Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US Heg is already dying--Trump, a rising China, Populism, and Nationalism

Boller et al. 21 – Florian Boller is from the Department of Political Science, University of Kaiseslautern, other contributors from array of different universities and institutions like JFKI, School of Government and International Relations, etc. “Hegemonic Transition,” 2021, Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2021, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-74505-9

The current international order is unraveling. Its traditional hegemon, the US, has ceased to unequivocally support the institutions it helped to foster. Us President Donald Trump’s “America First” policy has exacerbated ongoing forces pushing international politics toward a hegemonic transition. China’s power surge, contestation by smaller states, and the West’s internal struggles with populism and economic discontent have undermined the liberal order from the outside, and from within. While a diagnosis of this crisis is hardly new (acharya, 2018;Eilstrup-Sangiovanni & Hofmann, 2019; Friedrichs et al., 2019), its sources, scope, and underlying politics are still up for debate. This volume offers an assessment of the ongoing transformation of hegemonic order and its domestic and international politics. In doing so, it challenges the conventional wisdom in three ways. First, the role of the US under the Trump administration with regard to the liberal order is more complex than it may seem. It varies across regimes (e.g., trade and security), regions (e.g., Asia, Europe, the Global South), and is domestically contested by actors within Congress and society. After all, states are not unitary actors whose governments are free to decide the course of their countries, regardless of domestic institutions, voters' interest, and partisan politics. The upending of traditional leadership paths by the Trump administration, in fact, was contested by traditionalists within the executive, and, more importantly, within the legislature. Thus, this argument demands a closer look at the connection between domestic politics and international relations, and the resulting patterns of hegemonic politics across policy fields and regions. Second, there is significant variance in the responses of state and non-state actors toward this instability and disruptive transformation. Some actors forge new alliances, claim authority over policies or within institutions.? Others, in particular allies of the US, such as Poland within NATO, or Israel, who significantly depend on the hegemon's security provisions, reject leadership roles for themselves and try to entice the US to maintain its traditional role. Middle powers such as India and Brazil may find themselves wedged between the US and China, and their room for strategic maneuvering will be severely limited. It is thus a central aim of this volume to dissect contestation and support toward the current hegemonic order (and the traditional hegemon) among different actors. Third, while the topical focus of our endeavor is the age of Trump and the crisis of the international order, we recognize the longer-term trends that have paved the way toward the current hegemonic transition. Economic discontents within large swaths of the electorates in the US and in Europe have, for example, propelled populist and nationalism movements that, in turn, undermined support for maintaining policies and institutions within the liberal order (see Inglehart & Norris, 2016; Lammert and Werner in this volume). Furthermore, the traditional bipartisan foreign policy consensus, which provided the domestic backbone of the liberal order, has begun to erode since the end of the Cold War (see Schultz, 2017). In that regard, we hold that the Trump administration and its policies are a symptom rather than the cause of the unraveling of global order (see ye, 2019, p. 76). Consequently, the crisis of the global order will not simply vanish with the leadership change in the White House on January 20, 2021. Against such a backdrop, this volume contributes to the burgeoning discussion within the international relations (I) literature by offering theoretically informed case studies. Our reading of hegemony diverges from a static concept toward a focus on the dynamic politics of hegemonic order. This perspective includes domestic support and the demand for specific hegemonic goods, the contestation and support by other actors within distinct layers of hegemonic orders, and the underlying bargaining between the hegemon and subordinate actors.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.