Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Only alternative is degrowth through socialist movements – ecosystem collapse imminent

--decoupling and recycling are insufficient

Labonté 6/14/22 [Ronald, professor at the University of Ottawa, “Ensuring Global Health Equity in a Post-pandemic Economy,” International Journal of Health Policy and Management, ocp]

Degrowth/Post-growth: Should We Build Back at All? Two common elements in many post-pandemic plans are commitments to decouple economic growth from carbon intensity, and to embrace a ‘circular economy’ in which all goods are reused or repurposed to reduce material throughput and to eliminate (or massively reduce) waste. Such measures are essential, but many environmental economists are sceptical that they are sufficient. They also allow societies to avoid confronting ‘an inconvenient truth’[1]: That capitalism’s growth imperative is predicated on ever increasing levels of material consumption. The human population already consumes annually 1.7 times the ecological resources the world can regenerate. If everyone consumed at the level of OECD countries it would require the resources of 4.7 earths,21 even before accounting for the environmental damages such consumption generates. A relatively new concept has entered the lexicon of environmental economics: degrowth[2], which captures the importance of reducing aggregate global consumption levels to avoid catastrophic ecosystem collapse. The bulk of this responsibility lies with citizens, governments, and corporate actors in the historically over-consuming Global North,32 partly to make space for those in the Global South to reach consumption levels compatible with healthy life expectancies while remaining within safe planetary limits: “…it’s abundantly clear it’s in the poorest parts of the world that income growth makes a huge difference to prosperity. Life expectancy increases. Infant mortality decreases. Maternal morbidity decreases. Participation in education increases…that’s where growth makes a difference” (T. Jackson, interview communication, October 28, 2017). Labonté 4 International Journal of Health Policy and Management, 2022, x(x), 1–5 The implications of such a transition are enormous. The burden of change rests heaviest on the world’s wealthiest regardless of which country they may live in. Their carbon emissions and consumption levels massively exceed those of the majority of the world’s population, indicative of the link between rising economic inequality and environmental devastation.33 But a degrowth (or ‘fair growth’) economy will demand substantial change for hundreds of millions, and although: “…degrowth is the only alternative at this point in time, there will need to be political and social psychological transformations from societies that have been weaned on overconsumption. I will not underestimate this cost [since] we’re talking about transformations in the way that we have structured our lives” (W. Bello, interview communication, October 27, 2021). Others describe this as transitioning to a post-growth economy, one in which the pursuit of ‘prosperity’ replaces that of growth: “Many of our problems, both social and structural and environmental, arise from the idea that progress is about increasing productivity, the speed with which we create material goods and services, distribute them to people to buy and throw away as fast as possible, the belief that this material sense of productivity and progress is what human prosperity is really about. But what we saw through the pandemic is that health is really the meaning of prosperity. Health is the foundation for prosperity(T. Jackson, interview communication, October 28, 2017). This requires a very different economy: “…a care economy, one that enriches us as well as saving lives. It’s a lower carbon economy, with a lower footprint because it is about engagement and attention and time in the service of each other” (T. Jackson, interview communication, October 28, 2017). Such an economy is an extension of what: “…feminist economists have always talked about. There is the direct care which is looking after people… Then there’s extended care…doing things that help in adaptation to climate change…it is essential work that is being done in unpaid fashion by a significant part of the population” (J. Ghosh, interview communication, November 14, 2021).[3] Towards a Post-growth Caring Economy: Can We Challenge the Rise in Autocratic Regimes? Transforming from a consumption-based capitalism to a sustainable caring economy requires governments willing to discipline markets for public good purposes, and to initiate tax and fiscal policies that radically redistribute access to the resources people need for healthy lives. The immediate challenge to this aspirational goal is reversing the fifteen years’ worldwide decline in democratic accountability and parallel rise in authoritarian rule.34 One of the pandemic’s ironies is that even as it increased the state’s role in health and economic protection, it incentivized alt-right populism and provided opportunities for autocrats to increase their grip on power. As Walden Bello, a sociologist and economist who was interviewed for this editorial, noted: “We are in a race between the forces of the far right and progressive forces [which threaten] any sort of coordinated global action on climate” (W. Bello, interview communication, October 27, 2021). In response, Bello ran as a vice-presidential candidate in the May 2022 Philippines elections in an effort to avoid that country’s “resurgence of authoritarianism.” He did not win, but remains committed to the scale of transition needed for a survivable post-pandemic economy, one in which democratic participation must remain strong: “We can’t leave it just to the politicians. We’ve got to have civil society stepping in because if we leave it to the usual actors, we’re not going to get anywhere” (W. Bello, interview communication, October 27, 2021). Even as the space for such participation is under authoritarian attack, the importance of civil society efforts to retain and expand it is more important now than in the pre-pandemic period. We know the political economy tools that can bring us closer to what the Sustainable Development Goals describe as ‘the world we want.’ But only organized citizen demand will create the political will to adopt these tools, with recent history bringing us evidence of unwavering activism in global climate strikes, Black Lives Matter, buen vivir and peasant’s movements, and poor people’s campaigns worldwide. The post-pandemic public health imperative now is to protect and support such movements.35

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.