The UN works within international frameworks, more so than NATO
Fournier-Tombs ’21 (Eleonore, data scientist, researcher and author at United Nations University Institute Macau, “Towards a United Nations Internal Regulation for Artificial Intelligence, Published August 30, 2021, Accessed 7/13/2022, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/20539517211039493)
On 21 April 2021, the European Commission published a proposal for a regulation on artificial intelligence (AI) (European Commission, 2021), the first of its kind to attempt to integrate the multi-tentacled beast that is AI. The document enters into detail in terms of definitions and uses of the technologies, as well as very important sections on the forbidden uses of AI and high-risk activities, proposing that the latter go through an authorisation process much like a drug or a car would before being made available to the public. However, as set out in Article 2, the regulation does not apply to international organisations, regardless of whether they are operating in European Union (EU) territory. Naturally, the EU does not have jurisdiction over international organisations such as the United Nations, which is governed by international law (United Nations, 2021). The exclusion therefore does not come as a surprise but does point to a gap in the AI regulation, especially since technologies that are classified as forbidden or high risk for European citizens would presumably be also very risky for all other citizens, regardless of nationality. Furthermore, as explained by Bradford (2020) in The Brussels Effect, the EU is known to set regulatory precedents globally. It is therefore likely that the new regulation will have a ripple effect, which would reach many other countries. In that context, regulating at the United Nations itself would be an important way for the organisation to demonstrate its leadership on this important societal issue. The activities of the United Nations are regulated in a series of legal instruments in international law that have been developed since the drafting of the Charter of the United Nations (United Nations, 1945). The UN Charter sets out the role of the Secretary General, the General Assembly, and the Security Council, as well as the activities of UN Peacekeepers. Since 1945, there have been a few amendments to the Charter, as well as Security Council and General Assembly resolutions on issues that were not considered at the onset of the organisation. The United Nations itself is very likely to develop a convention on AI, which member countries would likely sign and possibly ratify (Garcia, 2020; ). However, such a document, like other United Nations conventions, would consist of a commitment by its member states to more ethical AI practices, rather than a regulation for the organisation itself to follow. This article therefore sets out the rationale for a United Nations Regulation for Artificial Intelligence, which is needed to set out the modes of engagement of the organisation when using AI technologies in the attainment of its mission. It argues that given the increasing use of AI by the United Nations, including in some activities considered high risk by the European Commission, a regulation is urgent. It also contends that rules of engagement for AI at the United Nations would support the development of ‘good artificial intelligence’1, by giving developers clear pathways for authorisation that would build trust in these technologies. Finally, it argues that an internal regulation would build upon the work in AI ethics and best practices already initiated in the organisation that could, like the Brussels Effect, set an important precedent for regulations in other countries. The United Nations’ artificial intelligence ecosystem AI technologies have, over the past decade, been increasingly used by United Nations agencies, funds and programs. Several research and development labs, including the United Nations Secretariat’s Global Pulse Lab (2021), United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR's) Jetson initiative (UNHCR, 2021), Innovation Labs (UNICEF, 2021) and United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) Centre for Humanitarian Data (OCHA, 2021a) have focused their work on developing AI solutions that would support the UN's mission, notably in terms of anticipating and responding to humanitarian crises. These research labs are largely composed of United Nations staff members and consultants trained in data science technologies. Many of the research labs have developed proofs of concept, which are yet to be integrated into the United Nations’ activities.2 They aim, for example, to explore the use of AI modelling in anticipating refugee arrivals (Jetson), predict coronavirus disease-2019 (COVID-19) cases in countries with ongoing humanitarian crises or better understand risks to the Sustainable Development Goals (Global Pulse). United Nations agencies have also used biometric identification to manage humanitarian logistics and refugee claims. For example, Population Registration and Identity Management Ecosystem (PRIMES) was launched in 2018 by UNHCR to provide a centralised platform for the management of refugee data. By the end of 2018, the biometrics of 7.1 million refugees were managed by the platform (UNHCR, 2019). The World Food Programme (WFP) has also used biometric identification in aid distribution to refugees, coming under some criticism in 2019 for its use of this technology in Yemen (Raftree and Steinacker, 2019). In parallel, however, the organisation has begun partnering with private companies that provide advanced analytical services. A notable example is the WFP, that in 2019 signed a USD45-million-dollar contract with Palantir, an American firm which specialised in data collection and AI modelling (Greenwood, 2019). In 2014, the United States Bureau of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) awarded a USD20 billion-dollar contract to Palantir, to track undocumented immigrants in the United States (Woodman, 2017). Their methodology was a classic case of what is called the ‘Mosaic Effect’, which is a technique used by intelligence agencies, which involves using multiple data sources to find personally identifiable information that might otherwise have been obscured. This technique is discussed in some detail by OCHA (OCHA 2021c), which explains that these databases can be used to reidentify highly vulnerable populations such as migrants to expel them from an area, recruit children for warfare, or otherwise threaten their safety. Palantir used this technique as part of its ICE contract by collecting and centralising large numbers of databases to reveal the location of migrants, leading to their eventual expulsion. Several human rights watchdogs, however, including Amnesty International, have raised concerns about Palantir, writing in a September 2020 report that: ‘Given Palantir's increasingly entrenched role in government operations and its multiple contracts across federal agencies, concerns about its human rights record are growing in urgency and deserve scrutiny’ (Amnesty International, 2020).