Clarifying article 5 reaffirms the newfound project of hegemonic visibility – that reifies operational warfare. 2 impacts – (i): a new form of control through warfare, and (ii): manufacturing the deaths and violence the aff seeks to prevent.
Dan Öberg (2016) War, transparency and control: the military architecture of operational warfare, Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 29:3, 1132-1149, https://doi.org/10.1080/09557571.2016.1230733 //ONHS IF
In this article I have argued for the need to examine the way warfare exerts control through discourses of transparency. In so doing I draw upon the insistence that we live in an era of ‘hegemonic visibility’ (Baudrillard 2014, 11) in which global wars are fought to extend a ‘matchless transparency’ (Virilio 2000b, 23) to the world. To analyse this, I have investigated military doctrines so as to illustrate how they render a mental and visual space and time of warfare visible through operational coding. I argue that this logic creates a military architecture characterized by an excess of Kafkaesque bureaucratic and organizational procedures in which warfare becomes a derivate of planning and modelling. At the end point of this logic we find a Weltanschauung characterized by US military operations conducted in ‘an operational environment that is ever expanding’ (AFDD 2007b, 1) where future threats are preemptively erased in real time. Such “transparent warfare” is closely connected to the “liberal way of war” as it helps to manage and mobilize visual regimes employed in and through warfare. One important point outlined in this article is the way the military architecture relies on an operational violence which cuts through political space and time and invests it as calculable, decipherable and foreseeable. The “hegemonic visibility” that Baudrillard has drawn our attention to is therefore an inherent part of the way the military architecture renders itself, the global battlefield and future political subjectivity transparent, and in doing so it helps to affirm a liberal way of life. Dillon and Reid have convincingly argued that the centre of gravity of the liberal way of war is the future itself (2009, 148). But while Dillon and Reid claim such policing centres around biopolitical stakes (particularly the discrimination of which life is worth living and which isn’t), I would argue that liberal control is also waged through the way it renders the future image of global time and space visible through operational coding. Henceforth, the targeting and erasure of future political subjectivity through hegemonic visibility play an important part in the way global liberal governance functions. Arguably, the most important impact of this technique is the way operational violence indicates a type of governing which aims to reduce space/time to a derivate of global warfare and cut it from its political potential. The form and the content of the military architecture—its excess of information coupled with the urgency to render the world transparent and control it—come together as an attempt to conduct a violent futurology which attempts to exhaust and govern the present. We are now in a position to better respond to the conundrum in the introduction of this article—that both the proponents of and those who challenge warfare invoke the need for increased transparency of the battlefield. Those who wish to see and construct the future battlefield rely on the details of its imagery in order to kill. Likewise, those who want to prevent or illustrate the unlawful nature of such attacks rely on virtual reproduction in order to know and prove that the attacks took place. However, if our contemporary world is understood to be enmeshed in an ideology of excessive visibility, the commonsensical answer “more transparency” becomes part of the problem rather than a solution. If seen accordingly, better visibility does not change the fact that control is exerted through the production of a constant demand for transparency that in turn masks the way the military architecture is founded on and enacts control through this very demand. As Chamayou has illustrated by quoting interviews with mutilated victims from drone attacks: When you ask Sadaullah, or Karim, or S. Hussein and others like them what they want, they do not say ‘transparency and accountability’. They say they want the killing to stop. They want to stop dying. They want to stop going to funerals—and being bombed even as they mourn. Transparency and accountability, for them, are abstract problems that have little to do with the concrete fact of regular, systematic death. (Chamayou 2015b, 149) Chamayou is no doubt correct in that more transparency is of little help to the victims of drone violence. However, as I have tried to illustrate in this article, it is not only the actual killings on the global battlefield but the way an ideology of transparency underlies the military supporting system which unveils warfare as a modelling and operationalization of administrative routines which manufacture such killings. If one is to challenge the way drones kill, one needs to understand the supporting system which creates a demand for the killing mechanisms. Every military “telecommuting office worker/hunter” is refracted in relation to an architecture that provides and manufactures an excess of visibility, invisible limits, illusions of choice, erasures and blind spots. This architecture creates a demand for a particular type of violence as it helps to unveil a world which is transparent, open-access, logical, measurable and always connected to the operational. This is not to say that operational warfare always works, or that the demand is always there. It is simply to say that operational warfare aims to keep the potential for violent techniques of control in place by unveiling itself as a particular kind of organizational routine. How would one challenge “transparent warfare”? If there is a “Baudrillardian” wager in relation to critiquing warfare as a means for control, it would arguably be that one needs to do so without reifying the value of transparency. Instead one should aim to ‘potentiate what is new, original, unexpected’ (Baudrillard 1990b, 148) in the military architecture itself. This article has strived to look for the potentially new in operational warfare, so as to tease out the politics of the processing and modelling of warfare. The challenge to “post-heroic” war consists in investigating the various logics of and consequences transparency has as a means for control. The novelty of this relation resides in the way warfare is not, as many tend to argue, first and foremost about a response to practical problems when conducting military operations. Rather, it is characterized by the potential to violently unveil global space (as an area of operations) and global time (as a battle rhythm) to maintain and control political becoming. It remains to be seen if it is possible to create hidden spaces and times, uncoded by operational warfare (see also Baudrillard 2014, 10), that are not conditioned by the hegemonic visibility of military architectures. In my view, to investigate and affirm such a project is a timely and important task for a future critical war studies.