Science disinformation hinders solutions to existential crises---climate change and vaccines
ALLEA, 21, ALLEA is the European Federation of Academics of Sciences and Humanities, representing more than 50 academies from over 40 countries in Europe; “Fact or Fake? Tackling Science Disinformation”, ALLEA, 05-2021, https://allea.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Fact-or-Fake-Discussion-Paper.pdf/chuo
===tbh this card is kind of similar to Gerbina but is better lol; not specific to undermining trust though this is about just wrong information makes people do the wrong things
The overall success of the scientific method also means that when someone wants to make claims that go against established scientific knowledge and are not grounded in the scientific method, they must seek to undermine the trustworthiness of the scientific method or scientists per se. Thus, paradoxically, scientific language is often adopted at the same time as scientific activities themselves are being questioned. An extreme and particularly harmful form of anti-scientific activity appears in the form of conspiracy theories with notable examples in the three areas chosen for analysis in this discussion paper: climate change, vaccines, and pandemics.3
Science disinformation is one of the major challenges of our times, with consequences for society at large and for (trust in) science.4, 5 This paper sheds light on the characteristics and mechanisms of science disinformation and discusses what scientists, science communicators and policymakers can do about it.
While science disinformation and misinformation is common in many different areas, we have chosen to focus on three that strike us as particularly important: climate change, vaccine safety and pandemics.
Climate change in the form of global warming resulting from human activities was first predicted more than a century ago. Continuous monitoring of various physical and chemical parameters shows that the process of warming has accelerated during recent decades. Signs of global warming include melting glaciers, thawing permafrost, and rising sea levels. These changes are caused by growing concentrations of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere. Findings in many areas of research are almost unanimously interpreted to mean that the large number of humans and their activities have prominent roles in these developments.6
Major concerns are now if the increase in carbon dioxide levels and temperatures mean that efforts to break the rising curves will come too late. Models predict rising sea levels and flooding of large coastal areas, thereby reducing areas for human settlements and food production. This is predicted to displace hundreds of millions of people, resulting in an increased population density and raising the potential for violent conflicts. Together, these processes will extinguish habitats for many species of organisms and exacerbate the ongoing mass extinction.
Despite overwhelming scientific evidence, politically motivated refusal to accept anthropogenic global warming (increasing temperatures due to human influence) has been intense and has used both ‘cherry-picking’ and conspiracy theories in order to counter widely accepted scientific evidence. This resistance has received strong financial support from business interests, further amplified by certain sections of the media. If the facts of climate change and its causes are countered with false claims about cause-and-consequence relationships, this will delay actions to reduce global warming, potentially with disastrous consequences.
Vaccines are considered one of the most important inventions ever for the benefit of humankind. The World Health Organization has estimated that vaccines save 2-3 millions of lives every year, especially children, and prevent unimaginable suffering.7 High immunity at the population level arising from vaccinations leads to reduced transmission of an infectious disease and may even eliminate it completely. Those who have been vaccinated will serve as a protective barrier by not transmitting the disease to those who have not been vaccinated (so called ‘herd immunity’).
Nevertheless, opposition towards vaccination has existed since vaccination programmes were introduced. The reasons for this resistance have varied over time and have at times been based on valid doubts as to the vaccine’s efficacy. However, some vaccines have been used for decades and all vaccines are consistently monitored to ensure a high ratio of benefits over risks. In addition, high standards for the approval of new vaccines have been implemented worldwide. Nevertheless, public resistance to vaccines prevails in some pockets of our societies, sometimes keeping vaccination uptake below the threshold required for herd immunity.
False information, exaggerated/unjustified claims about side effects, or conspiracy theories regarding underlying objectives for global vaccination programmes may ultimately lead to an insufficient rate of vaccination and therefore inadequate levels of immunity at the population level. Vaccine hesitancy can not only lead to unnecessary disease outbursts, but also puts those at risk who have not yet been vaccinated, especially infants, and those who cannot be vaccinated, such as individuals with immune deficiencies. Misinformation that increases vaccine hesitancy may cause more people to suffer from an epidemic, more people to show severe symptoms, and more people to die.
The origin and spread of the pandemic have been the subject of much speculation, some of which has involved fanciful conspiracy theories such as linking the pandemic to 5G mobile phone technology or suggesting the virus was man made and introduced into the population on purpose. In addition, there have been numerous cases of fraudulent marketing of health care products, ranging from face masks to ventilators. Even political leaders in several countries have promoted regimens that completely lacked clinical or biological evidence. Those who complied may have caused themselves unnecessary harm and/or felt unduly safe and have displayed more risky behaviour, either by exposing themselves to individuals infected with the virus or by ignoring their own symptoms and thereby exposing others. This ‘infodemic’ coined by the WHO may have contributed to the spreading of the pandemic and may have increased the number of patients with severe symptoms requiring intensive care, as well as the number of deaths.
Generating disinformation can be incited by different motivations in different actors and in numerous combinations. The most apparent motivations are financial profit and ideological conviction. Both can at times deviate from norms of rationality and moral standards when individuals ignore or are unable to recognise harmful consequences for others. In other instances, the aim of disinformation is to deliberately cause confusion, instability, or mistrust for political purposes.
Deliberate construction of false information is very difficult to prevent. When lies are generated wilfully, the responsible individuals have already committed themselves to fraud. Likewise, it may also be hard to convince those who knowingly disseminate existing misinformation to change their behaviour. In open societies with strong protective individual rights and freedom of expression, it is difficult to stop disinformation at its roots, except by appealing to humanitarian values and hoping that those who produce and spread disinformation will consider with empathy the consequences for other people and then stop themselves and change their behaviour. Instead of finding ways to prevent disinformation from being generated in the first place, efforts will have to focus on limiting the spread of disinformation and minimising the damage it may cause.
Policymakers have at least four ways to prevent the spread of misinformation: They can regulate content directly, provide someone with the authority for regulating content, redesign the structures (platforms) in which content is generated and distributed, or support the creation of instruments that can raise citizen awareness and enable them to identify and prevent the dangers of misinformation.30
One way forward is to ask public regulators of news media to intensify their regulation of social media platforms and websites. Web services are often sources of news and information while also financed by advertising agencies. This leads to an obvious conflict of interest that needs to be examined and constantly regulated.
However, search engines and social media platforms should not be viewed as a threat to our democracy per se. We should act in an enlightened manner to nurture and guide the rich value of diverse commercial sources of digital information, as we do with newspapers and television channels. We need to regulate them in a manner that allows us to access the accurate information and exploit emerging information technologies, e.g. automated factchecking and recommender systems.
Last but not least, governments have the option of strengthening incentives for empowering recipients of information to identify and cope with mis- and disinformation, either themselves or with the help of machine learning systems. (Digital) media literacy is crucial here for evaluating the content and context of information and ultimately detecting its accuracy. Several endogenous cues (content) and exogenous cues (context) can help test the validity of information.31 However, such cues to disinformation and their uptake for regulation remain largely underexplored.
Urgent action on a global scale is necessary to mitigate these processes. However, many political leaders and large proportions of populations still deny the factual observations, the observed or inferred causes, and the predicted consequences. This causes necessary decisions to be insufficient both in extent and time. Thus scientists and science communicators are facing an immense challenge to explain the chains of causal events, the ongoing global warming and the predicted future consequences.