The UN can create ethical standards that globally build trust
Fournier-Tombs ’21 (Eleonore, data scientist, researcher and author at United Nations University Institute Macau, “Towards a United Nations Internal Regulation for Artificial Intelligence, Published August 30, 2021, Accessed 7/13/2022, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/20539517211039493)
Ethical frameworks and best practices As we have seen, just like most AI initiatives developed in recent years globally, this work has happened largely without regulatory oversight. However, there have been many attempts within the organisation to set up ethical modes of operation, as well as to influence AI ethics globally. For example, OCHA's Peer Review Framework sets out a method for overseeing the technical development and implementation of AI models (OCHA, 2021b). Its objective is to provide a method for the review of models developed by humanitarian organisations by peers in the same sector, thereby providing a layer of validation that might hitherto not have existed. While there is no legal obligation for developers working with vulnerable populations to use it, it does attempt to increase accountability and transparency of models, in the hope of attenuating its risks and building trust ITU has also sought to encourage ethical uses of AI through its yearly conference entitled AI for Good, which is specifically oriented towards uses of AI that promote the Sustainable Development Goals. Several of AI for Good talks listed for 2021 address the ethics of AI use in specific cases, such as democratic participation or self-driving cars. However, the approach appears more focused on promoting implementations that drive sustainable development, rather than mitigating their possible risks (ITU, 2021). Finally, United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) has done considerable work in AI ethics, notably by convening intergovernmental meetings since 2019 to articulate a recommendation on the ethics of AI. The 2020 draft of this document focuses on values, such as transparency, gender equity, human rights and fairness, among others. While different from the European Commission's risks-based approach, this is certainly aligned with other United Nations documents, such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and the Convention on the Rights of the Child. Like the various United Nations Conventions, this document is therefore aimed at Member States, and could possibly inform the future United Nations convention on AI (UNESCO, 2020). Going a step further than the recommendation, the convention would be voluntarily ratified by Member States, who would then commit to following its principles in their own jurisdictions. Even without a convention, the United Nations would certainly have an incentive to apply internally its own recommendations to Member States. As such, the UNESCO work, along with other efforts of the ITU, OCHA and other agencies, can certainly be seen as building blocks towards a regulatory framework. However, without legal backing, they are not sufficient to ensure the safety of AI technologies as they are currently being used. Regulation to build trust in implementations In addition, the lack of AI regulation at the United Nations can be considered a barrier for agencies seeking to adopt more effective and novel technologies. While some systems, such as the OCHA-Bucky Model, which predicted COVID-19 cases in Afghanistan, Central African Republic, Democratic Republic of the Congo, South Sudan, and Sudan, have been deployed for humanitarian use (OCHA, 2021d); others appear not to have been integrated into actual decision-making systems. An example of this is the Jetson tool, which was developed by UNHCR to predict the arrival of internally displaced persons to refugee camps in Somalia (UNHCR, 2021). According to the project's public-facing website, the tool has not been updated since 2019. Several of the numerous proof-of-concept projects developed by the UN Global Pulse have also not been deployed into production (Global Pulse Lab, 2021). One of the most important difficulties in deploying these solutions is related to trust, both in terms of internal adoption of the tools by decision makers, as well as acceptance by the target populations. Trust in artificial intelligence systems is notoriously difficult to obtain, particularly in the work in which the United Nations engages, which is highly political and impacts very vulnerable populations. Some of the attempts at promoting transparency in AI, such as the OCHA Peer Review Framework, can be seen as a way to build trust. In fact, there have been other similar initiatives outside of the United Nations, such as Datasheets for Datasets (Gebru et al., 2018) and Model Cards for Model Reporting (Mitchell et al., 2019), as well as IBM's AI Factsheet, which provide tools for technical developers to explain their technologies, and therefore increase public trust in them. As explained by Aicardi et al. (2021), transparency is the most prevalent principle included in AI ethics. In the EU Guidelines on AI, which served to inform the 2021 regulation, transparency is listed as one of the ‘seven requirements in the realisation of a trustworthy AI.’ Rossi (2019) describes lack of trust as one of the key obstacles to the adoption of AI systems, regardless of the potential benefit. The onus has largely been on the technical developers of these tools, such as data scientists, computer scientists and engineers, to develop the credibility of their tools. While the United Nations has invested, and continues to invest, large amounts of money into research labs and private partnerships, unless it is able to build internal and external trust in them, it will also face important barriers in their implementation. A regulatory framework like the one proposed by the European Commission, however, especially with an authorisation procedure like the one described for high-risk activities, would take the pressure off technology developers in the humanitarian sector to individually justify their activities to decision-makers. Instead, agencies or research labs who wanted to develop an AI solution would work towards authorisation, likely quelling many internal doubts as to the effectiveness, safety and accuracy of their system. Given the powerful nature of AI, the risks of research and development initiatives and the threat of unregulated public–private partnerships, an internal, enforceable United Nations regulation on AI is highly recommended. An UN-wide AI regulation would not only protect the risks posed by the technologies to the mission itself of the organisation, but it would also build trust in those applications that are actually supporting its work. This is an opportunity to concretise the efforts of the organisation in AI ethics and best practices, as well as further demonstrate its leadership on an issue of global importance.