Democratic backsliding from Russia’s influence campaign is weaking NATO --- allows Russia to exploit the weaknesses and further undermine the coherence of the alliance
David Deulofeu AntúNez 18 – AntúNez was a former staff writer for the International Affairs Review. He studies and writes about security policy. ("NATO’s Trojan Horse: How Democratic Deconsolidation and Populism are Weakening the Alliance — THE INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS REVIEW," INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS REVIEW, 11-29-2018, https://www.iar-gwu.org/blog/2018/11/29/natos-trojan-horse-how-democratic-deconsolidation-and-populism-are-weakening-the-alliance, Accessed 7-13-2022, LASA-KS)
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) is facing an internal problem that coauld permanently weaken the Alliance. In recent years, we have seen the rise of a nationalist-populist wave in Europe and the United States: Viktor Orbán of Hungary, the Kaczynski in Poland, and President Donald Trump in America. This rise in illiberal world leaders has led to significant democratic backsliding in NATO countries, which pose a grave threat to NATO’s strength in the face of an aggressive and revisionist Russia. Democratic governance and strong institutions are as much a cornerstone of the Alliance as is collective defense. Article II of the North Atlantic Treaty (also known as the Washington Treaty) stresses the importance of “states’ promises to strengthen free institutions within their borders,” underscoring the vital democratic aspects of the alliance. Within NATO today, however, some states are shifting away from the core tenets of Article II and are actively conspiring to undermine the same institutional channels that brought them to power. These regressions of democracy create vulnerabilities that can be exploited by NATO adversaries, namely the Kremlin. In Hungary, Orbán’s increasingly authoritarian Fidesz government has taken an increasingly pro-Russia stance, doling out energy contracts to the country’s oligarchs and calling for Hungary to model itself a similarly to Russia’s illiberal state. In Turkey, the rise of Recep Tayyip Erdogan has resulted in members of the military being sacked and indiscriminate jailing of journalists and academics, while leaving no real opposition to his rule. This in turn has led to closer ties between Ankara and Moscow, especially in matters of defense and the ongoing Syrian civil war. Poland continues to see Russia as both an adversary and a threat; however, Poland’s judiciary reform has effectively turned the high court into a PiS puppet while media repression has simultaneously turned Poland into both a victim and purveyor of disinformation campaigns, further isolating it from its allies and European partners. Democratic backsliding and increased illiberal leaders in NATO countries have opened the door for Russia to engage in an influence campaign, and to pull those countries away from the Liberal Western Order the Alliance is founded on. Democratic backsliding weakens NATO internally by making cohesion, trust, and operations more difficult. Democracies tend to foster cooperation and trust; autocracies are always looking to blame “the other.” Within NATO, we are seeing bigger wedges being driven into member states, as illiberal regimes criticize their democratic allies, and democracies sanction authoritarian actions. Germany and the EU have become targets of the right-wing populist Prawo i Sprawiedliwość (PiS/Law and Justice) government in Poland. The current government has sought to expunge any guilt the “Polish Nation” incurred during the Second World War by engaging in an aggressive revisionist campaign aimed at denying Poland’s participation in Nazi death camps. Furthermore, Poland’s attempt to sack its Constitutional Court and replace 27 justices with PiS loyalists has alienated it from France, Germany, and the European Commission, which opened an Article 7 investigation last year into Poland’s actions and is currently threatening to take legal action against it. Likewise, Hungary has taken an antagonistic stance with EU members and their efforts to promote rule of law. Budapest has been in an entrenched battle against the EU, in what Orbán has called “liberal forces acting against Central and Eastern European countries,” while actively opposing and restraining EU laws on immigration, entertaining anti-Semitic conspiracy theories, and curtailing individual freedoms within Hungary’s borders. The right-wing populism of both Poland and Hungary, with their villainization of minorities, suppression of dissent, crackdown on civil society, and erosion of democratic norms and institutions, puts them at odds with their NATO allies and EU partners, fostering uncertainty and deep mistrust among them. Poland and Hungary are not the only NATO members breaking down trust. Traditional allies have taken an unprecedented stance on NATO, one which brings its members uncertainty and lack of trust. President Donald Trump has been a vociferous critic of the Alliance, admonishing members for failing to spend 2 percent of their GDP on defense while frequently highlighting the “lion’s share” the United States contributes. Trump has gone to the extent of questioning the alliance itself, asking, “What good is NATO…?” in a tweet. Apart from voicing criticism against NATO, Trump has repeatedly insulted NATO members and their leaders, while directing attention to closer relations with Russia, even though there have not been any significant changes in the Kremlin’s commitment to democracy, rule of law, or its meddling in internal processes of other nations. Russia continues to be a U.S. and NATO adversary. These stances from the current U.S. administration encourage anti-EU and anti-NATO rhetoric from other leaders, while at the same time erodes trust among its members and ultimately plays into the Kremlin’s intentions to destabilize the West and undermine the Alliance.