Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Aff’s discourse of pacification is inseparable with the logic of militarism which entrenches colonialism

McMichael 16 (Christopher, PhD in Politics from Rhodes University, research include organized crime, Libertarian Marxism, and Fascism, “Pacification and Police: A critique of the Police Militarization Thesis,” November 29 2016, https://journals-sagepub-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1177/0309816816678569)

The inability of the militarization argument to acknowledge how a patrol officer with a nightstick may be as much of a cause of terror and fear as the machine gun waving SWAT team unit, is further indicator of its liberal bent. Moreover, the popular lexicon of police militarization doesn’t offer any ability to critique the police officer reading books to children at a public school, or passing out candy during a parade, or holding ‘public forums’, press conferences and ‘community meetings’. Hence, instead of thinking about the police/war assemblage through the notion of militarization, it might be best to think of this through the idea of pacification. Although pacification most commonly evokes US counter-insurgency efforts in Vietnam, the concept has a much longer history, emerging first in the Edicts of Pacification of the mid to late 1500s, where these laws were said to be aimed at the ending of strife and to make populations submit to state rule primarily through peaceful methods. Drawing on , Neocleous reminds us that, in 1573, Philip II ordered that ‘conquests’ be renamed ‘pacification’, so as to help build consent among the colonized. As  states,

The dates are important, since they are deep into the period of global accumulation and the history of capital, or, in other words, the point of departure for the period in which the insecurity of bourgeois order had to be secured. (p. 199)

From here pacification became a means of original accumulation through the colonial conquests of the 17th century, only to be re-theorized, re-named and re-deployed across a plethora of more contemporary colonial geographies, from French counter-insurgency in Algeria and Indo-China, to Britain’s engagements in Malaysia, Cyprus and Kenya, to US counter-insurgencies in Vietnam. Pacification is best thought of as a central strategy of the colonialist, capitalist state as it works to secure the insecurities of accumulation both domestically and internationally, and this lines up with the police mandate. Instead of only describing state power as a pacification project,  argues that critical theory should reappropriate the concept of pacification as a way of understanding the security politics of liberal order building, as capital works to secure accumulation and the state demands order.

As a way of thinking through the police and war assemblage as always about the fabrication of order and productive labour, the notion of pacification better highlights the ways that coercion and consent are always the flip sides to the security coin. That is, it usefully accounts for not only the excesses or spectacular forms of police violence that the militarization thesis is rightly concerned about but also offers a way of thinking through the routine, non-spectacular violence of ‘Officer Friendly’ as well as this agents attempts of winning ‘hearts and minds’. Pacification, then, helps to keep in constant focus the iron fist and velvet glove of police power. Yet, pacification, with its evocation of counter-insurgency, colonization and war, doesn’t base its claims on making a distinction between police and war, or peace and war, or even foreign and domestic. Pacification, then, is not only an international, colonizing strategy as it is most commonly discussed (i.e. colonization of Algeria, Vietnam, Malaysia, for example), but simultaneously a way of fabricating domestic order, as liberalism deploys the police concept in relation to domestic dangers and threats. Police, then, at least in the domestic sense of the term, becomes a pacifying power directed at ordering the disorderly and possessing the dispossessed, or the ‘reserve armies of labor’ so central to capitalist modernity. But whether as war power or police power, pacification is animated by the inseparable logics of security and order, and hinges on a joint strategy of coercion and consent.  suggests that pacification as an ‘anti-security’ concept usefully gets at the heart of class struggle and the violence of capitalist modernity, as it implies that there are subjects and populations that refuse efforts at their pacification, which of course is inseparable from struggles over space. To think in terms of pacification, then, is to also ask who is being pacified and for what reasons and objectives ().

While the militarization literature has highlighted the repressive impacts of the wars on drugs, crime and terror on policing, this has primarily been understood as a matter of error and bad policy, in which the inaccurate metaphor of war mutates the ‘true’ function of policing. Understood as pacification, the wars on drugs, crime and terror are not actually metaphors at all but are real wars which ‘slip and slide from the foreign into the domestic and back again’ (: 201). At different points, for instance, the war on drugs involved military engagements in Latin America, provided a rationale for expanded police powers and massive growth of the prison population in the United States. This logic of security is also repurposed for police and military projects undertaken by other states. For example, the war on drugs in Mexico and Colombia has been used to displace communities from resource rich areas, for attacks on labour organizing and to create an environment favourable for corporate investment (). In post-apartheid South Africa, police methods adopted from the US war on drugs were incorporated into a new ‘war on crime’, targeting undocumented migrants and the urban poor (). The exchange between war and policing is more insidious and sophisticated than just the transference of combat equipment into the domestic sphere, with models of population control and public relations honed in counter-insurgency returning to the domestic streets ().

The liberal focus on establishing the correct boundaries between war and policing is also tactically problematic for political activism and organizing, as its shift the critique of police power away from issues of structural oppression and state violence into that of due process. For example, in the wake of the 2015 Baltimore uprisings following the police killing of Freddie Gray, President Obama has promised to restrict the federal transfer of military equipment to local police departments. But while this gives the surface appearance of answering the radical challenges presented by insurgent protest, it clearly does not actually address the racism and everyday brutality which sparks revolt. Unlike more bluntly authoritarian political system, the liberal state can incorporate pressure for reform from below into governance in a manner that appears to be progressive while, maintaining the ruling order. Writing in the wake of the social revolts of the 1960s,  observed that political repression in liberal states required a great deal of social consent, won through the agents of the state appearing to be consistent and law abiding, and the incorporation of the discourses and critiques raised by dissenting groups. Thus, policing in the United States since the 1970s has combined the impulse of militarization with community policing, in which the police are trained to be more ‘sensitive’ about racism and sexism (). Such a combination results in a more sophisticated repression, as communities are enlisted to collaborate with the police, while still maintaining an expanded capacity to deploy violence.

By failing to address the complex and sophisticated mechanisms of police repression in capitalist democracies, liberal critique ends up focusing on procedures and appearance to the ‘point where ends are irrelevant’ (: 34). The idea of militarization takes a legalistic focus on achieving the ‘proper’ form of policing, a discourse which easily be co-opted by the state. At core, it is based on a liberal frame of trying to establish appropriate boundaries between military and police, rather than looking at how war and police overlap and conjoin in the everyday governance of capitalism. It is focused on the apparent danger of liberal democracies becoming more like despotic political systems while obfuscating the fundamental violence of the liberal state. By contrast, thinking on police violence and state repression through the concept of pacification highlights that this is potentially already existent and apparent within liberalism itself. The problem is not that liberal democracies could become dystopic tyrannies through the negative pull of militarization, but rather that there is already a violent social war within capitalist society. And within this conflict, police institutions are central mechanisms for ensuring class and racial dominance already and have been since their founding.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.