Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The attachment to credible deterrence creates imperial violence and instability---sustained and predictable deterrence postures are impossible in IR, which instead becomes a justification for military interventions

Grovogui 16 – Director of the Africana Studies and Research Center at Cornell University.

Siba N. Grovogui, “Time, technology, and the imperial eye,” Time, Temporality and Violence in International Relations: (De)fatalizing the present, forging radical alternatives, 2016, 49-51,

Importantly, the predicates underlying this ideological formulation of the relationship between the West and others suggests necessity and enforcement through cooperation or confrontation. In either case, the contemporaneous Western language of geopolitics has provided pre-ordained answers: redress through treaty enforcement, wars of attrition, and enforcement through military interventions. As a result, from the discovery of the New World through the slave trade and colonialism and decolonization, the relations between, on the one hand, continental Europe states and European entities dispersed through the world and, on the other, political and cultural entities elsewhere have been mediated by a language of command unilaterally directed at others: the assumption of the sovereign right to defend the ‘national interest’ and unidirectional extra-territoriality.

There is no standard of violence in this context other than that deemed necessary or sufficient by those with the sovereign right to intervene. Hence, it is almost an article of faith that anyone disrupting the prescribed order must pay in discomfort (military coercion), materials (expropriation under occupation), and sovereignty (stripping local sovereignties of the essential dimensions of sovereignty allowable to the hegemon).

This predetermination of the terms of the relationships between Europe and others has necessarily prescribed a commensurate commitment to the requisite technologies of intervention. One need not endorse Vijay Prashad’s The Darker Nations (2008) to concur with him that European violence in non-European empires has been deliberately wedded to the ideology of pre-ordainment: if no longer the path of God, it is still the path of reason and pragmatism. In any case, to reprise an earlier statement, the idea that the West has a right of intervention is given, as is the determination to intervene. Related without dispute are the following: by faith or reason (or today’s rule of law), Europe is responsible for those who might be outside it; the West is answerable for, and by right concerned with, what happens all over the globe; the West will generate (when necessary in consultation with others) the principles, norms, and symbols of communications through which assurances are given to the self and others; the West alone determines the values or standards by which conformity with and transgressions of its proclaimed universal values are measured.

‘Just’ use of violence in this context is measured by its propriety as technique, coterminous with an imperial desire, to bring pagans, miscreants, and other metaphorically fallen entities back into the fold. This can only be done through intervention by self-professed masters of the universe to protect themselves and their pre-ordained destiny as inheritors of the Kingdom, dispense with illegitimate sovereigns who endanger the Kingdom, and conquer and subordinate (once in God’s name and now by reason) heathens and other ‘unknowing’ sinners for their redemption. This outlook remains central to modern empires and is a key structuring event of international relations [IR]., morality, and existence.

Time, consciousness, affectivity, and law

The right to intervene has ideational, constitutional, and institutional requirements. These operate mostly in the domestic realm when life decisions are made, particularly in security, access of resources, and their production, distribution, and consumption. In these latter instances, questions of the constitution and institutions such as the state are not merely standards for determining the propriety of conduct of national officialdom or measures of the satisfaction of citizens with the nature of their relationships with the state. Appreciation of the law, morality, and ethics appears in the national context differently than in IR where clarification is demanded in the relationships between self and others, between the freedom and security of nationals and of other nationals, between the security of one state and other states. The responses to these demands depend on intangibles and tangibles. The intangibles include psychic dispositions (toward fear, for instance), psychological factors (pertaining to, say, consciousness or awareness, feeling, and motivation) and symbolic resources (intellectual assets, knowledges). Together, these define the sense individuals and collectives have of the physical and moral landscape of international relations. By landscape, I mean not only regions and the mechanisms and institutions connecting them but also the flows and dynamics traversing them. The natural corporeal and non-corporeal endowments providing access to this landscape do so through the senses and are expressed through the faculty by which the body perceives external entities.

From the prior formulation, two kinds of sense are implicated into one another. The first is an historical sense (or appreciation) of the operation of the senses (or faculties) on its objects. This is determined by the psychology and other sciences of the brain. The second is a sense producing the faculties that is itself the product of their operations. One such product is consciousness, also a faculty. Each influences the other (Jay 2011). It is often assumed consciousness is formed through the interactions of fundamental entities: time, space, and matter. Each entity has unique properties, but all are intricately connected in the manners in which knowledge operates, previously by psychology and now by neuroscience and psychophysics.

To be precise, the relation relevant to me is not one implicated in the physicality of space-time or time-space. Rather, it is phenomenological – that is, the manners in which time-space relations are experienced in concrete circumstances. In this context, consciousness manifests itself as a factor of appreciation of time and space and as a means to integrate the dynamics and flows of time and within space. Consciousness is not the sum of all knowledges available to the individual mind as it synthesizes the landscape of social relations, regional connections, and human activities in conjunction with temporal and cultural understandings of the requirement of life for self and others. What is it then?

International relations does not depend on either constitutional self-understandings by states or observances of international legal stipulations on global coexistence. Rather, the existing constitutional and legal dispositions are augmented by temporal factors, including the imperial drive to conquer and colonize any related spatial affects. Whether these may be called national cultures or not, spatially defined entities historically internalize feelings toward self and others that leave significant impressions on the mind, shaping reflexes and moving intellect and body at the time of decision. These affects, the way they shape responses, and the extent to which they characterize actions can be filed under the rubric of affectivity.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.