Alt creates a monolithic view of queer bodies rooted in Western, privileged frames- this recreates dangerous hierarchies, forces normative dichotomies and prevents institutional change-turns the k
Mizzi MEd 08
(Robert C, Queer Peace International, Journal of Gay & Lesbian Issues in Education, “Queer Global Education: Finding Me, Finding You,” 2008, Taylor and Francis//wyo-mm)
Additionally, Morland and Willox do not include formal education, which is a founding block of our anti-queer taboos and inhibitions. Addressing LGBT/Queer issues in education, however, is an intrinsic part of social and moral change. For instance, in rural Saskatchewan, a twelve-year old Two-Spirited youth is courageously attempting to attend and be successful at school in her/his preferred gender. The absence of culturally relevant material in the curriculum, support from educators, and a gender flexible state-controlled institution makes such efforts difficult. When discussing the shake-up of social and moral taboos, Queer Theory fails to acknowledge and analyze that some of our most severe battlegrounds are taking place within such institutions like this eighth grade rural Canadian classroom. Morland and Willox analyses what the closet door might be for different queers: Perhaps you become queer by being seen reading this book or Maybe you are hiding its cover behind Cosmopolitan or Men’s Health. Alternatively, if you are queer, are your actions queer enough? Are you in the closet or are you out and proud? (p. 1) Queer Theory sets the tone that being in the closet (whatever shape, size, colour or texture that closet door might be) is bad; being out is good. Paradoxically, this text on queer theory then perpetuates a binary position. In my work with Queer Peace International, I have worked with queers who are refugees, displaced persons, and/or live in a homophobic community. These individuals must remain in the closet in order to grow, remain strong, and ultimately survive. There, too, have been those who have “come out” but, when they didn’t fit into the foreign based LGBT culture, returned to the closet where they retained some form of normalcy and acceptance. There is a certain a-critical “promosexual” cultural viewpoint underlyingQueer Theory.It insufficiently addresses those on the periphery or those affected by North American or Western queer exports in different world regions and communities. The contributors call for acceptance and embracing plural identities and, although this book does present several realities, it does not venture outside of the white, middle/upper-class American psyche.Queer Theory lacks a post-colonial/globalization analyses that speaks to plural identities in developing world contexts that this book could have drawn from.