Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO’s militarization reduced trust and security in nations around the world

Naidu 00’ M.V. Naidu is an Indian politician serving as the 13th and current vice president of India since 2017. Previously, he served as the minister of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation, Urban development and Information and Broadcasting in the Modi Cabinet. THE UN, NATO AND REGIONAL CONFLICTS; A LEGAL AND POLITICAL ANALYSIS on JSTOR, Canadian Mennonite University, Feb. 2000, (https://www.jstor.org/stable/23607681?read-now=1&refreqid=excelsior%3A1bc59f1a6cf97e6336f75f45d0907055&seq=4)//BNB

By setting up antagonistic blocs, NATO undermined the UN principle of international co operation. By emphasizing military preparation and militarism, NATO did not pave the path for peaceful settlement of differences. of deterrence, the military alliances generated distrust and insecurity among the nations of the world. In legal terms NATO is claimed to be a system of collective self-defense permitted under Article 51 of the UN Charter. The NATO Treaty does not invoke Chapter VII; nor is collective self-defense specified under that chapter. In political terms, NATO was created as an anti-Communist alliance inspired by the Truman Doctrine of communist containment through military deterrence and means. However, certain provisions in the NATO Treaty satisfy some of the criteria of a regional arrangement under Chapter VII. The NATO Treaty promises to uphold the purposes and the principles of the UN. Under Article 1, NATO pledges to settle all disputes peacefully as required under Article 52 of the UN Charter. NATO acknowledges the primacy of the Security Council in matters of international peace and security. If the NATO members were sincere in their commitment to peaceful solutions, they would not have needed an alliance that is heavily loaded with militarization and militarism. IF the NATO states were honest about their dedication to international peace and security, they could have also created the UN collective security system envisaged in Chapter VII, instead of the sectarian NATO. NATO was patterned on the model of the Rio de Janero Treaty of 1947, which is called a regional arrangement. Articles 5, 6, 10, and 12 and paragraph 3 in the Preamble of the NATO treaty define the region as the “North Atlantic area.” But then the NATO members Greece and Turkey are not in the North Atlantic region; besides, Italy and Portugal were not even members of the UN in 1949, as was pointed out by the U.S.S.R. on 31 March 1949. A main argument against NATO being a regional arrangement in the fact that NATO has been claimed to be a scheme of collective self-defense, but according to Chapter VII of the Charter, self-defense is not a subject of regional arrangement. Legally, a collective self-defense scheme has certain fundamental differences from a collective security scheme of regional arrangements. self-defense by definition is protection of, by and for a particular state or states, and not an enforcement action to protect international peace and security. As an inherent right , self-defense is subjectively determined by the concerned state, whereas enforcement action under regional arrangement is based on objective determination by the Security Council. Self-defense, triggered off as soon as an armed attack on the victim state occurs, is unilateral. Collective enforcement by regional arrangement is to the based on the consent of authorization of the Security Council. Under Article 51 self-defense is strictly after-the-fact, i.e., after an armed attack has occurred. This prohibits aggression rationalized as self defense. But enforcement action by regional arrangement can be both anticipatory and after-the-fact. Under a regional arrangement enforcement can be intra-regional, but collective self-defense is organized against external forces, not against a member state of the regional alliance. Thus the collective self-defense scheme of NATO cannot make NATO a regional arrangement. Nor can NATO be legitimized under Article 51 as an approach to collective self-defense, because NATO’s scheme is anticipatory while Article 51 provides for defense only after an armed attack has occurred. Even is defense preparation is considered allowable under Article 51, predetermination of a potential enemy is not envisaged or permitted by Article 51. Further, Articles 3, 4, 5, and 6 of the NATO Treaty imply self-defense against an aggression from outside the NATO membership. Article 5 of the NATO Treaty refers to threats to “the territorial integrity, political independence or sovereignty” of the member states; Articles 5 and 6 mention “armed attack.” And Article 3 talks of resistance to armed attack from outside the NATO alliance.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.