Baudrillard doesn’t disagree with feminism – his theories critique the lack of historical and cultural grounding within most modern feminist theory
Victoria Grace 2000, ‘Baudrillard’s Challenge: A Feminist Reading’, Routledge, London, accessed 17 July 2022, https://searchebscohostcom.proxy.lib.umich.edu/login.aspx?direct=true&db=e000xna&AN=60913&site=ehost-live&scope=site //ONHS IF
Feminist theory, discourse, action is infinitely diverse, traversed as it is by a multiplicity of positions and trajectories within constructs and experiences of identifications with numerous sources of ‘difference’, generally figured in terms of ‘politics’ in some form. The examples of contemporary western feminist theories of gender, or sexual difference, I have considered in relation to the challenges raised by Baudrillard have shown a tendency for these theories to pivot on combinations of concerns including the importance of the ‘female subject’, ‘women’s identity’, ‘women’s desire/feminine desire’, the ‘nomadic subject’, the multiplicities of ‘desiring subjects’, the notion of gender as ‘performative’, the intersection (and inextricability) of ‘gender’ with ‘other’ sources of ‘difference’ (race, culture, class, sexuality, and so on). Where there is a concern to subvert identity, all the tropes of the productive, of positivity in Baudrillard’s terms, remain firmly in place: ‘power’ understood as ‘productive’; the ‘real’ is produced and these productions are contested and resignified, re-produced; identity as self-same reappears in the guise of plurality, becoming, multiple subjects with no objects, nomadic and fluid. These concerns and foci of analysis and deconstruction are undeniably driven by an assumption of the inevitability of the economic (needs, production, value), the inevitability of the law (the bar that structures identity/ difference, subject/ object), even taking into account the attempts at deconstruction and rewriting from a position of a different ‘difference’, and of the inevitability of power. There is no seduction here. These theories unilaterally fail to engage the historically and culturally specific interweaving of the construct of the economic and the structure of representation which, in Baudrillard’s analysis, figures our ontological assumptions. Donna Haraway is a feminist theorist who departs from the constraints of some of the epistemological and ontological presuppositions critiqued by Baudrillard. Her ‘Manifesto for cyborgs’ (in Haraway 1991) shows a determination, like Baudrillard’s, to develop an analysis that is grounded culturally and historically. There are evident in Haraway’s work none of the universal questions or constructs that tend to creep into the works of those other feminist theorists discussed, in spite of their claims to support what Haraway has called ‘situated knowledges’. Nevertheless, Vicki Kirby (1997) takes Haraway to task for instituting the ‘specific’ as the binary opposite of the ‘universal’, a move Kirby questions as one potentially reinstalling ‘the cogito as the subject who only speaks for him or herself’ (1997: 161). Kirby’s interest in an ontology and epistemology that deconstruct this binary and rethink the question of ‘position’ in relation to the speaking subject is important. Haraway (1991) proposes the figure of the irreverent cyborg, a ‘creature in a post-gender world’, with whom she tracks a critical understanding of key facets structuring a world that is also postmodern. The breaching of the boundaries constructing the human is central to her inquiry. But these are boundaries that are still ‘transgressed’ (in accordance with the law). Haraway is concerned at what she views as the need to ‘resist world-wide intensification of domination that has never been so acute’ (1991: 154). This domination functions according to dynamics that are different from those confronted by a socialist feminism of an earlier era; the question of ‘political struggle’ remains, however, itself unquestioned by Haraway. A reading of Baudrillard throws the whole notion of the ‘political’, contemporarily, into question. Haraway’s cyborg manifesto recognises both the dangers (the grid of control) and the possibilities (ways out of the ‘maze of dualisms’) of the ‘New World Order’. Haraway develops a critical theorising on the situated decline in influence and potency of myths of origin (post-gender, a world without gender, without genesis, without end), of totalising epistemologies, of politics defined through immobile identities, of discourses both of unity and of contradiction. She proposes a schema of categories to distinguish the transition from what she describes as ‘the comfortable old hierarchical dominations’ to the ‘scary new networks’ which she calls ‘the informatics of domination’ (1991: 161). This chart of dual categories reflects, in idealised form, a listing characterising what we have moved from (on the left side) and what we have moved to (on the right). Haraway has no reference to Baudrillard in this work apart from the sole point of a definition of ‘simulacra’, yet her portrayal of contemporary social dynamics, and more specifically her chart, have significant resonances with Baudrillard’s analyses of hyper-reality and simulation. Indeed, at the top of Haraway’s list is ‘representation’ replaced by ‘simulation’, although the shift remains untheorised. The informatics of domination marks a world where: communications sciences and modern biologies are constructed by a common move – the translation of the world into a problem of coding, a search for a common language in which all resistance to instrumental control disappears and all heterogeneity can be submitted to disassembly, reassembly, investment, and exchange. (Haraway 1991: 164) Baudrillard’s work develops a critical theorising of precisely this phenomenon; a theorising that leads to a more cautious reflection on the possibilities for ‘political struggle’, and possibly a more nuanced questioning of the implications of a postgender world. It is noteworthy that Haraway’s chart does not include the ‘political’ on the left side, against which we might suggest ‘cool, ludic seduction’ on the right, as a simulated politics endlessly recast as yet another market niche. On the contrary, the ‘political’ appears in Haraway’s essay to assume a meta-position straddling both ‘eras’ (power as a universally applicable and non-situated concept?).