Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Without embracing vulnerability and a new way of thinking about the political, the postwar condition recreates nationalistic violence and hegemonic sovereign power

Väyrynen, Tarja. “Rethinking National Temporal Orders: the Subaltern Presence and Enactment of the Political.” Review of International Studies, vol. 42, no. 4, 2016, pp. 597–612., doi:10.1017/S0260210515000595. Accessed 7/22/22. //ONHS IF

Feminist IR has drawn attention to bodies such as Kaisu’s in the literature where the role of women’s corporeality in symbolising the nation and its honour is studied, particularly in times of violence and war.26 The abject figures of, for example, ‘comfort women’ who have been subjected to nationalistic violence and ‘female terrorists and torturers’ taking part themselves in violence and war have been also brought to the research agenda of feminist IR. 27 Recently, Christine Sylvester’s War as Experience: Contributions from International Relations and Feminist Analysis28 has opened up a new domain for the study of violence and war as a corporeal and a mundane phenomenon. She suggests that war should be studied as an institution whose actual mission is to injure the human body and destroy normal patterns of interaction. Due to the overtly abstract notion of war in IR starting with states, organisations, fundamentalists, security issues and weapons systems, ordinary people and their bodies are overwhelmingly absent in IR and its studies of violence and war, and consequently of postwar peace too.29 Sylvester’s view resonates with Julia Kristeva’s quest for research that seeks concrete instances of ‘women’s time’. This type of research emerges from lived experiences and, thereby, can reveal alternative temporalities not heard in mass media or politics.30 Kaisu is certainly an ordinary person and yet she does more than could be expected from the ‘ordinary’: her performance and temporality disrupt and destabilise, and as such, stand as guarantee for the reconfiguring of the space of the political. Kaisu’s speech act as such does not constitute the political contestation. Rather, the contestation comes forth through an ensemble of performance at a moment when there is an ‘opening’ in the national historiography.31 In short, she exemplifies Sylvester’s point on the importance and unexpectedness of the mundane and corporeal in relation to war and to postwar national identity politics as well as Kristeva’s notion of alternative temporalities that rupture linear ‘normal’ time. To understand the ways Kaisu has symbolically functioned as an abject who has not been ‘taken into account’ 32 and how her narrative brings an anxiety to the core of the imagined unitary postwar Finnish nation, this article derives from the psychoanalytically oriented IR that examines the nexus between war and collective identity, memory, and history.33 In this vein of thought, war and violence are seen to be a constitutive and, at the same time, traumatic event in the nation’s existence as it reveals the instability of the sovereign subject that was thought to provide security. Jenny Edkins argues that sovereign power cannot provide full security for its members. Instead, it sends individuals to their deaths in the name of the survival of the collective self. It is in this sense, that war and violence constitute a trauma in the nation’s existence: they reveal the unstable nature of sovereign power as a security provider. 34 The postwar moment that follows the war and violence is a potential moment of social disintegration, in which the cohesive power of the ideology that has created the nation’s identity as the primary security provider loses its efficiency. In Jenny Edkin’s words, this is ‘trauma time’ when nothing is certain and no decision is assured.35 In a similar vein, Peter Burgess summarises the characteristics of the national subject during this moment by arguing that ‘the subject is, … unstable, exposed, threatened and at risk’. 36 Hence, a new master narrative is needed to stabilise the identity of the sovereign power and to make the war and the collective trauma readable for the national subjects. Postwar memory work is of primary importance when the mastery of the postwar anxiety is created and its collective effects are controlled. Since the nation’s identity is rendered extremely truncated, impossible, mutilated, and antagonistic during the war, collective memory work, and particularly history writing, functions as a tool to cement a closure. National history works to secure for a contingent nation the false unity of the national subject evolving through time. According to Prasenjit Duara, ‘the subject of History is a metaphysical unity devised to address the aporias in the experience of linear time’. 37 Furthermore, as a number of scholars have pointed out, the way in which wars are remembered and war history written is fundamental to the production and reproduction of postwar sovereign political power.38 By 2010, when Kaisu told her story, the Finnish nation had largely sedimented a master narrative of its post-Second World War national history and location in world politics.39 By coincidence, in the same year postwar ‘abject history’ got some official recognition when the Prime Minister’s Office and the National Archives of Finland commissioned a study on the children of foreign soldiers in Finland. It was the first officially initiated attempt to deal with the question of children fathered by foreign soldiers, and consequently the relations between Finnish women and foreign armies. However, Kaisu’s public appearance carried more historical weight than the officially commissioned report40 that was published a year later as her performance exposed her as a living container of residual historical material whose subaltern past made visible the disjuncture with the present view of the national self.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.