The aff uses perfect deterrence theory, that can enable demilitarization AND strengthening security.
Chong Woo 20 – KIM CHONG WOO, Author and Attorney at Kim & Chang, 2020 (“Implications of Perfect Deterrence Theory for South Korea” Asan Institute for Policy Studies, September 1st, Available online at https://www.jstor.org/stable/resrep26115.3?seq=1#metadata_info_tab_contents, accessed 07/22/22
Perfect Deterrence Theory has been developed as an alternative to classical deterrence theory. We have become interested in the theory as it seems to be aesthetically more appealing than classical deterrence theory. It provides another way of looking at deterrence but, this time, without its internal structure plagued by logical inconsistency. As Frank Zagare & Kilgour, the creators of Perfect Deterrence Theory, explain in their co-authored book ‘Perfect Deterrence,’3 classical deterrence theory suffers from what is known as the paradox of mutual deterrence. Classical deterrence e theory hinges on the fact that the status quo is reinforced as the cost of conflict becomes higher. However, logic dictates that the status quo is not a rational choice when both States (A & B) prefer capitulation to conflict when challenged. The status quo is not a Nash equilibrium7 in the standard 2 x 2 game of Chicken in which there are four outcomes (i.e., A wins, B wins, status quo and conflict). The game of Chicken was a tool favored by classical deterrence theorists as it captured essential aspects of deterrence during the age of nuclear confrontation between the United States and the Soviet Union, as it was then. In this game, conflict is understandably assumed to be the worst choice and, hence, the contradiction ensues. The proponents of classical deterrence theory are yet to provide a satisfactory resolution to this logical inconsistency although various attempts have been made.8 Perfect Deterrence Theory was also developed to overcome the empirical deficiencies of classical deterrence theory. Zagare & Kilgour point out that the ‘power imbalance’ is a poor indicator for measuring the likelihood of war as there have been many instances of war fought between two states with roughly equal power, World War II between Britain and Germany for one. There is little empirical support for associating the power imbalance with the likelihood of war. It is a prerequisite that a good theory must stand up reasonably well to empirical evidence. Overall, Perfect Deterrence Theory’s predictions are more in agreement with empirical findings. Here are some distinguishing features of Perfect Deterrence Theory. As explained, in classical deterrence theory, the cost of conflict plays a ‘central’ role in deterring an adversary. Hence, it makes a perfect sense for a state to stock up on more powerful weapons to deter the adversary. These weapons will unleash more destructive power, thereby significantly raising the cost of conflict which, in turn, reduces the possibility of conflict.9 Any adversary would think twice before challenging to upset the status quo. However, as Zagare & Kilgour point out, this model of deterrence is deficient in the sense that there is no maximum limit on the cost of conflict (i.e., that is, a state should just keep on accumulating stockpiles of ever more destructive weapons as long as it can monetarily afford them). There is no built-in mechanism within the model that provides the maximum limit. Such a limit can be shown to exist inherently in some models of Perfect Deterrence Theory, beyond which further strengthening of deterrence becomes totally redundant (i.e., making a case for minimum deterrence). This is a desirable feature to have in the model of deterrence. The theory also gives due consideration to the importance of maintaining the ‘status quo’ which is somehow neglected in the past. The status quo did not receive much attention, as the focus was heavily on the cost of conflict. The emphasis was on the punishment side. Moreover, States A and B no longer have to be undifferentiated in the theory. If needed, one state can be specifically designated as challenger determined to upset the status quo while the other state, as defender, is determined to keep the status quo. This will better approximate a realworld situation. ‘Capability’ and ‘credibility’ are two critical variables in the analysis of a deterrence situation. In Perfect Deterrence Theory, capability is defined as one’s ability to hurt the other (i.e., adversary) while credibility is defined in terms of one’s willingness to fight rather than capitulate. These variables together with other utility variables (e.g., a utility for A wins, B wins, Status Quo and Conflict) are used to determine rational choices and the conditions under which those choices exist. These conditions usually take the form of mathematical inequalities and many insights are gained through analyzing these inequalities. At some decision points in the game (or tree),10 it may be necessary that States A and B update their belief about the other’s determination to fight rather than capitulate based on conditional probability.11 Zagare & Kilgour provide all mathematical details in the appendix section of their book.3, 12 Their work is firmly founded on logic and, hence, model predictions are the direct consequences of a rational decision-making process. In practice, rational choices are nothing but Nash equilibria. Determining these choices simply amounts to finding Nash equilibria. There can be more than one Nash equilibrium under a given condition, which is perhaps a less desirable feature of the theory as it loses predictability. It is simply not possible to know which course of action will be taken in a situation with multiple Nash equilibria.13 Hence, multiple equilibria may be able to explain the success or failure of a deterrence situation that has occurred in the past. One can only hypothesize which one might have been in play. In the theory, only a Nash equilibrium that fulfills Selten’s ‘Perfectness’ condition (i.e., being subgame-perfect) is thought to be a ‘rational’ choice. This condition is used to eliminate all choices which have at least one incredible (a technical term as explained later) decision made along the decision path. Only subgame-perfect Nash equilibria are of true interest as they are free of irrationalities. Accordingly, Zagare & Kilgour have named their deterrence theory with this game theory term ‘Perfect’ in front. It does not mean ‘Perfect Deterrence’ in the ordinary sense of ‘perfect,’ as such deterrence has never existed and never will. Perfect Deterrence Theory has been specifically chosen to be the basis of our study for these reasons. We sought to draw out valuable implications for South Korea based on Zagare & Kilgour’s findings.3 Basically, what can this deterrence theory tell us about strengthening the security of South Korea and continuing to preserve peace and stability in the face of North Korea’s growing nuclear threat? In the next chapter, basic concepts in Perfect Deterrence Theory are reviewed.