Biopunk overcomes the shortcomings of cyberpunk – able to challenge environmental issues
Schmeink 20 -- is the project lead at the “Science Fiction” subproject of “FutureWork,” a research network funded by the German Ministry of Education and Research. He was the inaugural pres- ident of the Gesellschaft für Fantastikforschung from 2010 to 2019 and has published extensively on science fiction and posthumanism. He is the author of Biopunk Dystopias: Genetic Engineering, Society, and Science Fiction (2016) and co-editor of Cyberpunk and Visual Culture (2018). (Lars, “Biopunk,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 10, p74-75) //le
As Thomas Foster has pointed out (and many of the entries in this collection further demon- strate), cyberpunk needs to be viewed as a cultural formation interacting with the posthuman: it acts as “an intervention in and inflection of a preexisting discourse, which cyberpunk signifi- cantly transformed and broadened, providing a new basis for the acceptance of posthuman ideas
in contemporary American popular culture” (Foster xiii).4 In spite of its posthuman potential, however, cyberpunk often retains a humanist subjectivity based on a position of human excep- tionalism and the underlying idea that “there is a distinctive entity identifiable as the ‘human,’ a human ‘self’” (Nayar 6). Cyberpunk, in many instances, depicts cybernetic technology as a means to enhance humans and overcome “any number of natural human limitations such as aging, death, suffering” (Philbeck 175). As a result, cyberpunk’s transhumanist concepts of cyborg enhance- ment, up to its extreme position of uploading one’s consciousness into fully realized machine bodies, are ways to allegedly free humanity from its biological limitations, or so the transhumanist arguments go. The humanist self, though, is untouched by these enhancements, transcending its bodily prison to consolidate its position of exceptionalism.
Biopunk may therefore be a better vehicle for posthuman lines of inquiry than cyberpunk; after all, cyberpunk’s desire to transcend human biology is a “fantasy of escape” (Braidotti 91) and a “grafting of the posthuman onto a liberal humanist view of the self” (Hayles 286–87). Biopunk, on the other hand, is founded upon what Donna J. Haraway refers to as “to become with many” (4). After all, Haraway reminds us that only 10% of the cells in a human body consist of human ge- nomes, while “the other 90% of the cells are filled with the genomes of bacteria, fungi, protists, and such, some of which play in a symphony necessary to my being alive at all, and some of which are hitching a ride and doing the rest of me, of us, no harm. I am vastly outnumbered by my tiny companions” (3–4). According to Haraway’s understanding, human has thus always already been a hybridized existence, inextricably linked to other species. Therefore, biopunk powerfully ex- plores the potential and the consequences that stem from this realization and best embodies the idea of a hybridized and pluralized posthumanity “constituted by and constitutive of multiple forms of life and machines” (Nayar 2).
Biopunk not only addresses the question of how the human relates to other forms of life, but it also challenges human relations with the environment, with the world. Cyberpunk’s enclosures, zones, and virtual worlds are representations of the impact of human technology, their differences highlighting the fragmentation of ontology into what McHale calls “multiple-world spaces” (250). In other words, our practices shape and form the world we live in; culture and technology define the boundaries and makeup of our world. In their focus on technologically shaped worlds, many cyberpunk texts see the world, as Veronica Hollinger points out in her contribution to this collec- tion, as defined by technology, with nature notably absent. Simply put, issues of human influence on ecology, or what is today referred to as the Anthropocene, act merely as background noise and not as narrative centers in cyberpunk. The scant attention paid to them lends credence to Gerry Canavan’s critique that cyberpunk has traditionally offered a shortcut “for getting outside scarcity and precariousness—simply leave the material world altogether, by entering the computer. In virtual space, with no resource consumption or excess pollution to worry about, we can all be as rich as we want for as long as we want (or so the story goes)” (9).
Biopunk, on the other hand, highlights the unrepresentability of the world, preferring to leave the scale of the human behind to address a “grey ecology” which “propels us beyond our own fin- itude, opens us to alien scales of both being (the micro and the macro) and time (the effervescent, barely glimpsed; the geologic, in which life proceeds at a billion year pace)” (Cohen 383). In other words, biopunk is an intervention in the discourses of the Anthropocene by exploring human life on a micro scale, the Harawayian becoming-with of viruses and bacteria. At the same time, biopunk also challenges our conceptions of life on the macro scale. For example, both the retrovirus of “Our Neural Chernobyl” and the single-cell lifeforms of Blood Music spread to all forms of life; their impact is global and will be irreversible for the Earth as a whole.