Demilitarization key to education – Change this goofy ass tag
Gwyn Kirk, 2018 has taught courses in women’s and gender studies at various US colleges and universities for nearly thirty years. She has written widely on ecofeminism and women’s peace organizing; coauthored work includes Greenham Women Everywhere, Women’s Lives: Multicultural Perspectives, and the documentary, Living along the Fenceline. Gwyn Kirk is a founding member of the International Women’s Network against Militarism, and Women for Genuine Security, the USbased partner in this Network. She is on the Steering Committee of Women Cross DMZ and a member of the Bay Area Comfort Women Justice Coalition. She holds a PhD in sociology from the London School of Economics.Demilitarization for Social Justice Gwyn Kirk Feminist Formations, Volume 30, Issue 3, Winter 2018, pp. 34-44 (Article)https://muse-jhu-edu.proxy.lib.umich.edu/article/705523/pdf//CDMoney
From 2014 to 2017, I taught an intensive January term course, Cultures of War and Peace, at St. Mary’s College of California, a Catholic liberal arts school. I wanted students to see that the United States is a highly militarized society, bolstered by massive corporate investments in military contracts and political support for high military spending, and to think about what could be gained, in terms of social justice and everyday security, by changing this. Students came into these classes with a wide range of knowledge and opinions. They had grown up on video games, war movies, mass shootings, and drone strikes. They had heard repeated assertions that war is “a necessary evil” or that “diplomacy doesn’t work.” Many believed that America (their term) is the “good guy” and strongly identified with the nation (“We went into Iraq . . .”). Two-thirds were young men, mostly first year students and mostly white. A few were veterans or enrolled in ROTC. Most had family members who had served in the military. Their affection and respect for these relatives made it difficult for many of them to question militarism as an institution. I provided a lot of information, which I hoped would help students contextualize and evaluate what they already knew. I emphasized the scale of US military spending, for example. This was $611 billion in 2016, more than the next eight countries combined.1 Over $700 billion is projected for 2019, over half the Federal discretionary budget.2 Yet we are told money is not available for public schools, Head Start, elder care, Veterans benefits, and many other socially useful programs that have been cut without remorse or apology. In researching Federal budget trade-offs many students were shocked to discover what their cities and counties could have bought with the money they contribute to the military.3 Some students felt the course was too negative about this country and war in general. They thought of themselves as realists—mature, pragmatic, and willing to accept “necessary evils.” They scorned moves toward demilitarization as idealistic. I asked what ideas and projects “realism” excludes, makes unsayable, or unimaginable? The course materials referenced the vast damage war and militarism cause.4 What is realistic about this? What might be useful about idealism? I wanted students to be able to question government policy and the role of the United States internationally. What does it mean to be American? Is there only one place to stand? How to widen the limited public discourse on Gwyn Kirk · 37 these issues? Could this country play a more constructive role internationally? If so, how should it do this? I wanted students to see that it is absolutely legitimate to desire something better than the current militarized, unsustainable state of the world. The college’s stated principles of social justice, religious faith, and respect for all persons created the space for a course like this. Even so, it was a hard sell. I discarded many readings I thought these students might dismiss as rhetorical. I tiptoed around feminist concepts like “militarized masculinity” (Enloe 2000, 235). I had to learn how to carry on this intensive discussion as a white woman older than their grandmas, with students I would probably not otherwise teach. I focus on militarism here, but those who teach about the impacts of globalization or the role of the nation-state face similar challenges. Liberal perspectives do not question the fundamental assumptions and institutions of our society, which is essential for addressing the root causes of injustice. By contrast, seeking equal access to combat roles or Senate seats, difficult as that may be, is a very limited goal. Further, many students know little about the effects of US policies on people in other nations, or how the United States exercises power worldwide—culturally, economically, politically, and militarily. Some students’ sense of patriotism made them highly resistant to thinking about such issues (Hase 2002). A few dismissed virtually all the course materials as “ridiculous rubbish,” “hippy nonsense,” or laughably naïve. In their papers, I commented that, in college, students’ work must engage with the ideas presented. You can rebut them but you can’t simply dismiss them with “put-downs” like this. I asked the group, If you find yourself feeling defensive about a reading or something said in class, what is being attacked? What is at stake for you? Could you respond with curiosity instead of feeling offended? What else would it help you to know? As a group, the students knew much more about war than they did about peace, a concept that seemed hazy and weak. We watched Facing Fear (Cohen 2013), featuring Tim Zaal, a former neo-Nazi skinhead, and Matthew Boger, the gay victim of Zaal’s hate-crime attack. Remarkably, these men met again twenty-five years after that incident. They were challenged to grapple with their feelings and fears about each other, and against the odds, they became friends. I asked students about their own experiences of forgiveness and reconciliation and what it takes to change their hearts and their behavior. We watched Regret to Inform by Barbara Sonneborn (2000), who visited Vietnam to learn about other widows’ experiences twenty years after her husband was killed there. Vietnamese women were touched by this and thanked her for wanting to know how they’d coped with the devastation of that war in their own land—a small moment of personal reconciliation between women who had been defined as enemies. A guest speaker, formerly in the Navy and now a youth worker, explained why and how he became a conscientious objector. Students read about US Army veterans who knelt before indigenous elders at Standing Rock and apologized for US wars against their people. They read about community truth-telling efforts as part of healing from violence and conflict, and about dedicated behind-thescenes work to hammer out agreements between groups or nations. Following Enloe (2000), I emphasized demilitarization as a step-by-step process rather than peace as a static condition. Nations may become more or less militarized, depending on many factors. Creating Resources for Teaching and Learning Thanks to Franklin Graham, our first editor, Margo Okazawa-Rey and I were able to include a chapter on women and the military in Women’s Lives: Multicultural Perspectives. This focuses on militarism as a central institution in this country. It considers how militarism deploys gender and race, the impact of war and US bases on women overseas, and it discusses feminist opposition to militarism and war. Although not all teachers who use the book assign this chapter, the increase in militarization, especially since 9/11, makes it a salient topic for an introductory course. Another resource is Living along the Fenceline, a low-budget documentary featuring grassroots women leaders from Okinawa (Japan) to Texas and Puerto Rico (Hoshino, Kirk, and Lee 2012). Although not considered war zones, these strategic sites are part of a network of roughly 1,000 overseas bases that allow the United States to go to war anytime, anywhere. These women are not fourstar generals or White House strategists. Their expertise comes from living with the effects of militarism on a daily basis. Director Lina Hoshino focused on women’s stories. She filmed barbed wire fences around the bases, DANGERKEEP OUT signs, fighter jets zooming overhead, and the grassy spot in a park where a woman was raped by soldiers and tells us, this is where it happened. Despite different locations, the film shows recurring patterns: gender-based violence, environmental destruction, the impacts of colonization, and the importance of women’s organizing and leadership. Our goal was to affirm each woman’s work in responding to the US military presence in her backyard, and to show the possibility of a very different kind of security centered on respect for people and the land. I have helped to organize antimilitary fashion shows as a way to discuss militarism in accessible terms (Ahn and Kirk 2009). The Women of Color Resource Center staged the first one at a standing-room-only event in Oakland in 2005 featuring original designs as well as street “camo” and demo wear (Enloe 2007). As models walked the “runway,” a narrator read a script describing each outfit.5 Feminist scholar Cynthia Enloe talked about the military origins of khaki. Spoken word artists and musicians added to the event’s energy and political analysis. Since then, various groups have put on their own versions of this show. Local artists and designers, thrift-store bargain hunters, and people handy with a needle, glue gun, stapler, or duct tape have made remarkable outfits: Bomb Gown, Military Carbon Footprint, Bikini, Respirator Bra, Fence Dress, War Is Not Sexy, People’s Budget, Uncle Spam, and more. These shows can be theatrical events as in Oakland and at the University of Oregon, or pared down as part of a talk or workshop. Much of the excitement is in designing original outfits and scripts that encapsulate the stories people want to tell. Another community project was an event at the Comfort Women memorial in San Francisco. This memorial, located in a public park, commemorates some 400,000 young women forced into sexual slavery by the Japanese Imperial Army from 1931 to 1945 (McGrane 2017).6 For International Women’s Day 2018, members of local groups created altars representing other examples of systemic violence against women—in addition to the plight of WWII comfort women—and celebrating resistance to it: • missing and murdered indigenous women, • women victims of war and drone strikes, • migrant women crossing the US-Mexico border, • women impacted by US military bases in Asia, • violence against Palestinian women living under Israeli occupation, and • violence against trans women in this country. In each case, soldiers, prison guards, police officers, or Border Patrol have assaulted, raped, and killed women or gender nonconforming people. This may be based on state policy as with WWII comfort women, or on militarized assumptions and cultures of law enforcement that condone, justify, or encourage gender-based violence. Those in authority may ignore these crimes. They may refuse to believe survivors’ testimony, close down public discussion, and cover up evidence. Culprits may be promoted, protected, or let off with a slap on the wrist. These factors make it imperative for feminists to speak out about such issues in public and demand that they be stopped. It was moving to see the care with which women had created their altars, placing photos and women’s names among flowers, candles, and colorful fabrics.7 Participants made brief presentations about these items as a way to explain each issue and to recognize the work of organizations that oppose these blatant violations of women’s human rights. Sharing these harrowing stories was an inspiring way to connect struggles across racial, ethnic, and national lines—an opportunity for learning, networking, and affirming shared beliefs about social justice and human integrity. Contexts and Frameworks In my experience, teaching for social justice requires focus and patience. It takes work to go against the grain. It may carry unacceptable personal and professional risks, especially for those responsible for children and other family members. As well as personal conviction, feminist scholars and teachers also need contexts that sustain us in this work. I am grateful for the support and encouragement I have received over the years from department chairs, colleagues, students, editors, and publishers. Also, I have benefitted enormously from working with Women for Genuine Security, a small but vibrant political community that is part of the International Women’s Network Against Militarism (Cachola et al. 2010).8 As teachers concerned with social justice, we are up against the teachings of the corporate media, right-wing talk shows, the stereotypes circulating in news reports and popular culture, and the echo chamber of social media. An iconic figure like Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. has been reduced to a “dreamer” by the news networks, while his hard-hitting speech linking “the giant triplets of racism, materialism, and militarism” is far less well known (King 1967). We are up against endless distractions, shorter attention spans, the price of tuition and textbooks, and other economic pressures students face. We are up against everyday psychological explanations that see inequality and injustice in terms of low-self esteem, poor identity development, learned helplessness, or a few “bad apples” that spoil the barrel. We juggle these considerations as we construct our courses, create assignments, and help students to absorb class materials, including structural analyses necessary to explain these systems of oppression.9 As well as identifying complexities and contradictions, intersectional feminist theorizing reminds us that academia was not set up to promote social justice, despite the development of fields like ethnic studies, women’s and gender studies, and queer studies that embrace this goal. As National Women’s Studies Association (NWSA) members know, these programs were created as a result of strong social movements and student demands. Determined faculty members generated the intellectual rationale for them. They negotiated with university administrators, got curriculum committees to approve courses, made connections across academic departments, and so on. In turn, they have needed Deans willing to validate such programs and direct resources to them. In the past twenty years, the political climate for WGS on campuses and in the wider society has become more challenging as misogynist, racist, and xenophobic viewpoints have gained ground through official rhetoric, legislation, policy, and the narrowing of public discourse. Increasingly, faculty members may face challenges to their teaching methods and course content; their work may be written off as “biased,” unscholarly, or politically motivated (Nisenson 2017). Indeed, such attacks on academic freedom have made many teachers’ lives more difficult, in some cases seriously affecting their physical and mental health, even leading to dismissal. Also, academic institutions have become increasingly beholden to corporate funding and values. Budget cuts, department mergers, and the fact that two-thirds of faculty are on part-time or temporary contracts these days all affect the organization and viability of interdisciplinary programs like women’s and gender studies. These turbulent times make the political nature of education explicit. It is crucial that we organize collectively on campuses and in communities to support teaching for social justice, and that we are part of strong, vocal, professional organizations that also do this. Tenured or tenure-track faculty must challenge the normalization of contingent labor and the professional and economic vulnerability of the many teachers hired on short-term contracts (Betensky 2017). As a community of feminist scholars and teachers, we must support those whose work is threatened by conservative voices and organizations on and off campus. We should help support feminist activist writers who have contributed to scholarship, teaching, and course materials over the years without regular remuneration for this. We should urge other professional associations to do the same. I believe our job as feminist scholars and teachers is to think big, to help provide spaces where students and community members can confront current challenges, and where they are affirmed as people who care about social justice, not based on guilt or pity, but as part of a “common context of struggle.”10 Ethnic studies, women’s and gender studies, and queer studies programs have all contributed to such understandings and communities of praxis. A silver lining in this wild time is that even as some political spaces are being closed down, new social movements are opening up others. The strong tradition of organizing for social justice in this country as well as the many efforts currently underway need to be much better known. They provide lessons, models, and inspiration. We cannot afford to despair or to nurture despair in others. We must continue to work for and hold out the possibility of progressive change even as past gains are being attacked and unraveled. In this regard, the 2018 NWSA conference theme, Just Imagine, Imagining Justice, is well chosen. A focus on values, beliefs, and visions is much needed in these challenging times. In October 2018, a Women’s March on the Pentagon seeks to refocus national attention on the immense costs of militarism at home and abroad.11 The organizers highlight the fact that both major political parties support war and militarism, and see the March as a call for a radical redefinition of security. Working for social justice means taking on the world as it is currently constructed. We need all our passion, creativity, skills, life experience, and the conviction that things can and must be organized differently, based on justice and love. How does your work contribute to such a vision? Who and what inspire you to do it? Who are your allies and accomplices? How do you cope with the challenges you face? What new processes, tools, and understandings do we need to create, as feminist scholars and teachers, to help us move forward?