Disinformation wrecks public confidence in science which undermines solutions to climate change and diseases---plan is key to solve
T. V. Gerbina, 22, Gerbina is from an Institute for Scientific and Technical Information from Russia; “Science Disinformation: On the Problem of Fake News”, Springer, 2-25-2022, https://link.springer.com/article/10.3103/S0147688221040092/chuo
This article is devoted to an important socio-cultural phenomenon that undermines public confidence in science, that is, fake science news. The term fake news is analyzed and data on the dissemination of fake news on social networks is provided. Information sources for science news and fake science news are identified. Special attention is paid to the dissemination of fake science news during the COVID-19 pandemic.
According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the 2016 word of the year was post-truth. According to the definition of British linguists, this concept means circumstances in which objective facts have less influence on the formation of public opinion than emotions or personal beliefs [1]. This phenomenon arose due to the influence of the media: by manipulating society, they create a different reality. One of the main reasons for the post-truth era is the abundance of fake news that the audience is unable to recognize.
The growing influence of fake news is fueled by a loss of trust in the authorities, as well as in the media and the journalistic profession in general. Fake news fills the vacuum for people or communities offering instant solutions to various problems. In their discourse, knowledge, science, facts, evidence, and rationality are swept aside as the sophistry of the elite. With the development of Internet technologies, anyone can become an author of fake news and begin to spread it instantly; any attempt to refute these false facts is useless. Emotions take over rationalism, i.e., people believe what they want to believe. All this fully applies to science news.
Development of the Internet provides an excellent opportunity to promote scientific knowledge, as well as to educate and disseminate research results. If it is credible, science news can be an influential vehicle for drawing public attention to important issues of our time; otherwise, such news undermines the credibility of scientific information and science in general.
The scientific news problem has been aggravated by the COVID-19 pandemic and the information wave that followed. Disinformation about the new disease spread faster than the pandemic, resulting in the emergence of the phenomenon of infodemic, i.e., an overabundance of both reliable and inaccurate information, which makes it difficult for people to identify reliable sources. Infodemic has exacerbated the problem of fake science news, since almost any message about COVID-19 relates to science, in particular, to medicine and biology.
In our time, science is more relevant than ever for society, given such important problems of our time as climate change, the energy supply, and the global spread of viral infections. Science news is a key resource for helping the public understand new scientific knowledge and the latest technological advances. The media, including social media, mediate relationships between people and technological development and help them to understand the new world by playing the role of a science conduit. According to the reach of the audience, the main channels for the receipt of science news can be divided into sources for professionals (scientists) and sources for society as a whole (Fig. 5). Accordingly, professional sources of information (mostly scientific articles) are the main channels for obtaining information for popular scientific publications and news agencies. It is difficult to judge the quality of scientific articles, but an article in a scientific journal is most likely to be peer reviewed, which makes it a more reliable source of news. However, this is compounded by the fact that the quality of scientific journals can vary significantly and some journals publish research without peer review. [figure omitted]
The most popular science fake news over the years has been vaccine manufacturer conspiracy theories and denial of man-made climate destruction. Vaccines are considered one of the most important inventions ever made for the benefit of humanity. The World Health Organization estimates that vaccines save 2–3 million lives every year. However, a fabricated scientific article that claimed that the measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine causes autism [26] led to widespread dissemination of this misinformation, especially through social media. This, in turn, led not only to record levels of measles incidence in Europe in 2018, but also expanded the range of so-called anti-vaxxers [27].
The denial of anthropogenic climate change, which is dismissed as fake science without any evidence, has led to universal acceptance of the international agreement on climate change being lost, and its impact on global warming is likely to be disastrous around the world [28].
One of the most widely replicated fakes is the so-called flat Earth theory. Tens of thousands of videos, social media accounts, podcasts, and websites are devoted to this absurd theory [29, 30]. Today, when space probes are exploring the planets of the solar system, such “scientific” information can only cause confusion.
In general, the coronavirus pandemic has spawned a host of conspiracy theories and fake science news, which can be roughly divided into the following categories:
• the origin of the SARS-CoV-2 virus (bat soup, a laboratory leak, creation of the virus by Bill Gates or the US Government);
• racial theory (for example, only Asians are infected with the virus);
• the spread of coronavirus (5G networks);
• treatment and prevention of coronavirus (alcohol consumption; rinsing with chlorine dioxide; bleach injections; swimming in a pool with chlorinated water; eating garlic, ginger, sesame oil, bananas; using cocaine; washing hands and rubbing surfaces with baby urine; warming up the nose with a hairdryer; taking baths with granite);
• politics (governments hiding the real deaths from coronavirus and falsifying vaccinations; the increase in the incidence in Europe is caused by illegal migrants);
• epidemiology and statistics (overestimated/ underestimated statistics on morbidity and mortality);
• vaccines and vaccinations (death after vaccination; mass vaccination for the sake of obtaining superprofits by corporations; the contents of heavy metals in the vaccine).
Most readers probably found this news funny, but there are examples where such messages caused serious harm to health and even led to death. As an example, by the end of March 2020, over 2100 Iranians had been poisoned by oral methanol. Iran, as an Islamic country, has strict restrictions on alcohol consumption, but in this case patients said that, according to information on social networks, SARS-CoV-2 infection can be prevented with alcohol. As a result, almost 900 patients poisoned with illegal alcohol were admitted to the intensive care unit and 296 of them died [36].
With the development of science and technology, there has been a clear increase in interest in science and scientific research. On the one hand, society is aware of the dependence of progress on the development of scientific research; on the other hand, it perceives science as something that carries potential threats. The digital revolution contributed to the replacement of vertical models of dialogue between science and society with horizontal models [43]. An important subject of the dialogue between society and science is the diversity of scientific knowledge in the information environment. The transition of scientific knowledge into knowledge for all is ensured by the popularization of science, which gives knowledge a form accessible to the general public.
The massive dissemination of fake science news can be seen as a crisis of the political system and science journalism and as a new propaganda tool, where fake scientific information is deliberately disseminated on social networks in a viral manner with the aim of quickly impacting the audience. There are many motives for creating fake science news, the most obvious being financial gain and ideological beliefs.
Preventing the deliberate creation of false information is very difficult, and, in democratic societies that operate on the principles of free speech and freedom of expression, it is even more difficult. Thus, instead of looking for ways to prevent the creation of misinformation, the primary focus should be on limiting the spread of fake news and minimizing the damage it can cause.