Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Liberty is only an excuse to continue to extend war and police power

McMichael 16 (Christopher, PhD in Politics from Rhodes University, research include organized crime, Libertarian Marxism, and Fascism, “Pacification and Police: A critique of the Police Militarization Thesis,” November 29 2016, https://journals-sagepub-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1177/0309816816678569)

Historically, liberals have praised the spontaneity of the market, in contrast with the ‘artificial, violent constructivism’ of other societies, and presented this as a virtuous cycle where economic freedom regulates and reduces the need for state intervention (: 283). On one level, liberalism is a political philosophy in which peace and freedom are seen to be the end historical goals of the extension of market order. But this discourse of emancipation has been historically tangled with dis-emancipation in which violent policing operations to contain the dangerous classes and foreign barbarians are the mechanisms for extending peace (: 286, 342). Therefore, the precondition for liberty and the pursuit of rational self-interest is the extension of police and war power. Rather than being primarily focused on liberty, liberalism is thus a politics of security, concerned with reshaping individuals, groups and territories in the image of capital (: 5). It is in this pursuit of security in the name of liberty that the most authoritarian tendencies of liberalism become apparent, from police killings to the revival of torture and indefinite detention. The danger is not therefore that liberal states can become more like fascist ones through ‘police militarization’, but rather that security politics reveal the fascist or authoritarian tendencies within liberal democracy already (: 9). In turn, this entails a particular situation where the continual expansion of intrusive police powers has historically been justified in terms of protecting individual freedom, while in practise encouraging despotic power in the protection of economic interests. For example, during the Cold War, the US government provided training and financial support to repressive police forces throughout the world, many which regularly engaged in torture and murder, in the name of fighting totalitarianism (). A similar process can be observed today when anti-democratic extensions in police and military power are legitimated as measures against anti-democratic extremism.

Recent scholarship has focused on the idea of ‘war: police assemblages’ evident in ‘contemporary liberal interventionism’, such as in the combination of clandestine drone attacks and special force interventions, full scale military invasions and counter-insurgency which have characterised recent wars in the Middle East and beyond (). But as : 441) points out the history of policing indicates that these current assemblages are not a recent phenomenon – ‘policing arrives once the condition for order have been violently established by the military so that reason of state can be implemented. Policing is the continuation of military actions by other means’. Viewed as continuum or assemblage, even a cursory survey highlights the extent to which the police have been central to the disciplining and oppression of the domestic enemies of liberal states. To give just a few examples, by the end of the 18th century, police forces in Europe were engaged in regular manhunts to round up beggars and vagrants (: 81), while across the Atlantic, the millions of Africans forced into bondage in the Americas were kept in line with slave patrols, which scholars are now increasingly viewing as one of the key forerunners of modern US policing (). The police were also at the forefront of state efforts to control ‘free labour’ through the suppression of strikes and revolts in the workplace. To give the example of just one country, the police were key agents in the ‘strikes (which moved) towards miniature civil wars between workers and the state’ during periods of intense labour militancy in the United States (: 236). However, this history is regularly omitted in contemporary discussions of police militarization. An illustrative quote, worth citing in full is from an interview conducted with  by the popular Vice website during which he details a version of (US) police history, in which

The Founders were quite wary of standing armies and the threat they pose to liberty. They ultimately concluded – reluctantly – that the country needed an army for national defense. But they most feared the idea of troops patrolling city streets – a fear colored by much of human history, and more immediately by the antagonism between British troops and residents of Boston in the years leading up to the American Revolution. The Founders could never have envisioned police as they exist today. And I think it’s safe to say they’d have been absolutely appalled at the idea of a team of police, dressed and armed like soldiers, breaking into private homes in the middle of the night for the purpose of preventing the use of mind-altering drugs.

What Balko omits is the question of how war and police power were deployed against groups considered as undeserving of liberty by the ‘founders’: slaves, American Indians, African slaves, the property-less and women. The violent economy of chattel slavery and oppression of indigenous peoples gained their political force from the police power. Indeed, in the heroic age of liberty conjured by Balko, the Founders were in fact prepared to use military force to suppress internal revolt, such as in the case of the 1794 rebellion against the Whiskey Tax by farmers in Pennsylvania in which Alexander Hamilton led troops against the revolt (: 100). Tracing the history of the police power and not just ‘the police’,  writes of the ways that the ‘Founders’ retained the notion of unlimited and undefinable police powers that operated in England. He writes, ‘Ending the king’s police power, it turns out, did not mean ending police power altogether … Americans didn’t appreciate being policed, but they had no qualms about policing’ (p. 83).

The policing of imperialism occurred in tandem with the foundation of modern police forces in Europe, but crucially this linkage was played down at the time. In the case of Britain, for instance, the creation of the police was influenced by experiments with colonial warfare in Ireland, albeit framed very differently: While the discourse for police advocacy for Ireland explicitly invoked the need for a paramilitary police under the spectre of ‘real or suspected insurrectionary conspiracies’, the militaristic character of policing could not enter the discourses of advocacy in the metropolis (: 231). This occurred in a context in which Atlantic political thinkers and the administrators in the late 18th and 19th centuries began to call for a professionalized body of standing police officers, capable of both managing the potential threats posed by growing proletariats in the metropole and the colonies and protecting production (). The military was not a practical institution to govern emerging capitalist societies:

alternating as it does between no intervention and the most drastic and violent procedures. The newly emerging police, in contrast, could penetrate civil society in a way impossible for military formations, less to crush disorder in the form of riots (though it also came to do that of course) and more to fabricate an order in which such disorder did not occur. (: 78)

The liberal demand for order was therefore not about so much reducing the threat of arbitrary military power, but rather of ensuring a more thorough policing of civil society, which was regularized and comprehensive (). In practise, however, the differences between the military and police was often more a question of degrees than of fundamental divergences of function, especially evident in colonies. In the case of South Africa, for instance, ‘the military feature of policing’ was dominant – both in terms of the institutional history of serving as an ‘internal army of occupation’ and in the usage of police formations as military units during war-time (: 3). Throughout the British Empire, there are similar examples of military forces gradually developing into police institutions.

The point which derives from these examples is that the dual historical formation of the nation-state and capitalism saw military and police forces enrolled in shared projects of conquest and control. These different forces were joined as part of the machinery of State – ‘armies of wars of colonial pacification, international competition and domestic repression’ (: 20). However, this is not to argue that the police are interchangeable with the military. Instead, they are able to conduct internal operations in a far more sustained but, when considering the historical record, often as violent a manner as military forces:

As states defined a part of their own population as an enemy, the military learned from those who know how to locate individuals and to ‘interrogate’ them: the police. If military dictatorships were so effective in suppressing all political opposition and taking thousands of lives, if they could wage unilateral ‘wars’ on their own populations, it was thanks to the ‘police method’ … (: 118)

Police institutions, thus, have a distinct role in ‘facilitating authoritarianism and state violence … that the scholarly emphasis on “militarization” tends to ignore’ (). The general thrust of much of the police militarization literature has been to portray police authoritarianism as intrinsic to non-liberal states but aberrant to capitalist democracies. Liberal societies are understood to be policed societies, in which the institutions work to achieve peace and prosperity in a regulated and consistent fashion, rather than police states, in which officers are at war with society. As argued in the previous section, this distinction omits the pivotal role played by police and military violence and terror in the foundation and extension of capitalism. But this is not limited to primitive accumulation but rather is a central, continuous process of pacification and of fabricating order through police patrolling, surveillance and governance. Police power is not restricted to repression of the state’s enemies but in the daily regulation of society, from administering discriminatory labour practices and environmental practices to penalizing the illicit economic activities of the poor. Police both intervene in the workplace, through their involvement in strikes and industrial disputes, and are the key instruments in enforcing social control over the dispossessed ‘underclass’, who are not integrated into the labour force. In a history of class war in the United States originally published in , the journalist Louis Adamic noted that the ‘police club’ was the pre-eminent symbol of capitalist power (p. 23). Almost a century later, the police club is now accompanied by pepper spray, tear gas, armoured vehicles and drones, but the police still represent the main force employed by the state to attack and control the social tensions generated by economic inequality and exploitation – from industrial conflict in the early 20th century to street battles around austerity and crisis in the early 21st century. Of course, the nature of whom and what is policed changes over time, and in line with changes in capitalist order, from domination over nascent industrial proletariats in the 19th century to regular campaigns of harassment against the unemployed and migrants in the post-industrial badlands of neo-liberalism.

But even without the more high tech accoutrements, the generic officer on the beat is nevertheless a figure of considerable power who enforces state domination on the street, and in particular against the ‘dangerous classes’. Indeed, Mike Brown was not gunned down in the middle of a Ferguson street by an overtly military-inspired SWAT agent. He was gunned down by the routine patrol officer, the state agent that is dressed in ‘traditional’ police attire and driving the ‘traditional’ police cruiser that more closely resembles the ‘community policing solution’ that so many public commentators have posited to supplant police militarization. Yet, soon after the routine execution of Brown, quickly most all of the controversy and criticism of the police power were aimed at the use of military gear, aesthetics, and tactics – attention was placed steadfastly on the spectacle of police–military repression. Of course, we are not suggesting that these developments should not be ruthlessly critiqued. They certainly demonstrate a significant ability of the local state to deploy maximum force. But here the spectacle stayed true to its own governing logic, hiding in plain sight the equally insidious violence of the ‘good old police’.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.