Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Epistemology shapes the “real world”---trying to disentangle the two creates bad policies

Little et al. 15 – Adrian, Professor of Political Theory and has been Head of the School of Social and Political Sciences since 2007; Alan Finlayson, Professor of Political and Social Theory at The University of East Anglia in the United Kingdom; Simon Tormey, political theorist based in the School of Social and Political Sciences, 2015 (“Reconstituting Realism: Feasibility, Utopia and Epistemological Imperfection,” Contemporary Political Theory (Vol. 14, 3, 276–313), August 2015, Available Online to Subscribing Institutions via Palgrave Macmillian)

In arguing for a process of reconstituting our understanding of realism in politics, this contribution seeks to break down some established understandings of the terms of political theory and ‘real politics’. It argues that political theory should be politically engaged, that the reason that it is political theory rather than ethics is precisely because it has implications for how the world is organized and raises action-based questions of how to achieve objectives. The challenge here is not only that political theorists need to think about the application of their work, but also that we need to think more clearly about what constitutes the ‘real world’ of politics to which it is applied. To unnecessarily distance the two, is an easy trap to fall into. For example, while Swift and White (2008) argue that political theory has a vital role to play in practical issues, they still differentiate theory from a real politics, which is depicted as the things politicians do and the strategies they employ to gain election.

While this activity is undoubtedly part of real politics, it does not entirely constitute what is real. In short, far too many political theorists readily accept an intuitive version of the ‘real’ without sufficient interrogation of that reality and the sometimes flimsy epistemological interpretations underpinning it. By failing to address the epistemological foundations of what constitutes ‘real politics’, commentators such as Swift and White – despite their arguments for political theorists to make modest contributions to real politics – actually reinforce an artificial divide between political theory and real politics. Thus, at the same time as Swift and White recognize that political theorists need to be more engaged with practical issues, their division between the two encourages a culture in which non-engagement is viewed as a sustainable position for theory. This provides an opportunity for realists to avoid serious challenge to what they consider to be real (Geuss, 2008, pp. 59–60)

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.