Moniz & Nunn 18
Ernest Sam Ernest Moniz, the former US secretary of energy, and Sam Nunn, a former US senator, are co-chairmen of the Nuclear Threat Initiative. “Cyber attacks and rising risks of an accidental nuclear war” 02-03-2018. https://www.straitstimes.com/opinion/cyber-attacks-and-rising-risks-of-an-accidental-nuclear-war
The world has crossed over to a new nuclear era in which a fateful error, rather than intentional aggression, is the most likely catalyst to nuclear catastrophe. American leaders have been warned more than once of incoming Russian missiles - in each case, it was a false alarm resulting from technical or human error. Former Russian president Boris Yeltsin was mistakenly alerted to a possible United States missile strike after the launch of a Norwegian scientific rocket. After every incident, we deceive ourselves that we can solve the problem with better technology and training, or we reassure ourselves that the combination of diligence and good luck we experienced during the Cold War will continue. But do we really believe we can prevent a nuclear catastrophe indefinitely in a world that has nine states with nuclear weapons and significant suspicion and hostility in many of their mutual relationships? The risks of human error involving nuclear weapons are compounded by the potential for deliberate cyberthreats to warning and command-and-control systems. Hackers could insert a false warning of a nuclear attack into national warning and alert systems and falsely attribute that attack to an innocent country. At a time of heightened global tensions, with too little communication or cooperation between nuclear rivals and only minutes of decision time, how would leaders of states with nuclear weapons respond? The Trump administration recently declared plans to broaden the role of nuclear weapons in national defences beyond deterring nuclear attacks on the United States and its allies. Its new National Security Strategy states that the arsenal is now "essential" to preventing not just a nuclear attack but also "non-nuclear strategic attacks, and large-scale conventional aggression". A leaked draft of its forthcoming Nuclear Posture Review has similar language. Expanding the range of threats against which nuclear weapons might be used - which implies, for example, "strategic" cyber attacks - will greatly increase the risks of miscalculation or blunder. If a cyber attack took out a major part of our electrical grid, would we be able to quickly and confidently identify the attacking country? If Russia, China, India, Pakistan and others adopt similar policies, are we moving down a path where nuclear use becomes highly probable? Every country with nuclear weapons perceives its geopolitical circumstances differently, but we all face substantially increasing nuclear risks. Every country with nuclear weapons perceives its geopolitical circumstances differently, but we all face substantially increasing nuclear risks. Individually, where necessary, and together where possible, they must move with urgency on policies that can reduce these risks for all nations.