Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
← SearchMichigan2022Disadvantage
Opening Word document…

Energy security key to the hege – both military and economic strength depend on energy independence.

Dan Brouillette ‘21. 15th Secretary of the U.S. Department of Energy. Secretary Brouillette has three decades of experience in both the public and private sector. “Economic and National Security Impacts under a Hydraulic Fracturing Ban: Report to the President”. United States Department of Energy. January 2021. https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2021/01/f82/economic-and-national-security-impacts-under-a-hydraulic-fracturing-ban.pdf, accessed 7-13-2021

The U.S. shale revolution has been the single most significant contributor to enhancing U.S. energy security. As a result of U.S. oil and natural gas production strength and resilience, the U.S. is far less impacted by global oil price shocks, consumers and manufacturers enjoy the benefits of reliable, affordable power, and energy is an important foreign policy tool. Instituting a ban on hydraulic fracturing would introduce several national security uncertainties. Fundamentally, energy security can be defined in a national security context using a three-tiered approach to national security itself. That is, national security as the functionality of military capabilities and security services at the primary level; as the functioning of critical domestic energy supplies and services at the secondary level; and as economic well-being and prosperity at the most removed, longest-term level. 66 A ban of HF would affect all three levels of this national security paradigm. While the ban itself would not directly induce a lessening of the national security posture, it would introduce more uncertainties, requiring additional scenario planning as the U.S. and our allies’ reliance on foreign oil and natural gas would increase. On the most basic level, national security assets are still largely dependent on liquid hydrocarbon fuel sources to power the engines of U.S. military vehicles and technologies. Aircraft require the lion’s-share of these resources, meaning that the bulk of the U.S. military’s forward-projection capabilities are reliant upon affordable and abundant fuel sources. Likewise, ground and sea-based military capabilities (except for nuclear-powered aircraft carriers and submarines) are also dependent on ready access to these fuels. From a training and readiness perspective to power-posture and actual combat operations, maintaining a steady and secure supply of fuels is necessary for the modern military and security apparatus. Activities, such as a ban, that would reduce the secure and reliable domestic source of these fuels would insert uncertainty into the energy supply chain. Beyond the primary level, the safety and reliability of the broader energy supply infrastructure and resources also plays a key role in overall national security. Severe supply disruptions to the overall economy, whether from natural disasters, confrontational tradecraft, or even open hostilities, could result in domestic unrest. There are several potential chokepoints in international trade routes, largely shipping lanes that could be used to cut off fuel supplies to the U.S. economy in the short-to-mid-term. Additionally, and less dramatically, a trade embargo, like the 1970’s OPEC oil embargo, could have a similar effect. While these outcomes would not directly result from a HF ban, increases in reliance on foreign sources of fuel would expose and exacerbate vulnerabilities. Finally, a thriving and growing economy provides the most significant and most enduring bulwark against national security threats. As was stated in the United States Senate’s Global Economic Security Strategy of 2019, “the national security of the United States depends in large part on a vibrant, growing, and secure United States economy;”67 As has been described in detail throughout the report, a potential HF ban is projected to have an impeding effect on overall economic growth, and to ultimately reduce the number of jobs, wages and tax revenues collected. These effects would compound over time, eventually weakening the economy and national security. Enacting a nationwide ban on the technology that has unlocked America’s energy revolution jeopardizes newfound gains in energy security and poses a significant threat to America’s national security. Hydraulic fracturing and horizontal drilling are directly responsible for most domestic oil and natural gas production. Taking away hydraulic fracturing technology from America’s oil and natural gas industry removes the primary technique needed to efficiently and responsibly extract abundant U.S. energy resources. Without new wells brought online, U.S. natural gas and oil production would rapidly fall, reversing the past decade's energy security gains. Importantly, the U.S. would lose its energy independence, and, since demand for reliable, affordable energy would remain, America would again turn to the Middle East and Russia for imports. An important asset in diplomacy would be sidelined and allies across the globe – from Southeast Asia to Europe and South America – would be cut off from a valuable, trusted energy trading partner.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.