Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Mitigating digital authoritarianism is key to successful alternatives

Sherman 21 – (Justin Sherman is a nonresident fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Cyber Statecraft Initiative, a research fellow at the Tech, Law & Security Program at American University Washington College of Law, and a contributor at WIRED Magazine. He was previously a cybersecurity policy fellow at New America and a fellow at Duke Law School’s Center on Law & Technology, “Digital Authoritarianism and Implications for US National Security”, 3-15-22, The Cyber Defense Review, https://cyberdefensereview.army.mil/Portals/6/Documents/2021_winter_cdr/06_CDR_V6N1_Sherman.pdf?ver=_8pKxD7hOFkcsIANHQZKDw%3d%3d)//Alk

Digital authoritarianism, at its core, is a mechanism for exerting increased, unchecked control over one’s population through digital technologies. Censorship, device hacking, and mass surveillance are all on the table. In this way, digital authoritarianism facilitates power consolidation—ensuring that challenges to a regime are outed in advance or quickly observed as they arise, and suppressed. This exposes US national security to risk. In a world where citizen revolt tops the list of authoritarian fears, digital authoritarianism promises a set of solutions: Internet Protocol (IP) address lists used to block foreign online content; traffic header inspection to monitor online activity; legal control of Internet Service Providers (ISPs) whenever the government wants to shut down Internet services; and more. Sometimes, this is quite explicit. The Russian government, for instance, strongly promotes information control in domestic cyberspace for this reason.[4] Other times, the suggestion is more subtle, for example when countries cite fake news and online disinformation as reasons to censor content deemed politically undesirable by those in power.[5] In either case, authoritarian fears of protest and revolt have long driven such regimes to monitor their citizens. The difference today, however, is that digital technologies, like Internet packet inspection software and artificial intelligence (AI) facial recognition, are increasingly making it cheaper for dictators to do so. These technologies also make surveillance more scalable. They also reduce some of the risks caused by relying on massive networks of human spies and informants.[6] Steven Feldstein points out, for example, that the principal-agent problem, where, by empowering agents to spy and suppress, regimes empower them to act against the government, is a vulnerability that can be reduced by substituting automated surveillance technologies for human beings.[7] In turn, these technologies can heighten the speed, scale, and accuracy of authoritarian surveillance. All of this matters for US national security because promoting democracy and contesting authoritarianism is in the US national interest—and digital authoritarianism helps authoritarian regimes consolidate power. Despite the sometimes resilient nature of online social movements, quashing political organization can be easier than ever before if aided by comprehensive digital surveillance and control technologies.[8] Governments can black out communications, such as Internet servers or mobile cell towers, during revolt. They can censor troubling posts before they bubble into something bigger. They can also censor foreign-originated information that could challenge regime narratives. Most importantly, they can continuously monitor their population, including during relatively stable times, to anticipate movements that could undermine government power. In the wake of a series of revolts in the Middle East that were informed, influenced, and/or aided in part by social media and the melding of online and offline mobilization, digital authoritarians, and those striving for such ends, are using digital technologies, often dual-use, to safeguard against such threats.[9] As the Russian General Valery Gerasimov offered in 2013, “The information space opens wide asymmetrical possibilities for reducing the fighting potential of the enemy,” making it “necessary to perfect activities in the information space, including the defense of our own objects [objectives].”[10] Many of these governments like China, Russia, and Iran, are unaligned with the US on security issues. In the cyber domain, they might engage in everything from pervasive trade secret theft to cyber attacks on foreign countries’ electrical grids. In more traditional ways, they also pose national security risks through such vectors as nuclear weapons, military buildup, territorial aggression against US allies and partners, and disrupting the international order.[11] While US bilateral relationships are complex, often interconnected, and never zero-sum, elements of those relationships already pose national security risks. Likewise, other countries pursuing digital authoritarian practices may be hostile to US interests (and democratic interests more broadly) or be aligned with other powers that threaten national security. Power consolidation by these regimes poses national security risks in various dimensions. In some cases, the export and diffusion of digital surveillance tools, as part of digital authoritarianism, also pose additional national security risks, the point of focus in the next section.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.