Militarization causes climate change and there can be no real ecological protection in the world of the aff.
Jorgenson 2012. Andrew Jorgenson is Professor and Chair in the Department of Sociology, Professor of Environmental Studies, and coordinates the Global Environmental Sociology Lab at Boston College. Jorgenson, Andrew K., et al. "The environmental impacts of militarization in comparative perspective: an overlooked relationship." Nature and Culture, vol. 7, no. 3, winter 2012, pp. 314+. Gale Academic OneFile, link.gale.com/apps/doc/A313972354/AONE?u=umuser&sid=bookmark-AONE&xid=c3de5be4.
War has long contributed to ecological degradation, including the diversion of rivers, scorched earth practices, the destruction of plants and animals, oil spills, the burning of oil wells, and the use of chemical and biological weapons. The atmospheric testing of atomic and nuclear bombs produced radioactive fallout that spread throughout the world via wind, water, and living creatures (Commoner 1967, 1971). In fact, the detonation of Trinity--the first atomic explosion--in the New Mexico desert on 16 July 1945 ushered in the nuclear era, which coincides with the age of ecology (Hagen 1992; Worster 1998). The environmental impacts of militarization are not limited to war and the testing of nuclear weapons. Military institutions, often in the name of national security and geopolitical circumstances, have created large-scale built and social infrastructures to sustain and support the coercive power of nations. Advances in military technologies, the resource demands to maintain the social and built infrastructures of militaries, the testing of machinery and weapons, and the of soldiers and weapons to distant places have increased the overall ecological and environmental impacts of the world's militaries (Clark and Jorgenson 2012). As a result of these activities, "the world's armed forces are the single largest polluter on earth" (Renner 1991: 132). In what follows we direct attention to the relationships between the environment and the world's national militaries. We present a general discussion of the treadmill of destruction theory, a sociological perspective that highlights the expansionary tendencies and environmental impacts of militarism. We then offer a brief account of recent military developments and expenditures, with a focus on the ascent of the military in the . Following this discussion, we examine how the growth and structure of militarization contributes to an array of environmental impacts. We conclude by calling for future sociological research to seriously consider the environmental impacts of the world's militaries. In this call we suggest fruitful avenues for future research, while recognizing some of the unique challenges faced by those who do research on the effects of the world's militaries on the environment. "Militarization" is recognized as "the single most ecologically destructive human endeavor" (Gould 2007: 331). Yet, with few exceptions, the environmental impacts of militarism and militarization are mostly overlooked in environmental sociology and other environmental social sciences. The general inattention to such relationships, given the scale and range of influence, is problematic. Military preparedness impinges--in a highly deleterious fashion--on the nation's physical environment and, all too often, that of their neighbors as well. From depleting resources, eroding the physical environment, destroying natural flora and fauna, or leaving behind a vast array of toxins and radioactive elements, all aspects of military activity defile our environment in some way. (Singer and Keating 1999: 326). Military operations, land holdings, forces, and production facilities are often exempt from environmental laws, at home and abroad, "in the name of national security" (Gould 2007: 331; Singer and Keating 1999: 327). Within sociology, the treadmill of destruction perspective examines how the expansionary dynamics and structure of militarism produce profound environmental impacts (Hooks and Smith 2004, 2005). This theoretical approach is influenced by and related to the treadmill of production tradition within environmental sociology, which is one of the area's foundational orientations. Thus, prior to discussing the treadmill of destruction perspective, we first provide a brief description of the treadmill of production theory. The treadmill of production theory posits that environmental degradation and are an inherent part of (Schnaiberg 1980; Schnaiberg and Gould 1994). Given that a capitalist economy is predicated on the constant pursuit of profit and expansion, its operations have "direct implications for natural resource extraction," the generation of pollution, and the overall state of environmental conditions (Gould et al. 2004: 297). The economy generates ecological problems, as it must continually withdraw resources from the environment to produce goods and power machinery, and such activities inevitably generate waste. The state, while often caught in contradictory positions, is an important social institution that supports economic expansion through negotiating trade agreements, bailing out industry and banking, promoting military spending, and protecting private property. According to treadmill of production scholars, the growth imperative of creates an "enduring conflict" between human societies and the environment (Schnaiberg and Gould 1994). Nature--in the form of matter and energy--is used to fuel industry and to produce commodities for the market. "As societies increase their production," Schnaiberg (1980: 20) pointed out, "they 'discover' resources and 'create' new products." Each expansion in the production process creates a higher level of demand for from , often at rates that exceed the regenerative capacity of these systems, in order to sustain economic operations on a larger and more intensive scale (Gould et al. 2008; see also Foster 2005). Ecosystems are actively transformed to meet the needs of the economic system, which contributes to ecological disorganization (Schnaiberg 1980). Producers attempt to externalize environmental costs as much as possible, as this has the potential to enhance profits. From this perspective, there is a strong relationship between economic development and , and this applies to both developed nations and developing nations (Jorgenson and Clark 2012). Hooks and Smith (2004, 2005) argue that while the military is linked to the economy, it is not simply a derivative of the latter. Militarism has its own distinct expansionary dynamics and produces specific forms of environmental degradation, part and parcel of the treadmill of destruction. Primarily for geopolitical reasons, states declare and wage wars (Mann 1998; Tilly 1990). Militaries are institutions that actively seek to shape and control information to secure funding and to expand their infrastructure (Bond 2011). As nations attempt to maintain and increase power, it spurs military development, which increases the lethality and ferocity of conflict (Tilly 1990). At the same time, these military developments increase the scale, intensity, and danger of environmental degradation (Hooks and Smith 2004). Militarism produces a treadmill of destruction that effectively restricts . The focus of the military in relation to the environment is made clear by a US military base commander, who, when responding to citizen's concerns about pollution, stated: "We are in the business of protecting the nation, not the environment" (Renner 1991: 152; see also Clark and Jorgenson 2012). Geopolitical competition often drives arms races as well as attendant technological advances, infrastructural development, and growth in troop size. The environmentally damaging capabilities of militaries, especially for developed nations, are partly a function of technological developments with weaponry and other machinery (Jorgenson 2005; Jorgenson and Clark 2009; Jorgenson et al. 2010). Capital-intensive militaries employ advanced weaponry and utilize state-of-the-art transportation systems to facilitate the rapid movement of troops and to enhance the strike capabilities of nations, including an extensive system of vehicles and infrastructure to aid in the deployment of equipment and personnel (Clark et al. 2010). Further, capital-intensive militaries are likely to increase their material infrastructure or become more spatially dispersed, bringing more land under their operations (Kentor et al. 2012). The structure and organization of the military requires access to and consumption of vast amounts of resources, such as oil, to maintain its basic operations. The growth dynamics of militarism further expand the treadmill of destruction, increasing the overall environmental demands of and degradation caused by this institution (Clark and Jorgenson 2012; Jorgenson and Clark 2009). International superpowers have historically used part of the social surplus generated through economic dominance to invest in military development (Hooks and McLauchlan 1992; Kentor 2000). Domestic politics, the position of nations within the global interstate system, and actual and perceived threats shape the course of military development. During the twentieth century, technological, political, economic, and ideological changes contributed to the ascendancy of the military into the power elite (Mills 2000). These changes expanded the influence and scale of militaries, deeply rooting the treadmill of destruction within national and international politics. The discussion that follows is largely focused on the military within the United States, in part due to the predominance of this nation's military within the world and the magnitude of annual military spending of this country. However, it is important to note that recent scholarship has extended the treadmill of destruction perspective to the comparative-international level. Multiple cross-national and longitudinal studies within sociology indicate that the relative size (i.e., military participation rate) and technological capacity (i.e., military expenditures per solider) of nations' militaries both contribute to growth in energy consumption (Clark et al. 2010), carbon dioxide (Jorgenson et al. 2010; York 2008), and overall resource consumption in the form of the ecological footprints of nations (Jorgenson 2005; Jorgenson and Clark 2009, 2011). These cross-national studies and their results indicate that the environmental impacts of national militaries are far beyond trivial, net of other human drivers of pollution and degradation, including levels of economic development, size, , manufacturing levels, and various forms of globalization. Furthermore, and in the context of generalizability, many of these studies indicate that the environmental impacts of national militaries are observable for samples of all countries as well as for samples restricted to only developed countries and only (e.g., Jorgenson and Clark 2009; Jorgenson et al. 2010). Figure 1 is a scatter plot that illustrates the relationship between carbon dioxide emissions per capita and military expenditures per soldier (i.e., technological capacity of national militaries), both presented in logarithmic form. These data include observations of 72 nations from 1970 to 2000 in five-year increments (i.e., 1970, 1975 ... 1995, 2000). Military expenditures per soldier is calculated by dividing total military expenditures by total military personnel. Figure 2 is a scatter plot that illustrates the association between carbon dioxide emissions per capita and military participation rate (i.e., relative size of national militaries), both in logarithmic form, and for the same nations and time points as in Figure 1. Military participation is the ratio of military personnel per 1,000 people in the general population. These data in both figures are the same data analyzed by Jorgenson et al. (2010). (1) Consistent with treadmill of destruction theory, Figure 1 indicates that the association between per capita carbon dioxide emissions and military expenditures per solider is positive and strong in magnitude (correlation = 0.802), while Figure 2 suggests that the relationship between per capita emissions and military participation rate is also positive and moderately strong (correlation = 0.486). Both world wars in the twentieth century resulted in an unprecedented scale of destruction, in part due to the use of new, more deadly weapons. C. Wright Mills (2000) explains that following the Second World War the military joined the economic and political elite in the United States. He indicates that other historical developments and transformations in the social order facilitated the ascent of the military into the power elite. The scale of military operations--including troops, equipment, and the theater of war--had greatly expanded. The military catalyzed scientific research and development, especially in the production of high-tech equipment and the development of new weapons. In fact, technological innovation became closely linked to the weapons industry (Galbraith 1998: 257). The expansion of the military provided economic benefits for powerful segments within industry due to armament and other military contracts. The destructive potential of nuclear weapons elevated military matters, increasing the influence of the military in both the state and the economy within the United States. The power elite increasingly adopted a "military definition of reality" (Mills 2000: 198). Due to geopolitics and the ascendancy of the military, the overall expenditures on military and expenditures per soldier continued to increase, helping create a permanent war economy. Figure 3 provides the total annual military expenditures (defined as the "total military budget") for the United States for the 1900 to 2007 period, while Figure 4 provides the annual expenditures per soldier (2) for the same range of years. These data, which are reported in 1990 international Geary-Khamis dollars (3) and thus adjusted for inflation, were obtained from the Correlates of War online data set (www.correlatesofwar.org/). As indicated by Figure 3, total military expenditures increased from $439,960 in 1900 to $649,800,000,000 in 2007. Turning briefly to Figure 4, military expenditures per soldier increased from approximately $3 in 1900 to $431,460 in 2007. In 1961, President Dwight Eisenhower noted that following the Second World War the United States, and by extension the world, had entered a new era of militarism. Prior to this period, domestic industrial operations were redirected to support the war effort during times of conflict. Geopolitical competition and the ascent of the military helped create "a permanent armaments industry of vast proportions" and an expansive military structure that included millions of enlisted soldiers. While Eisenhower is known for warning against the "unwarranted influence" of the military-industrial complex--a concept that had been introduced in the late 1940s (Riefler 1947)--he also upheld the imperative need for its development (Eisenhower 1961). The ascent of the military increased the interaction and traffic between the corporate and military realms. Mills (2000: 213) indicates that following the Second World War, "[m]ilitary demands continued to shape and to pace the corporate economy," especially given major military contracts. What is more, "military production helped prop up the entire economic edifice in the United States, and was a factor holding off economic stagnation" (Foster 2006: 110). In reflecting on the interconnections between the power elite, the expanding military budget, and the growth imperative of the larger system, Charles H. Anderson (1976: 76-77) explained, "Military spending is ideally suited to the growth system since it pumps money into private production, redistributes income upward, and always finds an outlet, that is, there is never enough military power or sophisticated enough military hardware." The expansion in military spending wedded "big science" to the military in the United States (and elsewhere), as research and development were geared to addressing the specialized technological needs for advanced military performance (Hooks and McLauchlan 1992). The military directed social resources to designing, developing, testing, and deploying superior vehicles, planes, boats, and weapons for national security and potential use in future conflicts. The new equipment was made of special materials, corresponding to advances in weapons. These technological developments have made the military more capital- and material-intensive (Shaw 1988). Technological advances allow the military to move massive amounts of equipment and soldiers throughout the world more easily, covering more land in less time (Collins 1981). These advances have increased the expense of military operations, especially the costs associated with operating special equipment such as aircraft carriers, planes, helicopters, and tanks. Such trends encourage the international arms race between the global powers, as novel technologies and weapons set a new standard for warfare (Clark and Jorgenson 2012). While the military (i.e., the treadmill of destruction) is connected to the economy (i.e., the treadmill of production) in complex ways, given the military-industrial complex, it also generates its own growth dynamics that require immense amounts of capital, supplies of energy, and other raw materials to sustain its operations (Clark et al. 2010; Jorgenson and Clark 2009). Figure 5 provides primary energy consumption (coal, petroleum, electricity, and natural gas) for the United States, measured in thousands of coal-ton equivalents, for every twenty years (i.e., 1900, 1920 ... 1980, 2000) from 1900 to 2000, as well as for the year 2007. These data were also obtained from the Correlates of War online data set. The consumption of such energy sources leads to increases in greenhouse gas emissions and thus contributes to climate change (IPCC 2007). As indicated by Figure 5, primary energy consumption in the United States increased from 256,081 thousands of coal-ton equivalents in 1900 to 5,548,023 thousands of coal-ton equivalents in 2007, and the general pattern of the increase is quite similar to the upward trajectories for both military expenditures measures in Figures 3 and 4. Militarism contributes to environmental degradation during times of war and peace. The environmental and public health harms associated with war are more obvious, so we provide only a few examples to illustrate the range of impacts. Biological and chemical weapons contaminate ecosystems and devastate landscapes. Agent Orange was used to defoliate the during the Vietnam War, polluting the land and water and causing significant health problems for citizens of Vietnam and US soldiers. More recently, depleted uranium has been used in the manufacturing of bullets, shells, and bombs. This material contributes to the contamination of the land during and following war and presents serious health risks for human and animal populations (Birchard 1998; Sanders 2009; White 2008). Waging war also produces a broad range of debris that accumulates as pollution within the nations where war is being waged, as well as at the military bases used in the military campaign. Debris, in this particular case, includes fuel deposits, ammunition dumps, drums filled with oil and solvents, asphalt, grease, paint, tires, cables, unexploded munitions, gunpowder, and fiberboard. These materials introduce an array of chemicals and other toxins into ecosystems that will continue to harm both flora and fauna unless a "clean operation" is conducted (Lanier-Graham 1993). Military campaigns consume enormous amounts of fossil (and nuclear) fuels in planes, ships, and tanks (Grimes 1999; Klare 2002; Lanier-Graham 1993; Marshall 2005; Pellow 2007; Thomas 1995). Michael Klare (2007) indicates that the US military consumes at least 1.3 billion gallons of oil annually in the Middle East alone--more than the annual consumption of Bangladesh. Such levels of fossil fuel use contribute to the global accumulation of carbon dioxide emissions and thus cause climate change (IPCC 2007). War also contributes to and the loss of wildlife habitat, as people attempt to rebuild what was lost during the conflict (Lanier-Graham 1993). Too often the environmental impacts of militarism are overlooked. This situation is especially true in terms of the expansionary dynamics and environmental impacts of militarism during periods of peace (Clark and Jorgenson 2012). The constant preparation for future conflicts by vested military interests and persistent geopolitical concerns escalate the scale and operations of militaries. As a result, the treadmill of destruction expands even in the absence of armed conflict. Military institutions and their activities consume vast amounts of nonrenewable energy and other resources for research and development, maintenance, and operation of the overall infrastructure (Dycus 1996; Jorgenson 2005; Jorgenson et al. 2010; Sidel and Shahi 1997; York 2008). At the same time, military operations generate large amounts of toxic substances and waste, which contribute to the contamination of land and water. The testing of nuclear weapons released strontium-90, iodine-131, and other radioactive isotopes directly into the environment, leading to the bioaccumulation of these materials throughout the food web (Commoner 1967; Hastings 2000; LaDuke 1999; Shulman 1992; Ward 1999). Other hazardous toxins are introduced into the environment through the production, storage, transportation, and disposal of biological and chemical weapons (Lanier-Graham 1993). In the 1940s, the Hanford Project was built in the state of Washington in the United States to manufacture nuclear weapons. Nuclear reactors were used to produce plutonium. When this plant was decommissioned, there remained millions of gallons and cubic feet of radioactive waste. The groundwater in the area is contaminated. This site, located along the Columbia River, is generally deemed to be one of the most polluted sites in the world (McNeill 2000). Likewise, Rocky Mountain Arsenal, also within the United States, which manufactured chemical weapons, remains a Superfund site, as the "by-products from the production of mustard gas, napalm, incendiary weapons, and other types of munitions were dumped on the land for decades" (Lanier-Graham 1993: 80). Pesticides, solvents, mercury, lead, and arsenic also contaminate this land. These toxins are known to pollute groundwater. Military bases throughout the world have been identified as sites of toxic contamination, and in the 1960s and 1970s, millions of gallons of radioactive waste were dumped by the US Navy into Pearl Harbor (LaDuke 1999: 173). Singer and Keating (1999: 330-331) detail how military preparedness includes use of "rare and poisonous metals such as titanium, beryllium, germanium, cobalt, thallium, and depleted uranium," which "are extremely toxic to extract and refine." These materials, as well as other potentially dangerous chemicals, are often exclusively employed in the production of military goods. Part of the everyday operation and maintenance of military equipment includes the use of a broad range of thinners, solvents, lubricants, degreasers, fuels, pesticides, and propellants. As a result, "the Department of Defense . generates 500,000 tons of toxic waste annually, more than the top five US chemical companies combined, and it is estimated that the armed forces of the major world powers produce the greatest amount of hazardous waste in the world" (Singer and Keating 1999: 338). Thus, "the most ecologically devastated locations on Earth" are found wherever "military production facilities" operate (Gould 2007: 331). Armed forces have used a steadily increasing amount of land for bases, other installations, and training exercises over the last century ( Center for Disarmament 1982). The end of the Cold War did not reduce the use of public lands for military operations, training, testing, and exercises (Singer and Keating 1999). In 2003, the United States alone had over 900 military bases located domestically and operated over 700 military bases in 130 countries (Johnson 2004). By 2007, there were over 800 US military bases overseas (Sanders 2009). A network of military bases encompasses the globe, requiring a vast amount of and other resources to staff, operate, and transport equipment and personnel between destinations. Even with advanced technologies, military operations require bases close to theaters of action to supply energy and personnel needs (Collins 1981). To a significant extent military power remains dependent upon access to land (Foster 2006; Jorgenson and Clark 2009). Militaries must have ready supplies of raw materials and energy as well as the infrastructure to support their operations and to meet the needs of their personnel. Consequently, military-oriented resource use involves strategic stockpiling of munitions, spare parts, fossil fuels, and other ancillary equipment to sustain its operations. The resource consumption of the military is further increased by that produce marginal equipment for the armed forces and their support economies (Jorgenson 2005). The production of such marginal equipment and stockpiling of fuels places greater demands upon the environment. The populations of armed forces also use large quantities of materials for uniforms and specialized forms of clothing that would not otherwise be consumed. Furthermore, the labor intensity of militaries increases the resources required for training, armaments, transportation, and the of troops and support personnel (Jorgenson and Clark 2009; Jorgenson et al. 2010). During regular operations, including peacetime activities, the armed forces consume large amounts of fossil fuels, adding to the accumulation of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere (Jorgenson et al. 2010; Roberts et al. 2003). Vaclav Smil (2000) points out that the three branches of the US military consumed approximately 25 million tons of fuel per year in the 1990s, excluding energy consumed in both the Gulf War and the bombing of Kosovo. He indicates that this amount was "more than the total commercial energy consumption of nearly two thirds of the world's countries" (Smil 2000: 38). The high consumption of fossil fuels is, in part, a reflection of the high-tech equipment employed by the armed forces. Additionally, soldiers must be constantly trained to use this equipment, and the high-tech machinery and vehicles must be tested. Planes, helicopters, ships, tanks, and armed vehicles all require enormous amounts of oil to make them move--not to mention the various ancillary infrastructures that are required for their operation, such as air strips, roads, and supply vehicles. For example, one hour of operation of a nonnuclear aircraft carrier consumes 21,300 liters (over 5,621 gallons) of fuel; large, high-tech military helicopters burn 5 gallons of fuel for every mile that they travel; and fighter planes, such as the F-15 and F-16, consume between 1,500 and 1,700 gallons of fuel per hour. If their afterburners are used, up to 14,400 gallons are exhausted per hour (Cutler 1989; Renner 1997: 120; Sanders 2009; Smith 2003). Renner (1997: 120) states that "a modern battle tank's fuel consumption is so voracious that it is better measured in gallons per mile than in miles per gallon." Of the top ten fuel guzzlers, eight of them are support vehicles that carry fuel and supplies. Only two are combat vehicles--the Apache helicopter and the M-1 Abrams tank (Karbuz 2007). As the military pursues "bigger, faster, and more sophisticated weapons, fuel efficiency continues to plummet" (Smith 2003). Superior combat performance of equipment is a greater priority than energy efficiency for military institutions. In the 1980s, "nearly a quarter of all jet fuel" was consumed by militaries throughout the world; and approximately three-quarters of the petroleum used by the armed forces fuels vehicles, aircrafts, sea vessels, and other forms of warfare machinery (Renner 1991, 1997: 120). The Pentagon has the largest fleet of high-tech military equipment, which is fueled almost entirely by oil. According to Klare (2007), it is perhaps the "leading consumer of petroleum" in the world. Figure 6 provides the results of Jorgenson et al.'s (2010) cross-national longitudinal study of per capita carbon dioxide emissions (emissions resulting primarily from fossil fuel consumption) for 72 nations from 1970 to 2000. The reported coefficients, which are all statistically significant, are estimated from fixed effects regression analysis and standardized, allowing for comparisons of the relative magnitude of the effects of the explanatory variables. Of particular relevance, the effects of both military variables are positive and larger in magnitude than the effect of manufacturing as percent of total gross domestic product (GDP). These results also hold in analyses restricted to just developing nations as well as for analyses of total carbon emissions. Besides directly contributing to carbon emissions through the consumption of fossil fuels, militarization appears to influence the willingness and timing of nations to ratify environmental treaties. In a recent cross-national study, Givens (2012) employs event history analysis techniques and finds that higher levels of militarization, in the context of both military expenditures and military participation rates, are associated with longer periods of time until ratification and/or failure to ratify the Kyoto Protocol. Along these lines, Christoff (2008) explores how the United States' position as a global "superpower," with unrivaled military and economic power, did not exempt it from censure when it refused to agree to the proposed text at the Bali climate conference. He also explores how the economic and military positions of the United States and China in the global system influence their actions on climate negotiations and notes the importance of the United States' internal budgetary issues and external attempts to retain military supremacy in shaping climate discussions (Christoff 2010). In conclusion, we forcefully assert that the environmental impacts of the nation's militaries must be seriously considered in future research on the anthropogenic drivers of environmental harms. Doing so will not be easy, but this broader perspective is imperative given that global climate change and unsustainable resource consumption are among the most serious challenges currently facing the world.