Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No hybrid war

Dr. Samuel Charap 16, Ph.D. in Political Science from the University of Oxford, M.Phil. in Russian and East European Studies from the University of Oxford, B.A. in Political Science and Russian from Amherst College, Senior Fellow for Russia and Eurasia at the International Institute for Strategic Studies, “The Ghost of Hybrid War”, Survival, Volume 57, Number 6, December 2015 – January 2016

Analysts in the West tend to think that Russia would choose hybrid tactics in order to sow discord within NATO – using ambiguity to create divisions among allies about what was happening and how to respond – and thus break the Alliance politically, without firing a shot.13 This scenario reflects well-founded doubts about Alliance cohesion and unity. It does not reflect the reality of Russian strategy. An extensive search of Russian military writings produces no evidence of such considerations. Moreover, what we do know about Russian military thought suggests that a hybrid war with NATO would not make strategic sense from Moscow’s perspective. For the Russian military, the most significant threat in the Baltic region, particularly because of the strategically vulnerable Kaliningrad exclave, where the Russian Baltic Fleet is based, is the potential deployment of US forces and high-end capabilities. A Russian hybrid operation would give ample time for the US to do just that. So, in the time it took for Narva, the Russian-speaking Estonian border town, to be occupied by the little green men, the 101st Airborne Division could land in Tallinn and a US carrier group could set sail for the Gulf of Finland. Moreover, Moscow has options to prevent this scenario from materialising. For example, the army, with air support, could rapidly push from the Estonian border to the Baltic Sea, destroying all Estonian forces and denying the US access to the region before anyone in Washington or Brussels had the chance to navel gaze. One Russian analyst noted that it would take 30,000 NATO troops about a month to deploy to the Baltic region, while a Russian force of three times the size could be sent there in just 24 hours. He concluded that ‘while Europe’s top brass discuss and argue how to transit to the theater, and coordinate all of this with [the US], Warsaw, Riga, Tallinn and Vilnius would be transformed into a rubbish heap’.14 Some analysts have gone even further than discerning a doctrine and now claim that Russia is already conducting hybrid warfare on the West. As one recent report claimed, ‘The various diplomatic, economic, military and subversive measures that have been employed by Russia in the Baltic Region and increasingly in the Balkans, Black Sea and Mediterranean regions, could be interpreted as elements of a protracted campaign already underway.’15 The author thus equates hard-nosed – but commonplace – tactics to gain influence with subversion that represents a threat to national security. But there is a major difference between efforts to subvert a population against its government on the one hand, and the use of normal tools of statecraft to gain influence on the other.16 The former would be, of course, a real problem for NATO; fortunately, nothing like the subversion of eastern Ukraine is happening inside member states today. As for all the other unpleasant activities that Russia undertakes inside NATO and EU member states, such as funding political parties or developing media in local languages, these certainly do not merit the label ‘hybrid’, let alone ‘war’. After all, Western countries have been doing many of the same things inside of Russia for years. And no one considered those activities ‘elements of a protracted campaign already underway’. * * * Three parallels between the developing conventional wisdom in Russia and the West on hybrid war emerge from the literature. Firstly, Russian strategists believe that the US is willing to risk conducting a limited, hybrid operation in Russia – that is, on the territory of a nuclear power – just as NATO strategists believe Russia is willing to risk the same on the territory of a nuclear alliance. Secondly, Russian analysts project well-founded fears about their country’s long-term political cohesion onto the West’s intentions. In other words, they know their political system is brittle, so therefore the Americans must be out to undermine it. In the same way, NATO analysts know there are divergences regarding threat perceptions inside the Alliance, so therefore Russia must be planning to take advantage of them. Finally, each side believes that Ukraine represents the other’s successful hybrid operation, and a potential precursor to such an operation being directed against it. Fortunately, on all three counts, the new conventional wisdom in both Russia and the West is wrong.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.