Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Perm fails – aff diverts the discussion from the demilitarization of the police and coops the movement

Phillips 18 (Scott, Professor at the State University of New York College at Buffalo in the department of criminal justice, Police Militarization: Understanding the Perspectives of Police Chiefs, Administrators, and Tactical Officers (1st ed), Routledge, published in New York, May 30 2018)

The extensive media coverage over several days of the police tactical operation in Ferguson, and the Senate hearings examining the federal governments funding programs for police agencies, might portend substantive changes in policing and how they are organized. At the very least changes in tactical units, and how or when they are deployed, would be expected. Past research indicated, however, that unless this policing issue consistently remained in the spotlight for a period of time, the images of militarized police officers would simply fade from the public’s memory. The police might still enact minor symbolic adjustments in their policies or procedures, but whatever institutional status quo exists in policing would be maintained. The disruption in society between the public and the police would eventually return to its usual condition of quasi-stable equilibrium. The results of the survey data collected at the National Academy in 2015 demonstrated that, for the most part, this occurred in many American police agencies. Respondents reported that their agency continue to utilize tactical units as they have in the past. While there were some minor modifications in how these units are used, or the policies associated with them, the police chief and tactical officer interviews showed that these changes may occur for reasons contrary to the “organizational survival” that is characteristic of some organizational change (Meyer & Rowan, 1977). The chiefs and tactical officers argued that the components of militarization are merely tools that are occasionally required as part of policing’s role in society. Policing sees the existence of tactical units in law enforcement as perfectly reasonable. It was illuminating, however, to hear many of these chiefs and tactical officers articulate that sometimes “we are our own worst enemy.” They are aware that appearances matter, and that tactical units should be used in a judicious manner. These are the areas of change that were found in the surveys and interviews: a reduction in the use of tactical units for some types of warrants, keeping armored vehicles out of sight when they are not needed, doing a better job with transparency, and questioning the need for tactical units in some police agencies. The chiefs and tactical officers are unwilling, however, to expose themselves, their officers, or citizens to danger when handling the tasks expected of the public

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.