Hegemonic masculinity sustains historical inequality
DiGioia, Amanda, 12 October 2020 “Duelling, the Russian Cultural Imagination, and Masculinity in Crisis” https://doi-org.proxy.lib.umich.edu/10.4324/9780429331459
Traditionally, the study of men has been called ‘history’, but there are also intersections between studying men and studying gender. For over thirty years, the study of gender has encompassed the study of both men and masculinities. Men and masculinities are shaped by differences of age, class, and ethnicity, and exist among other social differences (Kimmel et al., 2005, p. 3). There is also evidence that masculinity can be transgressed (Beasley, 2015; McGuffey & Rich, 1999; Surkis, 1996; Tsirigotis, 2017). However, toxic masculinity (and, by extension, duelling) is not transgressive; instead, it adheres to and upholds those norms.
Masculinity has been the subject of much previous scholarship, and contemporary masculinity scholarship is heavily influenced by a single theoretical framework established by Raewyn Connell. Connell’s theory acknowledges that while masculinities vary across time, culture, and individuals, there has been a practice (hegemonic masculinity) that legitimises men’s position as dominant in society (androcentrism), while subordinating women and men from marginalised groups (Connell, 1995). Hegemonic masculinity may explain why men maintain positions of power, because women, marginalised men (those in the LGBTIQA+ community, people of colour, Jewish men, etc.), and those of other genders are subsequently coded as female or women (Connell, 1995). An integral part of the continuing appeal of Connell’s theory is that the theory itself provides a critical feminist analysis of historically specific masculinities while at the same time recognising the various extents to which individual men contribute to its propagation. Finally, Connell notes that hegemonic masculinity is the currently accepted strategy in human societies, acknowledging that hegemonic masculinity can be challenged, changed, and usurped (Connell, 1995).
Some scholars argue that the theory behind hegemonic masculinity has become associated with ‘negative characteristics that depict men as unemotional, independent, nonnurturing, aggressive, and dispassionate’, which are then seen as the causes of criminal behaviour, while ignoring the ‘positive’ behaviour of men (Collier, 1998, pp. 1–29). Other scholars criticise the drift of hegemonic masculinity, suggesting that any contemporary trouble is now blamed on toxic masculinity (Martin, 1998). One academic argues that ‘defending gun ownership is a defence of hegemonic masculinity’ (Martin, 1998, p. 474), an equivalency that may serve as an example of what Collier (1998) deems an overreach. However, recent research has indicated that there is indeed a connection between hegemonic masculinity and carrying a concealed firearm, as part of the appeal of so doing is that it allows the man to identify with hegemonic masculinity through fantasies of violence, self-defence, or defending their spouse and/or children (Stroud, 2012, p. 216).