Democrats need to win at least three more seats
Trende 7/13 (Sean Trende is the Senior Elections Analyst for RealClearPolitics. He is the author of "The Lost Majority: Why the Future of Government Is Up for Grabs and Who Will Take It," and co-authored the Almanac of American Politics 2014. Before becoming a full-time political analyst, Sean practiced law for eight years at Kirkland & Ellis LLP, and Hunton & Williams LLP, where he represented clients in a variety of contexts, from state trial courts to the Supreme Court of the United States. Sean earned a juris doctorate from Duke University, a master's degree in political science from Duke University and bachelor's degree from Yale University. 7-13-2022, "Republicans Are Favored to Win the Senate," https://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2022/07/13/gop_likely_to_take_senate_but_its_far_from_a_lock_147883.html 7/23/22 JY).
That leaves Georgia and Arizona. Former Heisman Trophy winner Herschel Walker is a weak candidate with a penchant for outlandish comments, and Sen. Raphael Warnock is a charismatic incumbent. But this is still a seat that Warnock barely won against another weak candidate in a low turnout 2020 runoff, and he will have to convince a large number of voters who disapprove of the president to vote for him. Arizona is an under-polled race with a late primary. We don’t yet know what kind of candidate Blake Masters, the seemingly likely victor of the GOP primary, is going to be, although recent comments about the possibility that the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol was an FBI false flag operation aren’t particularly promising. But again, all he has to do to win is convince about 80% of the Arizona voters who disapprove of President Biden to vote for him.
In short, the battle for the Senate comes down to Democrats’ ability to win at least three of four seats that would likely be highly competitive if President Biden’s job approval were about ten points higher than it is today. But in a situation where Senate outcomes correlate heavily with presidential job approval in the state, that’s a tough row to hoe. While we should give more than a cursory nod to the possibility that Democrats will hold the Senate (unlike the possibility that Democrats will hold the House, which is barely worth that nod), we should also say with some confidence that Republicans are the favorites to win.
Probably the best counter-argument is that our high levels of polarization insulate Democrats from Biden’s job approval. In other words, there are voters who may disapprove of the job the president is doing, but will nevertheless vote Democratic. We saw this in 2008, where Republican candidates ran far ahead of President Bush’s job approval in many states. Republican voters may have recognized the poor job he was doing, but in the end, they were still Republicans.
There’s no doubt that we’ve reached that point, as most Democratic Senate candidates are running ahead of Biden’s job approval right now. We’ve become much more polarized since 2008, and Democratic candidates in these states probably have a higher floor than we might have seen 10 years ago. But this is a two-way street; Republican candidate quality won’t matter as much as it might have a decade ago either.