A) Reps first – failure to analyze their discursive constructions of the opposition between self and Other guarantee error replications and policy failure
Turner ’16 – Lecturer in International Relations at the University of Edinburgh
Oliver Turner, “China, India and the US Rebalance to the Asia Pacific: The Geopolitics of Rising Identities,” Geopolitics 21, no. 4 (2016): 922-944. Taylor and Francis.
A Genealogy of the Rebalance: Geopolitics, Postcolonialism, and the Politics of Identity
Logan, Swaine, Ross and others examine the US rebalance to the Asia Pacific in an unproblematic world in which the United States is responding to a selfevidently rising China. Yet these actors are not self-evident or unproblematic. Their realities (as threatening, benevolent, cooperative and so on) are subjectively defined, and socially and imaginatively constructed. Like the world they inhabit they are discursively spacialised or geo-graphed.12 The Asia Pacific for example was imagined into existence as recently as the 1970s, through the agglomeration of East and South East Asia.13 Peoples and places, moreover, are Othered from understandings of the self and for the self, with China historically existing in uncivilised, idealised, and anachronistic forms, among others, from the vantage point of the necessarily more ‘civilised’, ‘Enlightened’, ‘technological’ United States.14 This makes the relationship between self and Other inherently co-constitutive; “identity is constituted in relation to difference and [d]ifference is constituted in relation to identity”. 15
The United States’ contemporary geographical claims to the Asia Pacific, then, like all claims, are geopolitical because they inscribe Others with meanings which determine how they should be dealt.16 Discourse is thus not simply descriptive but performative in that it produces the effects that it names,17 fabricating global territories as sites of interest and material power. “Although often assumed to be innocent. . . geography [is]. . . a product of histories of struggle between competing authorities over the power to organize, occupy and administer space”. 18
In asking ‘how’ the rebalance is being enabled in its current form, the claim here is not that direct causal lines can be convincingly drawn between selected discourses and the implementation of policy. As Doty observes, the explanations of why questions are incomplete because they tend to take for granted the possibility that particular courses of action can happen, by presupposing the backgrounds of discursive meaning so central to that process. Asking ‘how’ is thus to examine how certain meanings are produced and attached to social subjects, creating discursive environments within which practices are made possible and others are precluded.19 The aim here then is to expose the discursive conditions which make ostensibly problematic or contradictory policies around the rebalance possible and which, as noted above, more traditional paradigms have difficulty explaining, through an analysis of the political history of the production of truth and knowledge about the ‘realities’ of China, the United States, India, and so on. It is to undermine the problematic self-evidences of the existing literature by revealing how rituals of power arise, take shape, gain importance, and affect contemporary politics.20 In tracing the genealogy of the rebalance, then, the expectation is not to locate its physical ‘origin’ in the rise of China, the Cold War or elsewhere. It is to explore the constitution of its knowledges through a ‘history of the present in terms of its past’, to show how ‘the present has become logically possible’. 21