Newtonian ontology cannot account for humanity’s intrinsic ability to have internal entanglements that then affect external relations. This destroys the affs ability to promote cooperation because their ontology sees humanity as separate, forever fracturing true global cooperation.
Chengxin Pan 20, Faculty of Arts and Education, Deakin University, Australia, 2020, “Enfolding wholes in parts: quantum holography and International Relations,” European Journal of International Relations 2020, Vol. 26(S1) 14–38
As illustrated in Figure 1, the Newtonian ontology sees individual entities as the basic units and their relations merely as an external function/effect of their subsequent interac- tion. In comparison, the existing relational literature affords a more prominent role for relations and networks. Nevertheless, relations often continue to be conceptualized as something external to or between solid actors and entities.4 Quantum holography, by con- trast, sees relations as part and parcel of what entities are and may become. That is, Pan 19 relations are already implicated in entities (hence implicate or internal relations) even as entities are also externally linked by (explicate) relations. As shown in the illustration about holographic relationality, inside an entity exist traces of its large whole and its over- all relations, just as inside a seed exist memories and traces of “interactions within the web of life” (Shiva, 2014: 438). Thus understood, an entity is always already relational and its relations are inherent and holographic. It cannot be disentangled or disembedded from the whole or other “entities” in the whole, even if it may appear to stand “alone.”