An expanded US influence expands the US’ nation brand – the K is key to explore the impacts of relationships that arrive as a result of the transition of governance into the simulacra.
Kaneva, Nadia. “Simulation Nations: Nation Brands and Baudrillard’s Theory of Media.” European Journal of Cultural Studies, vol. 21, no. 5, London, England: SAGE Publications, pp. 631–48, doi:10.1177/1367549417751149. 2018 Accessed 7/20/22 //ONHS CF
I have argued that Baudrillard’s assault on the real, as he theorizes media-saturated consumer societies, contains a radical potential for the analysis of nation brands. His notion of hyperreality points to the erasure of distinctions between the nation and its simulations. As the signs of nation brands circulate through media networks, they encounter other media signs, all of which intertwine in the play of appearances and seek to seduce media audiences. At the same time, what differentiates promotional simulacra, including nation brands, from other media signs is the overtly programmatic, strategic nature of promotional messages which, by definition, aim to alter perceptions. In that sense, nation brands have become integral to what Baudrillard calls ‘strategies of the real’ in contemporary media cultures. This is the Janus-faced nature of nation brands as simulacra – they claim to simultaneously reflect and alter the reality of the nation. Baudrillard’s theory of hyperreality offers one way to explain how this seemingly impossible feat is made to look real. Furthermore, Baudrillard (2001) describes a ‘precession of simulacra’, whereby non-referential models are used to manufacture simulations that stand in for the real. Based on this argument, the ‘core idea’ of a nation-branding campaign – derived through an obligatory distillation process (Aronczyk, 2013) – serves as the model that precedes the simulation nation that is conjured up through media. This process was clearly at play in Kosovo’s branding, in Ruslana’s Eurovision act and in numerous other nation-branding exercises. Among other things, this means that the simulation nation is not bound by historical fact, although simulacra of history and antiquity abound in its media manifestations. Rather, the simulation nation is created de novo each time it appears in the flickering lights of media screens only to disappear once again as the lights go out. But if there is no way to tell apart the real from the simulated, what can be the basis of critical inquiry into the workings of nation brands and media? How can research peer through the play of appearances and what could be its task? In my view, Baudrillard’s theoretical excursions are of limited help as we tackle these questions because they have little to say about the material aspects of media industries or institutions. Although his critical project starts as a revision of Marx’s critique of political economy, his later work abandons a focus on materiality and focuses instead on ‘the image form’ that emanates from the media, that is, the simulacrum (Merrin, 2005: 155). However, more than simulacra machines, the media exist as material networks of circulation, as technological systems, as profit-driven industries and as professional and cultural institutions, governed by economic, political and technological logics. That is where critical inquiry can continue to intervene and for that we need to look beyond Baudrillard. One source of inspiration can come from Marxist critiques of commercial brands as technologies for the creation of capital (e.g. Arvidsson, 2005). Drawing on Baudrillard, global media brands such as Apple, Google and Facebook can be seen as pure simulacra. Yet, beyond their hyperreal properties, these brands have also generated tremendous amounts of capital, expropriating human desires for sociality. What, if anything, is different about nation brands in comparison to commercial brands? What kinds of profits do they generate, in what ways and to whom do these profits accrue? Andrew Wernick’s conceptualization of the commodity-sign as an object with a dual purpose can be particularly helpful as we seek to move beyond Baudrillard but to retain the value of his critique. Following Wernick, nation brands are revealed to be more than clusters of promotional signs but also ‘objects-to-be-sold’, that is, they are units of media content that are created to generate profit within a system of market exchange. Although they are typically produced with public funds, nation brands as commodity-signs generate profits primarily for private media companies and for promotional outfits (Kaneva, 2015). The justifications for and consequences of this transference of wealth need further analysis. Furthermore, the logic of commodity-signs is not limited to promotional messages but applies to other media content as well. This is illustrated by the fact that some transnational media corporations today have special sales and production teams who approach national governments with ‘package’ offers that include country-specific news content paired with promotional videos, both of which are created by the media organization (Bolin and Ståhlberg, 2015). Media practices that blur the lines between editorial and promotional content have been examined in relation to consumer brands (e.g. Einstein, 2016). However, the impact of such trends on politics and governance needs further exploration. One example of possible implications can be seen in the recent proliferation of ‘fake news’ – fabricated content, the whose main goal of which is to generate maximum attention and, therefore, maximum profit. Despite its ‘unreality’, such content has been linked to shifts in political opinions and decisions, but the scope of this influence is still poorly understood. A related line of research would entail mapping the ways in which commodity-signs enter and move through the circulatory streams of global media networks. Some interesting work on this topic already exists (e.g. Valaskivi and Sumiala, 2014), but much remains to be done. A focus on circulation needs to acknowledge that promotion transcends the boundaries of ‘campaigns’ and infiltrates all forms of media that are not identifiable as ‘advertising’ (e.g. Aronczyk and Powers, 2010; Wernick, 1991). Exposing the industrial and technological protocols of media corporations would shed new light on the ways in which capital is enmeshed in the processes of assembling or dispersing national and transnational publics. These processes have important consequences for political mobilization, for the symbolic production of nationhood and for the construction of shared social realities more broadly. The lines of inquiry I have outlined above are far from exhaustive and are limited by their particular focus on media. The materiality of nationhood – how it is experienced by individuals on a daily basis, how it is enacted in institutional and policy contexts and how it intersects with simulations of the nation – is worthy of its own exploration, but that is a task for another study. At the conclusion of this theoretical exploration, we should be wary of making totalizing claims about the triumph of hyperreality. Nevertheless, we should retain at least one insight from Baudrillard, namely, that simulation functions ‘not only as a mode of communication but also as a mode of social control’ (Merrin, 2005: 24). Despite his self-professed nihilism, Baudrillard never abandoned the goals of social critique and transformation and therein lies the main value of his work.