Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Governments and militaries routinely militarize against disease, offering unique consequences and justifying use of violence to contain it

Christopher Watterson and Adam Kamradt-Scott 2015 Fighting Flu: Securitization and the Military Role in Combating Influenza https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.1177/0095327X14567364//CDMoney

Militaries also stand to make significant contributions to pandemic response measures, where their capacity to marshal resources and expertise can ameliorate civil efforts to contain outbreaks. The onset of pandemics can rapidly overwhelm medical facilities, upset logistics and supply chains, interrupt essential services, and in severe cases lead to the breakdown of public order.123 The operational self-sufficiency, capacity to rapidly mobilize, and independent medical capabilities that are essential to armed forces will also make them preferred agents for emergency relief in the event of an influenza pandemic,124 particularly where the requirements of the emergency go beyond the standing capabilities of the public health sector, or fall outside the usual remit of such actors, for example in mollifying civil disobedience. In addition to their potential contributions to civil society, militaries also have an interest in building internal capacity to combat influenza. Historically, influenza has depleted military readiness through the incapacitation of soldiers, overwhelming of medical facilities, and disruption of military operations and logistics. Although advancements in preventative and palliative medicine have, to a large extent, reduced the threat that infectious disease poses to modern armies, the contingency of an influenza pandemic still presents a significant challenge to global military 158 Armed Forces & Society 42(1) readiness, given the ongoing threat of novel antigenic shifts and the low rates of influenza vaccination programs in national armed forces.125 Militaries therefore have a strong imperative to bring influenza into their planning and applied medicine regimes such that seasonal and pandemic incidents of influenza are to the greatest extent managed through existing mechanisms of military health without presenting an unacceptable burden to readiness. Beyond the more pragmatic concerns of military readiness, there also exists an ethical obligation on militaries to ensure that the health care needs of their armed forces are met, whether in times of peace or conflict. As Harrison observes, ‘‘service-people have come to demand health care as a right: as part of an implicit bargain between themselves and the military authorities.’’126 Inasmuch as influenza poses a threat to the personal well-being of soldiers, there is likely to be an expectation that militaries remain engaged in activities that will confer a superior measure of protection to those that they have enlisted into service. Recognizing the stake that modern militaries have in the fight against pandemic influenza, how then do we reconcile competing agendas regarding military involvement in public health for the greatest collective benefit of pandemic influenza preparedness and response? Arguably an important first step is to acknowledge the long and distinguished history of military involvement in influenza-related activities, a small proportion of which this article has sought to convey. In the context of the United States, where civil–military cooperation is deep rooted,127 the contribution of the military to both domestic and international influenza surveillance and control efforts appears to be well recognized. Beyond this, however, broader acceptance of the fact that militaries can make substantive contributions to national, regional, or global public health is often lacking—not only with public health communities but also by military forces themselves. There is also a genuine need to increase dialog between the public health and military communities, at both the national level and the international level. More than this though, the dialog must be of a particular type—namely, it must enable a greater understanding and appreciation of the goals and objectives of each respective group, where they compliment each other, and where they stand in contrast. Tension between these camps routinely arises from a perceived lack of neutrality of militaries, particularly in international engagements where broader geopolitical concerns can become entangled in the business of providing public health. Discordant expectations about the remit and chains of command in preparedness and response measures can also diminish the efficacy of civil–military responses to disasters, particularly when such arrangements are constructed on an ad hoc basis.128 Highlevel joint planning and a mutual recognition of respective operational strengths will provide some basis for reducing tensions and identifying which particular public health objectives of the state will benefit from the engagement of one or both parties. Concurrent with these efforts, there must also be a concerted attempt to extract military participation in health efforts from the broader debate surrounding the securitization of health issues. Securitization is, in many respects, merely a Watterson and Kamradt-Scott 159 discursive tool that policy makers may seek to employ in an attempt to elevate specific issues, thereby granting them greater importance and (ideally) obtaining additional resources that may not otherwise materialize. Importantly, however, as acknowledged by the Copenhagen School’s founders, securitization also has several associated dangers including closing down or severely constraining public debate, justifying extreme measures, even legitimizing the use of force.129 By way of contrast, as this article has sought to evidence, military participation in health is a legitimate—even necessary—intervention with a long and distinguished pedigree that has been repeatedly demonstrated to benefit public health and society more generally. Therefore, to facilitate a more balanced assessment of the contributions that militaries can bring to public health, the distinction between the practice and implications of the ‘‘militarization’’ and ‘‘securitization’’ of health needs to be recognized.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.