Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The affirmative’s framework imposes language of war that standardizes militarization within debate and enforces a ceaseless cycle of violence

Marcinkevičienė 2011 (Rūta Marcinkevičienė, 8-25-2011, accessed on 7-13-2022, The Marketing of War in the Age of Neo-Militarism, "A Dangerous Language", )

Present-day authors continue talking about dehumanizing people and euphemising war along the same lines (i.e., focusing on indirectness and warning about the destructive power of such language). The author of The Language of War , Steve Thorn (2006), among other things, discusses how military discourse has entered mainstream language use. He also focuses on how language is used to construct opposing sides during armed conflict (Thorn 2006). A number of other authors such as linguists, discourse analysts and columnists mostly deal with two issues while talking about LW (i.e., its indirectness [cl. A twisted language of war ] and its influence on human minds and behavior). A natural question arises as to whether a direct LW exists. The most probable type of disourse would be military jargon reflecting the everyday reality of war. However, the experience provided by observers reveals the opposite. Military jargon is even more indirect than political discourse. The abundance of acronyms and abbreviations that hide full and direct names of weapons of mass destruction (e.g., nuclear weapons are called ABMs, SLCMs and MIRYs) (Bosmajian 1984) and euphemistic expressions with meaning hardly comprehensible for a lay outsider (e.g . , comic books : military maps, cracker box: field ambulance, chicken plate: chest protector [body armor] worn by helicopter gunners) (Bob Hersey’s K Troop 2009) as well as abstract nouns are prevailing features of military people’s language. “One hardly senses that war and killing are being discussed. The destruction of human life has been euphemized through using abstractions” (Bosmajian 1984). Thus, the specific disourse that could be sufficiently direct is reported to be indirect. Its negative effects are made explicit by Haig Bosmajian (1984): “Dehumanizing the enemy and euphemizing the weapons of war and war itself is a deadly combination that, unfortunately, has historically been successful in defending the indefensible.” He continues to explain that these two language behaviors together have the effect of a) making the reality of genuine violence invisible and b) making violence acceptable and even desirable when military terminology is metaphorically applied to everyday matters. The paradox of LW is that: “We have wars on everything now: poverty, child hunger, famine, debt, drugs, and even war. The only times we don’t seem to have war anymore is when we are actually involved in armed conflict. We have police actions, military interventions, occupying forces, peacekeepers, and peacemakers. They all involve the movement of troops, the firing of weapons, the destruction of property, and the loss of life the same as war does, but technically speaking, none of them are a state of war.” (Marcus 2006) In their famous book on metaphors, George Lakoff and Mark Johnson (1980) reveal how a concept of argument is verbalized in terms of war ( indefensible claims , to attack weak points , to shoot down somebody’s arguments ) and how the structure of an argument reflects this. They claim that the ‘argument is war’ metaphor “structures the actions we perform in arguing” (Lakoff and Johnson 1980, 4). Moreover, they suggest “to imagine a culture where an argument is viewed as a dance, the participants are seen as performers, and the goal is to perform in a balanced and aesthetically pleasing way. In such a culture, people would view arguments differently, experience them differently, carry them out differently, and talk about them differently.” They elaborate on the essense of conceptual metaphor that is “understanding and experiencing one kind of thing in terms of another” (Lakofff and Johnson 1980, 5). Some other authors, like Hardman (2002), go further and recognize the power of language for users of the war metaphor. The power manifests itself not only in understanding and experiencing reality, as stated by cognitive linguists, but also in accepting appropriateness of war: We clearly recognize the power of language. Nevertheless, we use a great deal of violent language in ordinary everyday speech quite oblivious of the way in which we are constructing our language to glorify war and violence and in that way make such violence appear appropriate even acceptable when it appears in reality. (Hardman 2002) He claims that the war metaphor plants seeds of violence and teaches the appropriateness of war. Authors who pursuade to drop the war metaphor (and not to fight against it) talk specifically about the ‘War on Terror’ metaphor. The metaphor appeared in the post-9/11 American-led narrative. As George Lakoff and Evan Frisch (2006) observe, the War on Terror metaphor was chosen by the Bush administration even though for a few hours after the towers fell on 9/11, administration spokesmen referred to the event as a crime . The authors argue that the frame of crime “would have involved international crime-fighting techniques” (Lakoff and Frisch, 2006). Once the war metaphor took hold, the real war started. According to Lakoff and Frish, “the war metaphor created a new reality that reinforced the metaphor.” That is fi nely tuned with Julie Redstone’s (2001) article about the new rhethorics and the labeling of national policy toward terrorism as ‘America’s New War.’ She further elaborates on the power of the war metaphor: “And it involves the choice of a particular language which shapes public opinion. The language of war is created long before the first plane takes off, long before the first missile is fired, long before the first soldier sets foot on foreign soil. It is created by a consciousness, whether individual or collective, that chooses war as the most effective response to threat. This choice, in turn, shapes the consciousness of a nation” (Redstone 2001). Cognitive linguists or any authors sensitive to language and its possible effects on human minds discourage against LW: “Locked in the language of war, it’s impossible to find another way out”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.