accepted as a legitimate soldier. Moore’s character is finally accepted as a legitimate man amongst her male military peers, after she demonstrates her ability to be ‘just like the men’ in her squad. This work contests the scope of military masculinities by insisting not only on their plurality, but by questioning the very constitution and production of masculinity as a social expression of gender. The other development is found in work examining both military femininity (Ombati 2015) and masculinity, as Dietrich does in her 2012 piece on militarisation in Peru, El Salvador and Colombia. This work, along with that of scholars such Myrttinen (2013); Parpart (2016); Maringira (2015) and Stachowitsch (2015) begins to pay attention to internal differences and inequalities amongst men. What these more recent works suggest is that the study of militarised masculinities has expanded considerably and draws on a range of concepts and theories. This is why it is unsurprising that intersectionality has appeared in the literature. Masculinity scholars have looked towards feminist theory for some time now, and in order to understand the complex theoretical terrain of military and militarised masculinities, scholars have turned to ‘classic’ texts, including that by Crenshaw and other intersectional theorists. As such, it is not surprising that the intersectional ‘turn’ should now make headway within the study of men, masculinities and the military

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.