Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Hungary will not escalate against Russia

Coakley 22

[Amanda Coakley ; 3-22-2022; "The Exception to Europe's United Front Against Russia"; Time; https://time.com/6159342/european-union-russia-hungary/; accessed 7-22-2022; MT]

In a European Union that answered Russia’s invasion of Ukraine with an economic war against Moscow, Hungary stands apart. While Orban stopped short of vetoing E.U. sanctions on Russia, he has said Budapest will block any E.U. sanctions on Russian oil and gas, and refuted calls to stop the expansion of the Paks Nuclear Plant, which is being funded by Russia’s nuclear power company, Rosatom. Arguing that Hungarians should not be faced with higher bills because of energy sanctions, Orban believes he is skilled enough to navigate a relationship with Russian President Vladimir Putin.

That irks the European Union—which in many ways is nothing new. Over the course of Orban’s 12 year tenure, Brussels has been at odds with Hungary for its increasingly undemocratic tendencies, including weakening the country’s free press and undermining its independent judiciary. So fraught was Budapest’s relationship with the E.U. that in December 2020 the European Parliament approved a new “rule of law conditionality” mechanism that linked E.U. funds to member states’ respect for democracy.

But the Ukraine invasion brought a new measure of Orban’s defiance: Hungary now finds itself isolated even from Poland, the country that joined it in wreaking havoc on the E.U.’s fundamental values, including by jointly launching a legal challenge against the rule of law mechanism (their case was rejected by the European Court of Justice, the bloc’s top court, in early February).

Russia has long tested the limits of Poland and Hungary’s “illiberal alliance.” While Orban has courted Putin since before his return to power in 2010, the man often called Poland’s most powerful politician, Deputy Prime Minister Jarosław Kaczynski, has never ceased to wax lyrical about the threat the Kremlin poses to the West. When Russia annexed Crimea in March 2014, Orban offered no strong opinions on the conflict and only reluctantly supported the E.U.’s sanctions on Moscow, arguing that “Russia’s exclusion from Europe is not reasonable; security in the region can only be achieved with Russia.” Meanwhile, Poland stood firm in its support for Ukraine and called on Europe to take the Russian security threat seriously.

In the infamous Transylvania speech announcing Hungary in 2014 as an “illiberal state,” Orban also called Russia—along with China, Singapore, India, and Turkey—a model for Hungarian society. None of this sat well with Warsaw but it wasn’t until Putin himself visited Budapest in 2015 and was allowed to state his position on Ukraine that tensions between the two came to boiling point. When Orbán later visited Poland, Kaczynski, whose Law and Justice Party (known by the Polish initials PiS) was still in opposition, refused to meet him. Over time these frustrations faded as the focus between the two moved to undermining the E.U. But they were never forgotten—and now demonstrate how much of an outlier Orban has made Budapest in the largest European conflict since World War II.

Though Hungary has thrown open its eastern frontier to Ukrainians fleeing the Russian invasion, unlike Poland it has refused Kyiv lethal aid and prevented weapons to Ukraine from being transported via its territory. Once again Orban has framed Russian aggression in Ukraine as an issue beyond his jurisdiction and promoted so-called “strategic calmness.” With elections on April 3 and the Prime Minister likely to win his fourth consecutive term in office, his Fidesz party is campaigning on keeping Hungary “out of the war.” Hungary’s six-party united opposition has highlighted Fidesz’s close affiliations to the Kremlin, but that may not matter in Hungary’s rural heartlands where both support for Orban and fears of regional instability run strong.

“Every step Orbán takes ahead of the elections is focused on winning,” Pál Dániel Rényi, a Hungarian journalist and author tells TIME. “Hungary is heading into a massive recession, the Prime Minister is power obsessed, and he isn’t going to do anything that won’t work in his favour.” If the price is isolation even from Poland that appears to be fine with Orban. On March 23 Hungarian President János Áder was due to unveil a statue in the southern Polish town of Bochnia to mark Polish-Hungarian friendship day. His trip was reportedly postponed because Poland’s President Andrzej Duda didn’t want to appear alongside him, given Hungary’s ambiguous stance on the Russian invasion.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.