Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

1---Complexity means realism is wrong

Little et al. 15 – Adrian, Professor of Political Theory and has been Head of the School of Social and Political Sciences since 2007; Alan Finlayson, Professor of Political and Social Theory at The University of East Anglia in the United Kingdom; Simon Tormey, political theorist based in the School of Social and Political Sciences, 2015 (“Reconstituting Realism: Feasibility, Utopia and Epistemological Imperfection,” Contemporary Political Theory (Vol. 14, 3, 276–313), August 2015, Available Online to Subscribing Institutions via Palgrave Macmillian)

There is a growing literature on complexity theory that has fundamental implications for how we think about the real in social and political terms (Cilliers, 1998; Richards, 2002; Urry, 2003; Harrison, 2006; Geyer and Rihani, 2010). Borrowing from its origins in the natural sciences (specifically the work of Nobel Prize winning chemist, Ilya Prigogine), complexity focuses on the chaotic blend of the orderly and disorderly in social and political life. This implies that phenomena cannot be properly understood through experimentation in controlled environments such as the laboratory. Instead, complex environments are much more dynamic with a plurality of actors engaging with phenomena in a multiplicity of different ways and generating effects that are unknown to each other.

Complexity in the social sciences suggests that the issues we engage with are in a constant process of development rather than being static entities – ‘facts’ – that just have to be acted upon. Moreover, the effects of political action are not linear, given that multiple other parties are acting on the same issue simultaneously. Thus, action on an issue with a specific outcome in mind does not guarantee that intended result as the actions and behaviours of other interested parties may interrupt the linearity of action and outcome. For this reason, the actual nature of things is dynamic and always in a stage of complex temporal development so that a snapshot of what reality actually entails can only be momentary (Connolly, 2010, pp. 17–42).

Complexity theory also suggests that the complicated interaction of a plurality of actors on social phenomena will always generate emergent properties that we may not fully comprehend. Part of the reason for this epistemological slippage is that we are largely beholden to established modes of understanding to make sense of the things we encounter. This path dependence can limit the horizons of possibility and bind us to particular methodologies for looking at specific issues. When it comes to social issues, political actors are always playing catch-up as they try to maintain traditional modes of understanding and action as a means of dealing with emerging problems. Ultimately, in terms of dealing with emerging complexities, it may actually be politically advantageous to relinquish path dependent modes of behaviour to develop new approaches to the fresh problems that we encounter.

On this account, the poverty of traditional forms of realism is clear because they rely on depicting the obvious ‘facts’ as the real. This ties us into existing understandings of what are often emerging issues and implies that we should rely on path dependent technologies inherited from the past to deal with things that might require fresh thinking. The epistemological blind spots of ‘fact-derived realism’ in complex environments imply that a more realistic politics might emphasize the sheer unknowability of all relevant phenomena when it comes to policy making in a simultaneously orderly and disorderly complex environment (Little, 2012). From this perspective, systems are always struggling reactively to contain issues that are constantly changing and evolving in relation to a multiplicity of actors engaging with them. In short, this complex temporality engenders an epistemological gap that undermines the claims of ‘fact-derived realism’ to a patent on what is actually real and challenges the methodological assumptions on which these theories are based.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.