Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

China victory in AI risk overturning unipolarity – AI is the KEY internal link between unipolarity and multipolarity. That EXPANDS the risk international competition and instability.

Sullivan 10/4/2021

Ryan Sullivan Army pilot studied at the prestigious Fudan University in Shanghai, China, as an Olmsted Scholar graduate-level work in the field of Artificial Intelligence to deliver an in-depth study of the critical elements of U.S.-China competition in Artificial Intelligence, “The U.S., China, and Artificial Intelligence Competition Factors”, – ECM

Henry Kissinger once wrote that “the stability of any international system ultimately relies on what he termed ‘generally accepted legitimacy.”371 Any international framework needs buy-in from the powers within it”, and the U.S. must play a central role in shaping the AI world order.372 This chapter focuses on AI competition between the U.S. and China for legitimacy to lead efforts “conforming to recognized principles or accepted rules and standards.”373 The international contest over global leadership occurs when China’s rise challenges U.S. hegemony in a liberal world order created without participation from the CCP. AI and other emerging technologies will disrupt traditional measures of power. While the U.S. and China will remain the strongest poles, the emerging world order will be more multipolar than bipolar in design, as AI enables regional powers to seek greater input over norms and standards.374 China perceives and desires multipolarity to limit U.S. power and influence to the degree that the U.S.’s preferred values and political institutions are not dictated to others. While some rush to make comparisons to the Cold War or the space race, a CNAS report suggests that “competition in the AI arena could be even more intense. The space race was fundamentally a bipolar competition – a subset of the broader Cold War... Competition in AI, on the other hand, may be much more intense because it will be much more multipolar and multisector.”375 This chapter focuses on AI competition in an increasingly multipolar world structure where values and influence with rising middle powers and developing nations “lend authority or respectability” to a nation’s leadership position on AI.376 However, for China, there is a domestic element of legitimacy competition related to Sino-American values competition in the first chapter of this monograph. For China, legitimacy also addresses the CCP’s concern over maintaining domestic legitimacy as the sole power in a single-party system. The CCP’s domestic problems reflect legitimacy in terms of “popular acceptance of a government, political regime or system of governance.”377 This definition highlights an area where competition over legitimacy and values overlap and should be understood by readers when viewing China’s actions in the global setting. There are two audiences for the CCP, the international community, and its domestic base, who want to see an emergent China take on a larger leadership role.

This global leadership focus aligns with one of the NSCAI’s National Technology Strategy’s key pillars, which calls for the U.S. to lead a “favorable international AI order.”378 China views actions over norms and standards as those of a technological hegemon. Fudan’s Cai Cuihong believes that the U.S.’ excessive pursuit of technological hegemony will result in a weakened superpower that cannot effectively compete, disrupted global markets and supply chains, a loss of “trust and soft power as a source of legitimacy,” and weakened efforts to form technical alliances of support.379 Written in 2019, Cai’s article addresses many of the emerging challenges that face both the U.S. and China, and she claims that China will never pursue technological hegemony. Nevertheless, leadership in developing AI norms, rules, and strategies for the new world order is more likely to occur in a multiparticipant setting where the U.S. and China lead factions but must rely on the support of other nations to achieved desired ends. As the CSG points out, “The successful adoption of AI in adjacent fields and technologies will drive economies, shape societies, and determine which states exert influence and exercise power in the world. Many countries have national AI strategies. However, only the United States and China have the resources, commercial might, talent pool, and innovation ecosystem to lead the world in AI.”380 AI will serve as a great enabler, and this paper aligns with the CSG in putting forth the argument that AI will emerge as a tool for other states to have a voice and punch above their weight in both regional and global settings. Influencing those nations and relying on a shared values approach is essential for the U.S. to gain a competitive edge over China.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.