Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff’s realism and claims of sovereignty disseminates the world into the hyperreal – Trump accelerated the road into the hyperreal and the plan loses the brink. That reproduces a violent reactivation of power that ends rationality.

Paul B. Richardson (2019) Sovereignty, the Hyperreal, and “Taking Back Control”, Annals of the American Association of Geographers, 109:6, 1999-2015 https://doi.org/10.1080/24694452.2019.1587283 //ONHS IF

The sovereignty delusion is by no means restricted to Brexit as the blurring of fact and fiction, and of 2006 Richardson reality and illusion, has been accelerated in the United States with the ascendency to the presidency of reality TV star, Donald Trump (for examples beyond Brexit, see Dunn 2010; Backman 2011; Cocks 2014; Juss 2017). In our age of the hyperreal, Trump has been called a “sovereign father” for our times (Connelly 2016), a leader who has risen on the tide of a sovereignty myth. It was a myth outlined by Trump at some length during his maiden speech to the United Nations General Assembly in September 2017 in which sovereignty dominated and defined his address, with the words sovereign and sovereignty mentioned twenty-one times (Tatar 2017). In the speech, Trump repeatedly equated sovereignty with global harmony, declaring, “Our success depends on a coalition of strong and independent nations that embrace their sovereignty, to promote security, prosperity, and peace, for themselves and for the world” (Haldevang 2017). He declared that “strong, sovereign nations allow individuals to flourish in the fullness of the life intended by God” (Miller 2018) and talked of a “great reawakening of nations, for the revival of their spirits, their pride, their people, and their patriotism.” That this has historically not been a recipe for “harmony and friendship” went unnoted in the speech (Chhabra 2017). In the Washington Post, Jaffe and DeYoung (2017) suggested that in his appearance at the United Nations, Trump had “cast his presidency as an avatar of international renewal,” a catalyst for a renewed patriotic spirit, national self-interest and cooperation among sovereign nations, which are posited as the solution for all international ills. Trump asked in his speech, “Are we still patriots? Do we love our nations enough to protect their sovereignty and take ownership of their future?” He also invoked sovereignty to attack the “mammoth multinational trade deals” that have supposedly empowered faceless global bureaucracies over nation-states, sent factory jobs overseas, and hollowed out the middle class (Jaffe and De Young 2017). Trump railed against the “unaccountable international tribunals and powerful global bureaucracies” that sap the sovereignty of nations (Jaffe and De Young 2017) and as a counter offered a passionate and populist defense of the principles of sovereignty and patriotism, which in his words could spark a “rebirth of devotion” across the world (Jaffe and De Young 2017). It is a devotion to a sovereign idyll and illusion through a missionary zeal anchored in the ether of hyperreality. As Nasr pointed out, Trump’s definition of sovereignty in the speech is derived “from a very narrow domestic prism” (cited in Landler 2017) out of which the United States emerges as the first among equals. It is a foreign policy doctrine that has been interpreted by some as the fusion of sovereigntism with “a style of big-power nationalism” and, in an echo of earlier presidencies, one that has been labeled by the president and his advisors as “principled realism” and “America first” (Bierman and Lauter 2017). For Patrick (2017a) it represents an invocation of sovereignty to “assert universal truths and to deflect messy realities.” Patrick suggested that Trump’s speech should be seen as part of a broader “sovereigntist” critique of the global order, which has been evident in policy stances from leaving the Paris Climate Agreement, to renouncing the Trans-Pacific Partnership, and the criticism of alliances like NATO, through to threats to ignore the World Trade Organization, and moratoriums on any new multilateral treaties (Patrick 2017b). It is in Trump’s sovereigntist agenda that we glimpse a mourning for the waning of U.S. hegemony in the face of “messy realities,” a lament for the absence of power, which “for some time now produces nothing but signs of its resemblance …; an obsession with its death; an obsession with its survival which becomes greater the more it disappears” (Baudrillard [1981] 1988, 180). Baudrillard ([1981] 1988) wrote of a “[m]elancholy for societies without power,” whereby “power is no longer present except to conceal that there is none” (180–81). It is out of this melancholy for power, and a rage against its loss, that the sovereigntist agenda can materialize in ever more disturbing ways. One such moment occurred on 4 April 2018, with the release of a memo by Trump titled, “Securing the Southern Border of the United States,” in which National Guard troops were ordered to the U.S.–Mexico border in response to a “caravan” of refugees traveling to the United States from Central America (Jacobs 2018). The first paragraph sets the scene of a sovereignty principle in crisis: 1) The security of the United States is imperiled by a drastic surge of illegal activity on the southern border. Large quantities of fentanyl, other opioids, and other dangerous and illicit drugs are flowing across our southern border and into our country at unprecedented levels, destroying the lives of our families and loved ones. … Deadly transnational gangs are systematically exploiting Sovereignty, the Hyperreal, and “Taking Back Control” 2007 our unsecured southern border to enter our country and develop operational capacity in American communities throughout the country. The anticipated rapid rise in illegal crossings as we head into the spring and summer months threatens to overwhelm our Nation’s law enforcement capacities. (Trump 2018, italics added) The memo stresses a border regime where the ability to ensure the sovereignty of the nation is in doubt (see Miller [2018] on Trump’s preference for the term nation), with it suggesting that “our American way of life hinges on our ability as a Nation to adequately and effectively enforce our laws and protect our borders. A key and undeniable attribute of a sovereign nation is the ability to control who and what enters its territory” (Trump 2018). Throughout the memo a sovereignty principle in crisis is invoked, with paragraphs 4 and 5 warning, “The lawlessness that continues at our southern border is fundamentally incompatible with the safety, security, and sovereignty of the American people. … the highest sovereign duty of the President is to defend this Nation, which includes the defense of our borders” (Trump 2018). The memo’s unsubtle generation of an existential threat to “our American way of life” works to regenerate the sovereign nation; it strives to revive a moribund “moral and political principle … in distress” (Baudrillard [1981] 1988, 172–73). From it emerges a pure and perfect U.S. sovereignty that contrasts with the disorder and chaos beyond, “a simulated real, which henceforth supplants the real and is its final solution, a virtual universe from which everything dangerous and negative has been expelled” (Baudrillard 2004). To maintain the illusion of sovereign perfection, in June 2018 children of asylum seekers were separated from their parents at the U.S. border, as Trump declared, “The United States will not be a migrant camp … You look at what’s happening in other places—we can’t allow that to happen to the United States. Not on my watch” (Gambino and Lartey 2018). In the simulated sovereignty of Trump’s America First, the “circulation of hyperreal signs of his ability and often his ability alone … deliver what he defines as truly in the US national interest” (Weber 2017, S-137, italics added; on Trump scripting himself as the superhero, see Dittmer 2018). In one sense, Trump is a continuation of U.S. presidents since Ronald Reagan who have each told us “a meta-theoretical story about Baudrillardian sign theory where presidents … mark different moments of the simulacrum” (Rubenstein 2008, 11). For example, on George W. Bush’s presidency, Suskind (2004) outlined a faith-based administration with a disdain for “the reality-based community.” A senior advisor to Bush at the time, stated to Suskind: “We’re an empire now, and when we act, we create our own reality. And while you’re studying that reality—judiciously, as you will—we’ll act again, creating other new realities, which you can study too, and that’s how things will sort out.” Suskind described a presidency of “unflinching confidence [that] has an almost mystical power. It can all but create reality.” 3 Trump is also a continuation and confirmation of the practice of “statecraft as mancraft” (Weber 2016, 4; see also Ashley 1989), whereby the sovereign foundation of the modern state is presented as a “phantastical yet presumed-to-be-factual ‘sovereign man’—as if it were the singular, preexisting, ahistorical ground that authorizes all sovereign decisions in its political community” (Weber 2016, 4–5). Applied to our own phantastical times, Trump as sovereign man could claim on 5 April 2018—without any corroborating evidence—that in the caravan of refugees “women are raped at levels that nobody has ever seen before” (cited in Z. B. Wolf 2018). Then, in October 2018, as a group of mainly Honduran asylum seekers moved through Mexico toward the U.S. border, Trump called it an “onslaught of illegal aliens” (Darrah 2018). On 31 October he tweeted, “We will NOT let these Caravans, which are also made up of some very bad thugs and gang members, into the U.S. Our Border is sacred” (Evans 2018). In a speech at the White House on the same day, Trump added that if “they want to throw rocks at our military, our military fights back. I told them to consider it a rifle” (Weaver and Manson 2018). In such hypermasculine declarations and denunciations, a state of crisis and threat becomes the norm—a form of “banal geopolitics,” whereby crises and extreme remedy become “nothing out of the ordinary,” “routine,” “normal, taken-for-granted geopolitics” (Sidaway 2001, 606–7). These episodes also recall Brown’s interpretation of border walls and their paraphernalia and performance “as symbolic and semiotic responses to crises” (R. Jones et al. 2017, 2). For against Trump’s refrain that “a secure border is a sovereign right” (Swoyer 2016), Anderson (2018) noted in The San Diego UnionTribune that the immense efforts at securitizing the U.S.–Mexico border have had the counterfunction of 2008 Richardson jeopardizing U.S. sovereignty and human security as “[s]trong, militarized enforcement has resulted in a stronger militarized response by well-financed drug cartels and increased corruption, violence and death, but not a decrease in the flow of drugs.” Extreme violence and discipline were anticipated by Baudrillard ([1981] 1988), who noted that power threatened by simulation “risks the real, risks crisis, it gambles on remanufacturing artificial, social, economic, political stakes. This is a question of life or death for it” (180). It also becomes a question of life and death for those caught in the “collective demand for signs of power—a holy union which forms around the disappearance of power” (180). In the desert of “Making America Great Again” are the drowned of the Rio Grande and the missing of the arid U.S.–Mexico borderlands—victims of a melancholy for a society without power. While hyperreality’s scenario of power conceals the fact that the real power has disappeared (Baudrillard [1981] 1988), simulation does not exclude the violent counterconvulsions of a sovereign tormented by the ebb of its power. As Baudrillard (1983) insisted, the simulacrum of war does not make it “any less heinous for being a mere simulacrum—the flesh suffers just the same, and the dead ex-combatants count as much there as in other wars” (70, cited in Merrin 1994, 444). A condition of the hyperreal makes possible absolute sovereign authority and with it the full realization of sovereignty’s devastating foundational logic—the operation of a binary of those who are protected and those who could legitimately die (Agamben 1998). For Weber (2017), the Trump “campaign and presidency are part and parcel of earlier historical ‘experiments’—in white, Western, heteropatriarchal authoritarian leadership, in neoliberalism and the specific modalities of citizenship, governance and reason” (S-134; see also Adorno et al. 1950; Brown 2003; Bauman 2016; Connelly 2016). Weber saw Trump’s simulated form as president as akin to Badiou’s (2001) description of the function of the simulacrum under Nazism: in which a hyperreal national allegiance to the selfreferential simulacrum as heteropatriarchal leader piles specific fictions upon fictions. It does so not only to mask … the absence of the reality principle but to generate a dangerous, materializable, national fantasy that depends upon particularizing, identifying and regulating abstract allies and enemies. (74; see also Weber 2017, S-135) For Weber, Trump “opposes the ‘righteous’ to the ‘unrighteous’, who he variously named during the campaign as all or many of ‘the blacks’, ‘the gays’, ‘the Mexican rapists’ and the ‘radical Islamic terrorists’” (Weber 2017, S-136). In her polemic, Weber highlighted how simulation and dissimulation “re-code sovereignty … in the name of that particular abstract set of sovereign US subjects on whose behalf the administration (pretends to) claim(s) its authority to rule—‘righteous Americans’” (Weber 2017, S-138). In a haze of “fake news” and “alternative facts” (which are read by some as “real news”) the administration’s strategy is one “that attempts to overwhelm US democracy with … representations, simulations and dissimulations of facts and fictions, so all that remains intact is the authority of Trump and Trump as our authoritarian leader” (Weber 2017, S-137–39). These hyperreal simulations and dissimulations of sovereignty are far from intangible, unreal, or benign but effectively maintain violent exclusionary hierarchies through privileging “righteous Americans” and the elevation of “a particular people and its mode of life above those marked as alien” (Cocks 2014, 3; Weber 2017, 136). It is out of the sovereignty of the hyperreal that there emerge new terrains and possibilities for the “violent reactivation of a form of power that despairs of its rational foundations” (Baudrillard 1980, 110, cited in Kroker 1984, 58).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.