Western imperialism inspired China’s exploitation of Africa --- capitalist drive for profit underlies resource extraction
Andrews ‘21 -- professor of black studies at Birmingham City University (Kehinde Andrews, “The New Age of Empire, How Racism and Colonialism Still Rule the World”, p. 183 – 190, Bold Type Books, Accessed 7-23-22)//ror
THE CHINESE SCRAMBLE FOR AFRICA China’s links to Africa go back centuries, at least as far as the Han dynasty in 202 BC. (The idea that Europe initiated global trade and connectedness is one of the many fictions of Whitewashed intellectual history.) The Communist People’s Republic of China had strong ties to Africa and the liberation movements to end colonialism. In the global fight against capital, Mao was keen to support the armed struggle in places like Mozambique and Angola. China was a key player in the 1955 Afro-Asian Bandung Conference, which sought to create a united non-aligned front to combat the global power of both the West and the Soviet bloc. China’s credentials in Africa were well forged and included building a railway line connecting Zambia to Tanzania in the early 1970s. In return for its support, African nations backed UN recognition of revolutionary China and supported the nation’s rise to prominence on the world stage.7 China was influential in the Black radical imagination and was seen by many ‘as the land where true freedom might be had’.8 The Black Panther Party initially started fundraising by selling copies of Mao’s ‘Little Red Book’ to college students,9 and co-founder Huey P. Newton invoked Mao in his book Revolutionary Suicide when he argued that their revolutionary commitment was the Panthers’ ‘great leap forward’.10 Numerous Panthers visited China, including Elaine Brown who would become the party’s chairperson. Given China’s progressive history with Africa and Black politics, its increasing influence on the African continent has been welcomed by many. Indeed, China plays off its historical relationship, painting itself as an underdeveloped country aiming for a mutually beneficial relationship with a friend in need. Although China’s links to Africa are not new, its economic role in the continent has drastically changed since the start of the new millennium. From 2000 to 2012 trade between China and Africa grew twenty-fold to $200 billion.11 Between 2001 and 2010 China’s Export–Import Bank provided $67.2 billion in loans to so-called sub-Saharan African countries, $12.5 billion more than the World Bank.12 The West is wary of China’s rapid expansion in Africa due to the increased competition for resources in the region and also because Chinese money provides an alternative to the conditional loans enforcing the dreaded Washington consensus.13 China does not attach structural adjustment strings to its loans, preferring to stay out of matters of state and stick to finance. Chinese aid has empowered African countries to say no to the devilish pacts with the IMF and the World Bank. While the West has looted resources and meddled in political and economic systems, China has been busy building the roads, dams, buildings and railways that Africa so sorely needs. Not only that, but China has also invested in the manufacturing sector, to the tune of over $3 billion by the end of 2012.14 With its history of comradeship, its massive investment, and the fact it represents an alternative to the hated IMF and World Bank, it is easy to see why there is some optimism and a view that ‘the Chinese are our friends’ among many on the continent.15 But we must remember that the China that holds the revolutionary link to Africa is an historical artefact. Since China’s economic reforms, the country has embraced the same political and economic order that oppresses Africa, and in many ways has legitimized neo-colonialism by posing as a friend.16 To understand China’s neo-colonial role in Africa we need look no further than the reason for its increased involvement in the first place. After China embraced the capitalist global order, and its economy grew on the basis of production, it needed to find fresh sources of raw materials. You cannot make the goods for the world without their ingredients. China’s entry into Africa has been driven by the need to acquire resources such as oil and minerals to secure its place in the global economy. China’s expansion in Africa also occurred mostly after it joined the World Trade Organization in 2001 and it therefore operates firmly within the global economic consensus that is a major part of the continued underdevelopment of Africa. While Chinese money may not come with the requirement for structural adjustment, it is a lie to say there are no strings attached. For China finance is tied to natural resource extraction rather than political control. China’s interest rates are typically higher than those from Western financial institutions and it generally takes payment in the form of mining rights rather than cash. Therefore the vast majority of Chinese assistance goes to mineral-rich African countries. In places like Congo, Angola and Zambia, China is providing money to build infrastructure while stripping the natural resources of the countries. A classic example of this arrangement, in what was dubbed the ‘deal of the century’ when it was signed between China and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) in 2007, is a $9 billion loan that meant China would commit to building roads, hospitals and other vital infrastructure projects in return for almost monopolistic control over the mining of cobalt and copper.17 It may sound like a good deal for Congo, but consider that the minerals in question are worth an estimated $87 billion and it is quickly apparent that China is extracting the materials from Congo for a fraction of what they are worth.18 The IMF were against the loan because they wanted to offer their own finance package with the usual conditions. But by avoiding the Western institutions the DRC has jumped out of the frying pan and into the fire. Across the African continent, countries are making the same deals with China, selling off their most valuable resources on the cheap to get at least some infrastructure built. It is not hard to see why, when Africa is in dire need of such spending, with estimates that it requires well over $22 billion spent annually to address its infrastructure problems.19 But these resources are precious to the future of Africa, which by rights should be the richest place on earth thanks to its abundance of natural wealth. By cashing in, the continent is destroying its future. Natural resources are finite and for Africa to prosper it should be maximizing the wealth produced from them to truly transform the continent. Green technology will become the next boom industry and Africa holds a bounty of the minerals necessary for the shift to sustainable energy. China, on the other hand, has only accelerated the exploitation of Africa’s resources. Worse still, the model used to build this infrastructure is of more benefit to China than Africa. When signing agreements such as the ‘deal of the century’ China insists that it provides the majority of the equipment and labour (usually 70 per cent).20 In effect the vast majority of the ‘aid’ that is given to a country is spent buying goods from China and paying Chinese companies and workers to rebuild Africa. China is basically providing a stimulus to its own economy, dressed up as foreign aid. Not only does the recipient country have to pay this loan back with interest but China also reaps massive profits from its preferential access to precious mineral resources. This model has all of the ‘Alice in Wonderland craziness’ about it that Kwame Nkrumah described in Western neo- colonialism.21 Even China’s support for infrastructure spending is not as benevolent as it can appear. European colonizers spent massive sums on roads, railways and the like because they were necessary to extract the wealth out of the continent. When the Chinese offer to build roads that connect an untapped mine to the sea, they are not doing so out of their wish to better the economic circumstances of Africa. China has also built forty-four sports stadiums in Africa, raising serious questions about the nature and utility of its infrastructure spending.22 These projects routinely end up as white elephants, something the rulers can use to show off but which have no long-term beneficial impact on the economy. It is abundantly clear that China’s involvement in infrastructure is not a break with the logic of Western empire. It may be a different model, but it is one that supports the principles and functioning of the current system. After all, the Chinese are extracting these resources to make products to be sold, in large part, to the West. China’s presence in Africa is also not always at odds with Western interests. There are a number of direct collaborations between Chinese and Western companies in Africa, who are after all in the region for the same reasons. The French company Total partnered with a Chinese oil company to extract oil from the Nigerian seabed,23 and Chinese companies also enrich themselves by bidding for contracts funded by Western agencies like the World Bank. Bamako International Airport in Mali underwent a $181 million upgrade between 2007 and 2012 funded by the Millennium Challenge Corporation, a US aid agency. Regardless of the fact that China and the United States may be in a struggle for global dominance, this United States government contract was carried out by Chinese workers.24 Migrant workers being imported into Africa to rebuild the continent has created a specific form of tension. It is estimated that there are now over 1 million Chinese people living in Africa, attracted to the continent by the opportunities there. It should be no surprise that the natives of the poorest continent in the world are wary. Chinese migrant workers enjoy better pay and working conditions. This marks a reversal of Chinese people being used as a cheap and discriminated-against labour force to build the original version of Western empire. China is now providing the frontier folk, seeking new opportunities. It is also not difficult to find attitudes reminiscent of the old European colonizers who went to Africa to make their fortunes. In journalist Howard French’s book China’s Second Continent he explains how commonplace colonial-era racism was with the Chinese migrants he spoke to across Africa. His discussion with Hao, a migrant to Mozambique, stands out. Hao had migrated with little, had not learned a local language, and yet managed to acquire 5,000 acres of land, much to the displeasure of the locals, and planned to grow cash crops to sell to Western countries. He explained his decision to try his luck in Mozambique as follows: Can you imagine if I had gone to America or to Germany first? The people in those fucking places are too smart. I wouldn’t have gotten anywhere. I don’t think I could have beaten them. So we had to find backward countries, poor countries that we can lead.25 Colonial-era attitudes could also be found among those delivering aid projects. Li Jinjun, head of the Central Agricultural Research Institute in Liberia, explained that the Chinese would only run the project for a limited time in order that the locals ‘learn to support themselves’. In classic civilizing mission language, the Institute was proud that ‘little by little... can change them in this way.’26 Of course, we cannot generalize these attitudes to the whole of the Chinese migrant population in Africa but we also should not be surprised if they are prevalent. They are only important insofar as they speak to the wider power dynamics of the Chinese neo-colonial relationship with Africa. Objections to Chinese migration are not solely down to their colonial attitudes or denying locals the opportunity to work on infrastructure projects, but tie into the other major area where China has continued the work of Western imperialism on the continent. As heralded as the increased trade between China and Africa has been, it represents the classic relationship between colonizer and colony. China’s imports from Africa are comprised of well over 90 per cent oil and other natural resources. At the same time, Africa’s imports from China are 90 per cent finished manufactured products. Africa exports its resources well below the value that they are worth to China, which manufactures goods and sells them back into Africa, collecting all the profit. As a result China is able to produce cheap goods and flood African markets at prices that local producers have no way of competing with. The result has been a de-industrialization of Africa as local manufacturers are forced out of business. In 2008 manufacturing made up 12.8 per cent of GDP in Africa, and just eight years later that figure had fallen to 10.5 per cent. Between 1980 and 2008 Africa’s share of global manufacturing was down from 1.2 per cent to 0.9 per cent.27 In Nigeria the impact of Chinese textile imports has been devastating to local manufacturing. In the 1980s there were 175 textile factories in the country, but within twenty-five years that number had declined to only twenty-five. Even though imported textiles are illegal they account for over 85 per cent of the market and are valued at $2.2 billion annually, versus only $40 million for locally produced products.28 The impact on jobs has been catastrophic, with the number of those working in Nigeria’s textile industry in 2015 declining to 20,000 from 600,000 in the 1990s.29 The result has been tension and even strikes in Senegal over the presence of the Chinese in local markets: they have become a feature as imports have flooded in. There is no doubt that the Chinese who are trading into Africa are profiting from the underdeveloped state of Africa and taking advantage of the situation created by Western imperialism. This kind of opportunism from those whose skin is not White is also nothing new for Africa. Lebanese traders were dominant as middlemen between the French and their African colonies and there was a similar relationship between South Asian communities in East Africa and the British. The only real difference with the Chinese is that they are not playing the role of middlemen to European colonizers; instead they represent one of the strongest emerging neo-colonial forces. China is certainly not a colonial power in the same way as Britain, France or any of the other European nations were. There is no invasion, violence and domination of political affairs. But, as we already know, that is not how the new age of empire works. Although the former colonial masters may have links and historical advantages in particular countries (particularly in relation to language), underdeveloped economies are open to exploitation from any nation or corporation that has the capital. There is no metropolis, no mother country, just a racialized political and economic system that allows for such exploitation.