Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

It’s still unlikely to be the EU

Norrlof 10 – Carla, Professor of Political Science at the University of Toronto, “America's Global Advantage : US Hegemony and International Cooperation”, 4/29/10, Cambridge University Press, https://ebookcentral-proquest-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/lib/umichigan/detail.action?docID=502502.

Furthermore, the European Union is, I think, more likely to displace American power. The reason is simple. Cooperation in Europe cuts to the heart of core superpower functions. The European Union has a large product market where other countries can offload their exports. A European currency union has been in force for a decade, supplying the euro, a currency widely used, with the potential of becoming the primary currency. Significant advances have also been made in the field of security cooperation. Despite these portents, even the European Union is unlikely to take over America’s role in the world economy. While it is possible that the euro will crowd the dollar out to the extent that a symmetrical, multiple, key currency system, is introduced, the euro is unlikely to replace the dollar as key currency. On the security dimension, there is no prospect for the European Union to rival the United States in the foreseeable future. It is even unclear whether the political will exists to create a rival autonomous capability. The second Bush presidency did much to speed up security cooperation, but the initiative quickly petered out, and one wonders how much transatlantic discord would be needed to create a critical security force when policies so disliked in European quarters could not generate stronger developments. This gets to the crux of what keeps American hegemony alive. Transforming the current power structure is not only about America’s relative weakening, but also about other states’ incentives and capacities to organize. Currently, they are too dependent on America. They cannot project power because they do not have the autonomy to define and pursue their interests. Both East Asia and Europe rely on America economically and militarily, Europe less so economically than in the past. But, as we have seen, economic and security functions intersect. This makes it virtually impossible to reach the top, without assuring self-sufficiency in both domains. Of course, in our globalized world, no actor can turn its back on all others in the system. Everyone is interdependent to some extent, although not everyone is dependent to the same extent. Recognizing shared dependence is important for all actors but, for any single actor with the ambition to rule the world, paying attention to the differential vulnerability that comes with relative dependence is imperative. If other Great Powers become serious about closing the American era, they will not be able to continue to depend on the American system for their economic well-being and basic security. Those longing for another world order may be disappointed with them for lacking the political will to stand on their own feet. However, a crisp lesson from this exploration of the determinants and consequences of American power may very well be that, while breaking away from an inequitable system which is exploitative is hard, breaking away from an inequitable system which is not, is harder. The substitution of American leadership is slowed by the way American power is exercised. Not quite benevolent, the current world order is, for the most part, mutually beneficial. Everyone benefits from cooperation, although not everyone benefits equally, and the gains from cooperation are asymmetrically distributed at the crest. This leads me to predict that rapid decline is not on its way. America will bounce back, preserving its unique position in the international system for the foreseeable future.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.