Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Anti-Cap movements adopt Enlightenment universalism, reinforcing universal Whiteness

Andrews ‘21 -- professor of black studies at Birmingham City University (Kehinde Andrews, “The New Age of Empire, How Racism and Colonialism Still Rule the World”, p. 183 – 190, Bold Type Books, Accessed 7-23-22)//ror

IMPERIAL DEMOCRACY What ultimately undermines the Enlightenment is the claim to the universal when its theories are based on the particular. Whiteness is at the heart of Enlightenment thinking and this is no different in the supposedly radical new approaches. All are fundamentally incapable of even naming the racism that is the basis of the global political and economic system, let alone able to offer any actual solutions. We can see this in the distorted Enlightenment progress narratives that underpin the new utopias, but also in the genesis and creation myths of the social movements that have informed the theory. The sparks that lit many of the new social movements were the financial crisis in 2008, the election of Trump and the vote for Brexit, which created, in Bregman’s words, ‘more and more people hungry for a real radical antidote to both xenophobia and inequality... for a new source of hope’.40 Ground zero in this narrative is the birth of neoliberalism, ushered in by Thatcherism and Reaganomics in the eighties. Dismantling the social democratic settlement unleashed the forces of capital and sowed the seeds for the economic crash in 2008. The unemployment, insecurity and austerity that followed led to the inevitable rise of the new right as people looked for causes of their poverty. It also exposed the inherent contradictions of capital and stoked the embers of protest by revealing their oppression to the oppressed. One of the first and most high-profile responses to this crisis was the Occupy movement, which swept the globe. On 17 September 2011, protestors occupied Zuccotti Park in downtown Manhattan near the financial district in order to protest at the cause of the financial crisis. The movement grew rapidly, spreading to a thousand cities and racking up 6,500 arrests within its first six months.41 The occupation was prompted by the Canadian anti-capitalist magazine Adbusters which ‘issued a call to action for a “revolution,” a “people’s revolt in the West”’ in response to the crisis of capitalism.42 Occupy took inspiration from previous movements like the Indignados in Spain, who had occupied public space in response to rising unemployment, austerity and other structural adjustments enforced by external financial institutions.43 The Arab Spring, highlighted by the occupation of Tahrir Square in Egypt in 2011, had a large influence on Occupy as the images of mass occupation of a public space took hold in the imagination. Thousands occupied Zuccotti Park for almost two months, until police raided and shut down the protest on 15 November. Occupy’s reach was such that President Obama gave the movement his approval in his 2012 re-election campaign. By focusing on the economic crisis Occupy changed the political language and ‘income inequality’ became the ‘crisis du jour’, something that all the 2016 presidential candidates at least had to address.44 The power of the economic message was its simplicity. The Occupiers declared that they were the 99 per cent standing up to the evil 1 per cent who hoarded the wealth. The only problem is that this idea is a delusional fantasy and a continuation of the universalizing of the White particular that we have seen from both left and right. Global inequality is so stark that those on the poverty line in the United States are still in the top 14 per cent of earners worldwide. The average US salary puts you in the top 4 per cent of earners. There is simply no comparison between the conditions facing the poorest in the world and those who are at the bottom in the United States, or in the rest of the West. Only by focusing on a national analysis could the ‘99 per cent’ rhetoric make any sense. By looking at its demands, or at least its articulation of the problem, it is abundantly clear that Occupy was focused on those in the West, not the victims of it. The Declaration of the Occupation of New York City, collectively produced by Occupiers, is a laundry list of national demands around healthcare, jobs and student debt. The most telling line is the complaint that the 1 per cent ‘have consistently outsourced labor and used that outsourcing as leverage to cut workers’ healthcare and pay’.45 No prizes for guessing which ‘workers’ they are referring to here. Presumably, bringing back those jobs and further impoverishing the underdeveloped world would be acceptable as long as the true ‘workers’ had access to unskilled and well-paid work. The declaration does include a line condemning the elite because ‘they have perpetuated colonialism at home and abroad.’ But this is so vague and contradictory to the rest of the declaration that it makes a mockery of their plea for the ‘people of the world’ to join the struggle. In the same vein as the Enlightenment thinkers, the centre of Occupy’s world was the West because it contained the fully formed workers, the movers of history. Even within the West the movement faced criticism for its tendency to ‘exclude minority voices’46 and faced serious issues of misogyny.47 There were also marked class differences, with the people who could afford to sleep in Zuccotti Park in protest brushing up against those who had already made it their home because of poverty. The classed differences also spread into tactics. Occupy Seattle angered working-class dock workers by closing down the port in protest against commercialism; their principled stance meant the people they were supposed to be fighting for, the ‘workers’, lost valuable income. Occupy prided itself on democratic decision-making but it was ‘limited by failures to build alliances beyond those implicit inside its inner community’.48 Democracy matters very little if your electorate is highly exclusive, a lesson that the left needs desperately to learn. It might be tempting to see Occupy as ‘a global movement (inspired by the Arab Spring)’, but the reality is that it was in a long tradition of Western social movements which broke out in the United States and spread into Europe and the rest of the world.49 In claiming to represent the 99 per cent, Occupy, perhaps unwittingly, followed in the path of Enlightenment universalism, speaking for the entire world through the very narrow lens of Western privilege.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.