Revolutionary democratic reform sustain racial exploitation and imperial narcissism – Occupy proves
Andrews ‘21 -- professor of black studies at Birmingham City University (Kehinde Andrews, “The New Age of Empire, How Racism and Colonialism Still Rule the World”, p. 183 – 190, Bold Type Books, Accessed 7-23-22)//ror
In many ways Occupy was ‘the idealist moment, the performance rather than permanence’.55 In Zuccotti Park, or in their hundreds of other locations around the world, they were performing the ideal. Occupy was performance art, a grand piece of ‘utopian theatre’ dramatizing the other world that is otherwise out of reach.56 Here we see the White left at its most stomach-churning. Reading through some of the misty-eyed reflections on the movement, they have the feeling of romantic holiday diaries. Nothing may have changed and the movement may have collapsed but no fear, we will always have Zuccotti Park. Occupy’s horizontal organization involved both a deep narcissism–with slogans such as ‘we are our demands’–and a way of building community that relied on ‘people forming loose connections quickly’ which fit perfectly into current times.57 It was the swipe-right of social movements, with no deep ideological commitments, loose connections, and the ability to find some fun elsewhere without feeling guilty. Performance over permanence is only an option to those in the land of plenty who have jobs or at least a welfare state to fall back on. What made Tahrir Square a completely different sort of movement was that the protestors had a clear demand, which was life or death, and they refused to move until it was met. We can debate how much difference came about when the military took over from President Mubarak in Egypt but not the organic commitment of the people to their struggle, nor that they risked their lives for their cause. The stakes in the West are of a different nature and therefore so are the politics. Democracy as a principle runs through the new left agenda. In Britain the new left is pushing for a more inclusive economy, similar to the demands of Occupy. Neoliberalism is diagnosed as the source of the ills of society, with the rich taking too much of the economic pie. We are promised that by a ‘democratic revolution’ we can transform the institutions of governance and society at large.58 Not only is this struggle about income but it is also about reducing the social distance between people in society so that ‘everyone can share a common life as citizens’.59 The Labour Party under the leadership of Jeremy Corbyn embraced these ideals when he was unexpectedly voted leader in 2015. Prior to this, Labour had been in a period of mimicking Conservative policy on the economy, fully embracing neoliberalism with the idea that the spoils could be shared across society. After Labour’s surprising success (but not victory) in the general election of 2017, Corbyn launched what he called Labour’s ‘radical and ambitious’ manifesto for the 2019 election, promising to transform both society and the economy.60 Labour’s plans mirrored much of the New Economic Foundation’s recommendations for policy reform (the NEF is a key think-tank for the new left). The NEF hits all the key notes with the goal to build a society where all people are ‘paid well, have more time off to spend with their families, have access to affordable housing, know there is a decent safety net if they need one, and are provided with a high level of care throughout their lives’.61 In order to do this they propose a four-day week, a living wage, boosting trade union membership and fashioning a ‘well-being state’ where targets are not simply economic but relate to the mental and physical health of the nation. They stopped short of a universal basic income, instead suggesting a far more modest national allowance of £50 a week that counts when calculating benefit entitlements. But they are in favour of universal basic services, nationalizing key industries and providing free childcare to support families. The Green New Deal is of course embraced as a motor for both saving the world and job creation. They are also keen on ‘people’s participation in decision making’ in both policy- making and business.62 One of the NEF’s and Labour’s main focuses is on establishing workers’ cooperatives as a model for sharing wealth. Preston, a small city in the north of England, has an outsize importance in the new economy, since it has become a model for local-government led cooperatives. The council’s decision to source more locally and create cooperatives in the city has both boosted income and dispersed that extra money somewhat more fairly. Other large local employers like the university have followed suit by engaging with local suppliers, and the city is improving. But we should be wary of celebrating a radical new dawn.63 For a start it is nothing new, with democratic reforms being part of the left-wing imagination for ‘at least a century’. Labour governments and councils attempted such projects before neoliberalism took over in the Thatcher era.64 John McDonnell, the architect of Corbyn’s economic policy, served his political apprenticeship in the eighties under Tony Benn, who developed a series of cooperative projects. The major flaw with these concepts of participation is who is included and who remains firmly on the outside. For all the talk of participation there is scant regard for the fact that those in the underdeveloped world are equally stakeholders in the economic life of the West. One of the cooperatives so praised in Preston is a coffee shop, and while we celebrate the benefits to the worker in Britain, the shop’s success is only possible because of the racial exploitation of the poor people farming the coffee beans it uses for next to nothing (it may be a surprise, but coffee does not grow in the north of England). This is Cadbury World all over again but on a societal scale. The wealth the left wants to share with those in their nations is derived in large part from global, racial exploitation. What the new left are offering is just a modified version of social democracy. A return to the days of high taxes, social housing, reduced inequality and the guarantee of a decent wage... but only in the West. In reality it is not a social but an imperial democracy they are yearning for.