Turn – Populism in opposition is good for democracy because it keeps the elite in check – no democratic backsliding in Europe, just a positive feedback loop to correct democracy
Jane Mansbridge and Stephen Macedo 20 – Mansbridge is the professor of political science Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University. She is one of the world’s most prominent scholars of democratic theory. Macedo is the Laurance S. Rockefeller Professor of Politics at Princeton University and he focuses on topics related to liberalism and democracy.("Populism and Democratic Theory,"Annual Review of Law and Social Science, 2-25-2020, https://www.princeton.edu/~macedo/Papers/Mansbridge%20Macedo%20Populism%20AnnRevLawSocSci%2019.pdf, Accessed 7-21-2022, LASA-KS)
Commentators routinely describe "populism" as vague. Some argue that the early US populists, who coined the modern usage, were not populists. We disagree and identify this common conceptual core: the "people" in a moral battle against "elites." The core definition fits all cases of populism: those on the left and right, those in the United States, Europe, and elsewhere. In addition to this minimal common core, we identify strongly suggested and frequently correlated non-core characteristics. These include the people's homogeneity and exclusivity, direct rule, and nationalism, as well as a single leader, vilification of vulnerable out-groups, and impatience with deliberation. The US Populist Party and Spain's Podemos Party fit the core definition but have few of the other characteristics. The core can be good for democracy, we argue, while the associated characteristics are often dangerous. Populism in opposition can be good for democracy, while populism in power carries great risks. We further distinguish, with many others (e.g., Judis 2016; Kazin 2017b; Mudde & Kaltwasser 2017; Müller 2016; Urbinati 2014, 2019a), between populism in opposition and populism in power. Populism in opposition often revitalizes democracy when the populist ideals and moral fervor anmating antagonism to entrenched elites crack through a prevailing political and discursive hegemony, bringing concerns that had been ignored or suppressed into the political arena. Yet populism in power poses risks to democracy. The same moral fervor and us/them dichotomy that help disrupt the entrenched political and cultural order when populists are in opposition militates against the mutual respect, tolerance, forbearance, negotiation, compromise, and respect for constitutional institutions necessary for egalitarian and pluralist democratic politics when populists take power. The core elements of populism are not antidemocratic. On the contrary, when a large group has designated itself "the people" and has come to see itself in a moral battle against "the elites," the members of that group have often had significant interests and values that political elites have neglected or even denigrated. At these moments, populism is democracy's way of saying, "Listen harder." Although ordinary citizens are not policy experts, they are in a position to judge how their lives are going, and when they have long-standing grievances that powerful elites have not effectively addressed, organizing in protest is a rationally and emotionally appropriate democratic response. Democracy particularly needs the populist impulse at certain historical moments. Elites often develop interests and values that diverge from those of the less affluent, less educated, and less privileged who live far from centers of political, economic, social, and cultural power. Thev often talk primarily with one another and reinforce one another. Power tends to beget more power. When groups with more power neglect the values and interests of the less powerful for too long, populism is what we want from democracy. the capacity to let the needs and values of the less powerful break through and thrust themselves on the increasingly insulated political, economic, social, and cultural ruling classes.