Democrats are losing seats and ballots – can’t catch up.
Trende 7/13 (Sean Trende is the Senior Elections Analyst for RealClearPolitics. He is the author of "The Lost Majority: Why the Future of Government Is Up for Grabs and Who Will Take It," and co-authored the Almanac of American Politics 2014. Before becoming a full-time political analyst, Sean practiced law for eight years at Kirkland & Ellis LLP, and Hunton & Williams LLP, where he represented clients in a variety of contexts, from state trial courts to the Supreme Court of the United States. Sean earned a juris doctorate from Duke University, a master's degree in political science from Duke University and bachelor's degree from Yale University. 7-13-2022, "Republicans Are Favored to Win the Senate," https://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2022/07/13/gop_likely_to_take_senate_but_its_far_from_a_lock_147883.html 7/23/22 JY).
The president’s party has performed better in open seats that lean toward the opposition in presidential elections, but even then they are just 3 for 35 in the past 40 years. Republicans won an open seat in Minnesota in 2002, while Democrats won the Indiana Senate seat in 1998 and held the West Virginia Senate seat in 2010. But these three pickups all involved some combination of strange circumstances (the death of Sen. Paul Wellstone shortly before the election in 2002), an extremely popular president (1998 and 2002), or unusually strong candidates for the opposition (Evan Bayh, Joe Manchin, and, arguably, Norm Coleman). We might posit that Fetterman qualifies as an unusually strong candidate, but that remains to be seen; his endorsement of Bernie Sanders and his health issues are potential minefields for him to navigate.
In any event, it isn’t impossible for Democrats to flip one of these seats. It would just be unusual, especially with a president whose job approval sits in the 30s, and we should treat the possibility as such.
Democrats then have the task of defending three clearly vulnerable seats. Another one, in New Hampshire, is in some jeopardy, but probably doesn’t fall unless at least two of the other three seats also flip (Colorado and, to a much lesser degree, Washington State, could also come into play in the fall, but are unlikely to do so unless the previous seats are lost). Two of these states – Arizona and Georgia – have PVIs (Partisan Voter Index, which measures how each district or state performs at the presidential level compared to the nation as a whole) that lean toward Republicans, while a third (Nevada) has no lean in either direction. The president’s job approval in these states likely mirrors his national job approval; this means that a successful Democratic candidate is going to have to convince about one in six voters who don’t approve of the president to nevertheless pull the lever for the Democratic Senate candidate.
That’s a tall order, especially in Nevada, where Republicans have a reasonably good, if not spectacular, candidate in former Attorney General Adam Laxalt. Laxalt hails from a famous Nevada family, and is a capable enough politician that he lost the gubernatorial race by just four points in the solid Democratic year of 2018. He’s a candidate that is at least at the Mendoza line in an environment where Mendoza-line candidates should win.