Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

1033 is used to target black and brown communities – perpetuates racism and white supremacy

Singhvi 21 (Sahil, Root-Tilden-Kern scholar at NYU Law, Studies Economics and Sociology at Wesleyan University, Research and Program Associate at Brennan Center for Justice, “Demilitarize the Police,” Brennan Center For Justice, https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/demilitarize-police)

Last summer, the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD) became the latest police department to take violent action against peaceful protesters.  shows LAPD officers acting less like protectors of the peace and more like an occupying force in a theater of war as they beat already subdued individuals with batons, shot noncombative people with so-called “less-than-lethal” munitions, and  protesters before arresting them en masse.

To those familiar with the history of policing in the United States, this behavior did not come entirely as a surprise. Some of the earliest  of policing are found in patrols and Night Watches that hunted down runaway slaves,  in the South and around the country. And law enforcement has a long and shameful history of , particularly when expressed by communities of color. Nonetheless, it would be a mistake to ignore the ways in which the more recent phenomenon of police militarization has played into the hostility that some police officers exhibit toward the communities they are intended to serve.

The material militarization of police has been on an upward trajectory since the , who “[allowed and encouraged] the military to grant civilian law enforcement agencies access to military bases, research, and equipment”  as part of the “War on Drugs.” That anti-drug fervor continued into the 1990s, when Congress  the transfer of unused Department of Defense equipment to state and local law enforcement for counter-drug activities, a measure which was then replaced with what is now referred to as the “,” named for its establishing numbered section in the 1997 National Defense Authorization Act.

Though these measures were intended strictly to mitigate drug trafficking, they resulted in an explosion of the use of military equipment . We saw this militarization come to a head , when riot police dressed for combat deployed flash grenades, used mine-resistant vehicles to drive through throngs of people, and surveilled activists from  during the protests following the murder of George Floyd. It’s no wonder that calls to repeal the 1033 Program and demilitarize police have  in civil rights circles and in Congress.

But it’s not enough to see militarization as simply the use of military equipment. As Columbia University Law Professor Bernard Harcourt , along with tanks and night-vision goggles, American police in many cities have imported and adopted the mentality of the military, down to the idea that the residents of the communities where officers patrol are enemy combatants to be met with force. And it’s worth noting which populations are seen as those enemy combatants: left-wing protesters are  to be subjects of police violence than right-wing protesters, who are often  by police.

This development flies in the face of Americans’  that police and the military should be separate. It is an idea that can be traced back to the nation’s , when British soldiers quartered inside colonists’ homes ransacked rooms looking for evidence of treason against the Empire. The principle is also embodied in the , which prohibits the deployment of the federal armed forces to perform domestic law enforcement activities unless expressly authorized by Congress.

The military has a different role than the police. As a  during the George Floyd protests, “We’re a combat unit not trained for riot control or safely handling civilians in this context. Soldiers up and down the ranks are scared about hurting someone, and leaders are worried about soldiers’ suffering liability.” Police, on the other hand, regularly come into contact with people whose civil rights they are required to respect and uphold. This difference in role should be reflected in a difference of capabilities.

Preventing an “us versus them” mentality is all the more important when police departments across the country have been . While the overall percentage of white supremacists in law enforcement is , incidents of white supremacy within police forces across the country for decades  in the police, and with good reason: the presence of white supremacist affiliations and views in police departments has been found to  disproportionate policing of Black and brown communities as well as more use of force against those communities.

Many of the communities that police perceive as “them” are , not violent intervention. When police bring , for instance, they further damage an already tenuous relationship between their departments and their neighborhoods. As sociology professor and coordinator of the Policing and Social Justice Project at Brooklyn College Alex Vitale , “The alternative is not more money for police training programs, hardware or oversight. It is to dramatically shrink their function. We must demand that local politicians develop non-police solutions to the problems poor people face.”

So, yes, we should demilitarize the police because “when all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail.” We should ask police to make meaningful changes to how they interact with civilians instead of allowing them to use equipment built for war when engaging with the public. But we need to demilitarize the police because of militarization’s poisonous effect on policing culture. Today, the commonly understood duty of police — to “protect and serve” — is far too often replaced by a combative approach.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.