Cracks in China’s Economic Foundation prevent China from achieving hegemony
Roy 20 – Denny; Ph.D. in political science, University of Chicago, 1991) writes mainly on Northeast Asian international security issues; “China won’t achieve regional hegemony”; 19 Mar 2020, , The Washington Quarterly, 43:1, 101-117, DOI: 10.1080/0163660X.2020.1734301
An exceptionally strong economy is a necessary foundation for projecting hegemonic power. China has established itself as the top supplier of manufactured goods to the Indo-Pacific countries, creating a common perception of growing Chinese economic domination. China’s economic strength, however, is easily exaggerated. Official Chinese statistics consistently overstate Chinese growth and wealth. Assessments of the size of China’s economy typically employ GDP adjusted by purchasing power parity (PPP). The PPP method, which controls for the different prices of the same commodities in different economies, artificially inflates the appearance of wealth in a relatively poor country being compared to a richer country. More generally, emphasis on GDP as the key indicator of economic vitality obscures the problem of what economists call “bad GDP.” This term refers to outcomes that do not contribute to national strength such as overproduction and unrepaid debt. Tellingly, China had a larger economy than countries such as Britain and Japan which militarily rode roughshod over China in the nineteenth century.24 An alternative, and in some ways more meaningful, measurement is GDP per capita. On this score, China was actually below the world average in 2018 (US$11,312) at US$9,771 and far below the US figure of US$62,641.25 Several serious structural flaws threaten China’s future economic growth. China’s banks are state-owned and lend mainly to state-owned enterprises (SOEs) which are largely unprofitable.26 The banking industry could easily collapse under even a moderate economic shock, dragging down the entire financial system.27 Tackling the country’s massive air and water pollution problems will be a drag on Chinese economic growth far into the future.28 Many Americans are deeply concerned that US debt is now over 100 percent of US GDP—but China’s debt has reached 300 percent of China’s GDP.29 Although large, China’s economy is not especially productive, lagging far behind the United States.30 The International Monetary Fund calculates that growth in China’s total factor productivity, or the amount of production not accounted for by increased inputs, has averaged only about 2 percent annually since the global financial crisis that began in 2007.31 Several serious structural flaws threaten China’s future economic growth. Continued nominal rapid economic growth in China is uncertain. Even according to Chinese official statistics, which are often intentionally inflated, during 2019 China saw its slowest GDP growth rate since 1992, and the slowdown was not a result of China’s trade war with the United States. Rather, it is consistent with a decade-long trend of decline based on gradual changes within the Chinese economy.32China is far from guaranteed to join the short list of countries that have successfully moved from middle-income to high-income, and China’s immense size will make the challenge relatively more difficult. China’s demographic trends suggest changes that will force Chinese economic growth into a long-term period of leveling off. China will certainly “grow old before it grows rich,” at least in terms of per capita GDP. China’s huge population will begin gradually declining around 2025, mainly because couples are choosing to have fewer children because of the rising cost of living and because the “one child” policy, combined with the cultural preference for boys, created a reduction in the female population, resulting in a drop in births. The cohort of workers aged 18 to 30, which supplies factory labor and is crucial to maintaining the country’s economic growth, is already shrinking.33 By 2030, China will have a retiree for every two working-age people,34 which will require both the state and individual families to divert a large amount of their resources into care for the elderly. Much of China’s economic dynamism of the post-Mao years resulted from harnessing a gigantic pool of low-cost labor created by young people moving from the countryside into urban factory work. But with 60 percent of China’s population now living in the cities35 and many other countries providing cheaper labor, China will need to find other ways of sustaining rapid growth.CCP elites recognize the need for economic restructuring but have struggled to implement it. Outgoing PRC Premier Wen Jiabao famously warned in 2013 that China’s economic growth was “unbalanced, uncoordinated, and unsustainable.”36 Since Deng Xiaoping began promoting major marketizing reforms in 1978, the Chinese government has struggled to find a balance between two contradictory imperatives: economic growth and stability. To ensure continued healthy economic growth, China needs to decrease central control, speed liberalization, and stop coddling loss-making SOEs. Such policies, however, damage the Party’s popularity by creating mass unemployment and social upheaval. The Chinese government led by Hu Jintao (2002–12) decided to implement the principle of allowing the market to determine the allocation of resources. Predictably, this effort floundered because it threatened the accustomed profitability of various powerful interest groups including bureaucracies, provincial governments, industrial sectors, and the military. Xi ascended to paramount leadership in 2012 with a mandate to restart the marketization of the Chinese economy, but, against the usual opposition, he has achieved only modest reforms despite vigorously suppressing dissent and removing many of his enemies. Xi’s efforts are at least partly negated by countervailing policies such as strengthening Party control over business decisions, favoring chosen SOEs over the private sector, increasing political interference in the judicial system, tightening the restrictions on discussion of political issues in China, and requiring China’s best minds to divert their attention away from innovative activities to read Xi Jinping Thought.37 The CCP seems trapped by its unwillingness to tolerate the political consequences of the changes necessary to unlock China’s economic potential. The required capabilities for hegemony are a relatively large and healthy economy, a technologically advanced military that can project decisive power far beyond national borders, and a government that is able to pursue a coherent and effective strategy without being impeded by domestic political or social conditions. China need not solve all of its internal problems as a prerequisite to dominating its region—having only a moderately wealthy society, for example, would not necessarily prevent the PRC from having a wealthy state that could pour resources into enhancing national military strength. It is possible that China could muddle through its domestic political, economic, and social challenges for the next few decades while maintaining a solid growth rate and fielding Asia’s strongest military forces. The standard for hegemony, however, is higher than this. It seems unlikely that China will overcome its internal challenges to achieve a sufficiently strong and stable platform from which to attempt to dominate the region.