Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Militarism is entrenched in the Liberal Order, we must abolish the military industrial complex and the police institution

McMichael 16 (Christopher, PhD in Politics from Rhodes University, research include organized crime, Libertarian Marxism, and Fascism, “Pacification and Police: A critique of the Police Militarization Thesis,” November 29 2016, https://journals-sagepub-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/doi/full/10.1177/0309816816678569)

Despite the different political orientations which converge on the idea of militarization, it is notable how they all rely on a particular narrative about the nostalgic image of the ‘bobby on the beat’ or ‘ Officer Friendly’ being replaced by camouflage wearing brutes. Such imagery suggests that militarization is a problem because of its excessiveness (doors kicked in, armoured vehicles on the streets, officers faces hidden behind threatening helmets) – the implication being that more ‘ordinary forms’ of policing are warranted as long as it does not become excessive (). But what is often absent is that the ‘ordinary’ history of modern police institutions is itself a history of state repression, economic exploitation and structural racism. But even more importantly, police power’s intimate links with military power is in no way new or aberrational. As this article will stress, war and policing continually overlap and intertwine. This crucial relationship is often downplayed or completely omitted within much of the militarization literature. For example, much of the coverage of Ferguson focused on the newness of Special Weapons and Tactics (SWAT) Teams and no-knock warrants, frequently neglecting how these have historically been used against people of colour – ‘for blacks, the war on terror hasn’t come home. It’s always been here’ (). Correspondingly, tactics and expertise from imperial warfare have long fed into domestic policing in the United States – for instance, August Vollmer drew extensively on first-hand experience in brutal counter-insurgency in the Philippines, while ‘modernising’ police work in the early 20th century ().

But the problem with the militarization concept is not just conceptual, but political. The constant reiteration of a narrative in which the norms of policing are being superseded by aggressive new tactics and technologies rests on the assumption that there is a politically neutral and sociologically unbiased ideal of police which must be returned too. This is obvious in the case of some commentary: While focusing on the evils of the state, right libertarian commentaries avoid the central role of police power and violence in the fabrication of capitalist social relations – a gymnastics to be expected of a political ideology, which is based on critiquing state power while promoting unrestricted power for capital and private property (social relations that have historically been forged and protected by police power). But even more centrist liberal positions criticize excessiveness while nonetheless accepting the police as a fundamentally beneficent institution – such as the  report which suggests that the problem with militarization is that it distracts the police from their proper job. Even many radicals have problematically accepted the police mandate as one of ‘protecting and serving’; hence, the institution itself must be extricated from the bad elements of violence and abuse. When left of centre and even radical scholarly critique and alternative media accounts start to mirror critiques coming from mainstream media, state officials, and right-wing think tanks, then perhaps it is time to revisit the utility and force of normalized scholarly concepts. The fact that the mainstream media echoes the ‘militarization of the police’ mantra so easily and frequently should be a cause of concern for critical theory. In particular, the prominence of right libertarians highlights how the police militarization concept doesn’t entail an accompanying critique of the relation between capital and the police institution.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.