Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Aff’s framing of countries as aggressive justifies violence abroad and ignores the internal warfare at home

McMichael 16 (Christopher, PhD in Politics from Rhodes University, research include organized crime, Libertarian Marxism, and Fascism, “Pacification and Police: A critique of the Police Militarization Thesis,” November 29 2016, https://journals-sagepub-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1177/0309816816678569)

But what is it at stake is not just the definition of police, but of war. Since at least the end of the Cold War, the concept of militarization has been taken on-board across many disciplines. We read of everything from the ‘militarization of urban space’ () to the ‘militarization of entertainment’ (). This literature generally portrays the sense that war has become more expansive than conflicts among nation-states, with security and surveillance becoming increasingly central to areas of social life, which appear distinct from formal military engagements. Our argument is not with the merits or the validity of this work but rather with its assumption of there being a traditional form of warfare – most generally defined as a geographically bounded and declared Clausewitzian struggle between states for power and territory. The most far reaching critique of such narrow definitions comes from , , , , ) work on security and pacification. The liberal definition of war as a confrontation between formally opposed states both ignores ‘the transnational nature of a great deal of warfare’ and ‘obscure the structural and systematic violence through which liberal order has been constituted’ (: 9). This ideological blurring goes back to European imperialism where, from the 16th century onwards, complex legal and philosophical arguments were used to present wars of colonial expansion as police actions to ensure peace and security – often referred to as ‘small wars’. The military campaigns at the forefront of conquest and violent accumulation were philosophically and ideologically rationalized as necessary to pacify ‘savage’ populations and to liberate their bodies and resources for the benefit of civilization (: 14). A key point of liberal thought is conceptualizing the military as an institution solely for foreign policy and the ‘over there’ and the police as a domestic institution only deployed ‘here’ for law enforcement and keeping the peace. Through this logic, the liberal state set itself up as different from feudal power and later what would become known as the totalitarian or ‘police state’, in which warfare against citizens is said to be unbound. Therefore, the notion that police powers and war powers come from different logics and mandates is a relatively recent notion that largely emerges out of liberal doctrines on state power (i.e. separation of powers and rule of law), which of course also merged with a nascent capitalist modernity (which was contingent on mass state and private violence against the indigenous, slaves and poor people). What is deliberately obscured is how civil society under capitalism is already at war. As described by Marx in Volume One of Capital the history of liberalism is also of the ‘logic of war, exercised in a permanent fashion against rebellious slaves, antagonistic Indians, wayward workers, and criminals with something unsocial in mind’ (: 15). Two centuries later, we see ‘semi-permanent wars against the enemy within and without – such as the war on drugs and the war on terror’ (: 16). The dominant thrust of the liberal tradition is thus to simplify the complexity of political power into dichotomies with policing and war treated as separate endeavours, represented by different institutions and practised within separate territories. However, even left theorists across different disciplines have accepted these distinctions, leading to work which focuses on the ‘overlaps’ and ‘blurring’ between the police and military, rather than on war and police as ‘processes working in conjunction as state power’ (: 587). From this standpoint, the question is not then about how the police resemble militaries, but rather the role that the police play in the liberal war for peace and pacification. In order to understand this, we first need to understand the liberal arguments, which are at the centre of the police militarization concept.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.